Danny Torrance, Bryan Lyndon and Helena Harford do not serve the same narrative function. Comparing them requires distinguishing what they perceive, what they can communicate and how much their safety depends on decisions made by other people.
Danny: perceiving more does not remove dependence
The Shining gives Danny a unique access to what is happening in the hotel. His visions and his communication with Hallorann expose him to information the other characters do not possess in the same way. The film does not present him simply as someone who needs adults to explain things to him. In several scenes, the problem is precisely that the child perceives something for which the available answers are inadequate.
That knowledge does not bring complete autonomy. Danny still depends on transport, care and decisions made within his family. He can recognise a threat without having the means to get away from it immediately. The analysis of Danny, Tony and the gift of the shining distinguishes the forms that perception takes. Here, what matters is its relationship to dependence: knowing more in a particular situation is not the same as controlling the material conditions in which he finds himself.
Hallorann listens to Danny differently from the way others do in their conversations. He recognises a shared experience and passes on warnings. Their relationship means the child is no longer completely alone with what he perceives, although that recognition does not make Hallorann a constant presence. Help comes through communication that must overcome distance and obstacles; it does not guarantee immediately that nothing can happen to him.
Danny’s ability to observe and act has consequences without turning him into a shrunken adult. His movements, silences and decisions belong to a character with limited but not nonexistent resources. The film allows us to recognise both a child’s initiative and the need to protect him. Reducing him to a figure of passive innocence would erase visible actions; treating him as fully self-sufficient would erase the conditions that make those actions difficult.
Bryan: adult affection does not make the world safe
In Barry Lyndon, Bryan is surrounded by a level of attention that contrasts with other relationships in the household. Barry can be tender and indulgent towards him while maintaining a severe conflict with Bullingdon. The child allows us to observe a particular kind of affection, not to prove that all paternal roles are fulfilled in the same way. The distribution of affection depends on the place each child occupies within a family structure that predates their own decisions.
The desire to ride a horse brings enthusiasm, a gift and limits imposed by adults into relation with one another. Bryan does not control the material conditions that make this desire possible. He receives an object of attention, as well as instructions about how to use it. The tragedy should not be simplified into a lesson that blames the child for wanting something: the film shows an environment of expectations and care whose ability to protect has its limits.
After the accident, the child temporarily changes the relationships of those around him. His vulnerability forces the adults to address him differently and makes their confrontations lose immediate priority. In the Bryan’s episode and the family’s breakdown, affection becomes visible through presence, words and gestures. That attention can be sincere without being able to prevent what is happening.
The depiction of death examines the adults’ preparation and reactions; from the perspective of childhood, what matters is that Bryan is not reduced to the effect his loss will have on others. Before serving that dramatic function, he is a character who wants things, listens and takes part in relationships. The scene’s emotion also depends on having recognised these small actions, not merely on assigning childhood a general idea of fragility.
Helena: sharing domestic life without knowing the whole story
Eyes Wide Shut presents Helena as Bill and Alice’s daughter, not as part of a group of siblings. Her presence establishes obligations and routines in a home whose central conflict belongs to the adults. Shared activities continue as her parents’ relationship changes. The girl can be close to those living through this crisis without the film giving her access to their conversations, fantasies or nighttime experiences.
This limit on information also shapes the viewer’s position. We know things about Bill and Alice that Helena has no reason to know. Her behaviour should not be interpreted as a conscious response to every event we have seen. This difference guards against over-attribution: a child’s gesture can belong to the immediate activity of a scene without functioning as a secret comment on the marriage.
In the toy shop, Helena’s interests and her parents’ conversation share the same space, but not necessarily their attention. The adults try to work out what they will do next while accompanying a family activity. The ending of Eyes Wide Shut examines this coexistence. The presence of other shoppers or the girl moving away does not, by itself, justify claiming that she is abducted or assigning her a fate the film does not depict.
Danny encounters a danger others do not understand; Bryan receives a level of protection that is not enough; Helena remains partly outside the knowledge of the adults’ crisis. The forms of family authority and care explain these differences better than a single symbol of childhood. Each character has a particular combination of information, initiative and dependence. Paying attention to that combination makes it possible to describe what the child does in the story without diagnosing them or using them as an automatic explanation of the director’s intentions.
References: Stanley Kubrick, Barry Lyndon (1975), The Shining (1980) and Eyes Wide Shut (1999). The names and relationships correspond to the characters in the films.
View all articles in Themes and conflicts in Kubrick’s cinema
