Obeying and disobeying in Kubrick

An order can come with recognised authority and demand an action that contradicts the judgement of the person receiving it. Kubrick presents this conflict in different situations: an offensive, a nuclear chain of command and a platoon trying to survive.

Paths of Glory: an order cannot make its objective achievable

In Paths of Glory, the offensive against an enemy position pits the will of the commanders against the conditions the soldiers encounter. The distance between giving an order and carrying it out is no abstraction. Those who must advance are exposed to fire and do not have the same options as those who make decisions elsewhere. Assessing conduct requires taking into account how danger, information and the practical ability to move are distributed.

Dax takes part in the operation and later tries to defend the men accused. His actions do not amount to a complete withdrawal from the institution. He uses a recognised role within it to challenge the interpretation of what happened. The duty and defence in Dax's character allow us to examine this tension: maintaining a responsibility towards his subordinates can lead him to confront his superiors while still accepting his own obligations.

The order to fire on their own positions introduces a particularly clear limit. The demand for written confirmation interrupts automatic execution and makes the commander's responsibility something that must be recorded. Asking for a document does not remove the risk of disobeying, but it changes the terms of the discussion. The voice giving the order is no longer enough: the person issuing it must be able to answer for the action they demand.

The subsequent procedure also distributes responsibility. A tribunal can make a political decision look like an individual assessment. The accused men's subordination, by itself, does not explain what they could have done or why they were selected. The film forces us to distinguish between impossibility, refusal and failure. Bringing all three situations under the same accusation allows the superiors to avoid questions about how the operation was designed and about their own decisions.

Dr. Strangelove: discipline can protect an action that no-one can manage to stop

Dr. Strangelove changes the problem through an organisation designed to ensure that instructions are carried out even when communications are difficult. This preparation is intended to protect a capacity to respond. Within the story, however, confidence in the procedures allows a destructive initiative to continue while other authorities try to cancel it. The local effectiveness of each step can conflict with the broader need to stop the chain of events.

The bomber crew interprets its instructions within this system. Its members solve problems and keep the mission going, but the audience has information they do not share. Observing their technical competence does not require us to celebrate the outcome. The film separates the care with which a task is carried out from the validity of the purpose behind it. Carrying out an operation well does not yet answer the question of whether it should be done.

Mandrake represents a different relationship with orders. He recognises that Ripper's explanations do not amount to a reliable assessment of the situation and looks for a way out. His rank, his proximity to the general and his ability to reason do not give him enough control. The study of Mandrake and his limited authority shows how courtesy and argument can keep a conversation open without persuading the armed man to abandon his decision.

The difficulties continue when other military personnel arrive with their own framework for interpreting events. An urgent request can seem suspicious if it does not fit the mission each person believes they are carrying out. The problem is not that all rules are useless. It is that a rule needs channels for review and recognition of exceptions. Without them, protecting the procedure can block precisely the information that would help prevent its consequences.

Full Metal Jacket: the group learns to respond before facing uncertainty

The training in Full Metal Jacket makes coordinated responses a daily activity. The voices, movements and repetition make the relationship between order and reaction tangible. Discipline promises to turn different individuals into a body capable of acting together. This transformation includes mutual dependence: one person's mistake affects the others and can change how the group treats someone who cannot keep up.

Collective punishment shows that obedience and responsibility are not distributed simply. The recruits learn the consequences of failing, but are also encouraged to watch and correct their fellow recruit. When that pressure turns into aggression, it is not enough to point to the instructor as the sole cause or to absolve the participants because they are subordinates. The film shows specific actions carried out within a structure that encourages them and gives them meaning.

In combat, decisions do not always find an immediate answer in prior training. Helping a wounded person, holding a position or advancing involves risks to others. Orders can compete with bonds of loyalty and with partial assessments of danger. The trajectory of Joker as observer and participant allows us to follow this loss of distance: commenting on an institution from within does not mean you can avoid having to act when a situation arises that cannot be dealt with by commentary alone.

The comparison does not require us to settle here the debate about free will and conditioning. It examines something more specific: how much room a person has to manoeuvre when given a particular instruction. Their information, the means available to them, the possibility of objecting and the foreseeable consequences all matter. The three films show that obeying can involve initiative and that disobeying does not guarantee a just response. Responsibility must be examined in the decisions actually made, without treating rank as either an absolution or a complete explanation.

Films discussed: Stanley Kubrick, Paths of Glory (1957); Dr. Strangelove (1964); Full Metal Jacket (1987). Sources: American Film Institute, AFI Catalog, Paths of Glory (1957) entry, synopsis and credits.

View all articles in Themes and conflicts in Kubrick’s cinema