Point of view and audience knowledge in Kubrick

Following someone throughout a film does not guarantee access to all their thoughts or to every action that affects them. Point of view organises proximity and information, but does not require the audience to accept the character’s explanations.

Lolita: Humbert’s version doesn’t exhaust what the film shows

Humbert occupies a central position in Lolita’s story and has a narrative role that shapes the information available. That centrality does not make every image a literal transcription of his consciousness. Other people act, respond and resist within the frame. The audience can hear his explanation and observe clues that create distance from it, without another voice necessarily appearing to correct him.

The study of Dolores and the limits of what Humbert lets us know examines a specific inequality. The narrative does not give both characters equal verbal space to present their experience. This asymmetry should be analysed, not reproduced as if a person’s silence meant they had no interests of their own. A brief response or an action can carry weight even without accompanying internal commentary.

It is useful to distinguish perception from knowledge. Humbert may be present in a scene without correctly understanding what is happening; the audience may recognise a connection based on information received earlier. Following his movements does not require sharing his interpretation. The film creates a physical and temporal proximity that allows us, precisely, to observe the limits of his reading.

The narrators and voice-over raise a related but more specific question: who is telling the story, and from what position? Point of view also includes what can be shown when no one explains it. An interested voice and a camera that preserves other people’s reactions create a complex relationship; there is no need to declare that one contains all the lies and the other all the truth.

The Shining: perceiving a threat is not the same as being able to explain it

Danny receives images and impressions that he does not share in the same way with those around him. The film makes some of this experience accessible to the audience, but does not always provide an immediate explanation of its origin or timing. Seeing a clue does not mean knowing whether it refers to something that happened, a possibility or a current presence. Perception can precede understanding.

The connection between Danny, Tony and the shining requires attention to specific clues. The narrative comparison need not settle on an all-encompassing theory of the gift here. What matters is that the boy has a connection to certain images that the adults do not share, and that this difference does not automatically give him the authority to convince them. Knowledge, language and social recognition do not necessarily progress together.

The film also lets us follow Wendy and Jack in situations where Danny is not present. This movement prevents the entire story from being reduced to a single consciousness. Each character has access to different fragments of the hotel and of the others’ behaviour. The audience can piece them together, though doing so does not fully resolve the relationships between memory, apparition and event.

The distribution of information changes the nature of the threat. We can worry about someone who is unaware of behaviour shown in another scene, or share their uncertainty when they enter a space without enough preparation. These experiences require different narrative choices. The camera does not have to literally adopt their eyes to bring us closer to their vulnerability; it only needs to limit or expand access to what might affect them.

Eyes Wide Shut: following a journey while retaining its inaccessible areas

For much of its running time, Eyes Wide Shut follows Bill’s movements. The audience encounters places and people through his meetings, but is not given an independent investigation to confirm every account he hears. The study of Bill, his jealousy and his social position allows us to examine what he assumes when entering a situation. Proximity to the character also preserves the limits of his access.

Images associated with his imagination should not automatically be confused with records of events that have taken place. A representation can make visible what troubles him without certifying it as an external event. To distinguish between levels, we need to consider how the image is introduced, what information precedes it and how the film returns to the action. The intensity of a vision is not proof of its factual status.

Other characters’ explanations offer versions, not an omniscient perspective simply because they sound convincing. Bill may accept or dispute what he hears, or be affected by it; the audience must assess the extent of that information. The story preserves distinctions between witnessing something, imagining it and receiving someone’s account. A verbal conclusion does not necessarily collapse these categories into one.

The temporal structure can reinforce this uncertainty when later information changes how we read an earlier encounter. However, changing our understanding does not always change the event shown. The new information may be a proposed cause, an identity or a possible consequence. An interpretation should indicate which part comes from the image and which from an explanation a character offers later.

In these three films, point of view does not mean moral approval either. Proximity lets us understand mechanisms of self-justification, fear or desire without turning them into criteria for analysis. It is more precise to ask who perceives, who tells the story, who knows and who can make others believe them. The answers may belong to different people and change from one scene to the next.

Films analysed: Stanley Kubrick, Lolita (1962); The Shining (1980); Eyes Wide Shut (1999).

View all articles in Narrative, Screenplay and Adaptation in Kubrick