Scorsese on Kubrick: framing, camera movement and storytelling

Scorsese described a specific practice: returning to Kubrick’s films to study how one shot led to the next. His recollection invites us to ask what a camera does, beyond simply recognizing its movement.

Framing determines which relationships can be seen

In a 2001 interview with Charlie Rose, cited by DGA Quarterly, Scorsese recalled studying Kubrick’s films in theatres and taking notes. He singled out the journeys through the trenches in Paths of Glory and the narrative force of its framing. His account points to an attentiveness to technique, not an inventory of images that Scorsese later copied.

The question can be asked without turning precision into an abstract compliment: what does this camera position help us understand, and what does it leave out? The same character seen from far away may appear integrated into an organization; seen up close, they may draw our attention to a reaction. The choice has no permanent meaning. It depends on what is happening around it and on the information the film has already given us.

The composition and perspective in Kubrick’s films make it possible to study this relationship between figure and surroundings. Depth can show those waiting while someone advances, or keep a structure that limits the action within the frame. Framing need not pause the story to describe an institution. It can help viewers understand it through the positions and movements of its members.

The transition from one shot to another also matters. A reaction can change what we have just interpreted as confidence; a change in distance can reveal that someone was being watched. Studying storytelling through framing requires preserving that sequence. A collection of isolated frames can help us examine compositions, but it removes the duration and temporal relationships that turn those images into a scene.

Moving through a trench does not mean sharing the experience of those who occupy it

In Paths of Glory, Mireau’s walk through the trench brings authority into contact with the bodies and responses he must manage. The general can stop, question and judge what he encounters. The camera makes these interactions legible without turning the journey into a neutral inspection. The space is occupied by people whose ability to respond is not equal to that of the person asking the questions.

Dax’s passage through this setting takes on a different meaning in relation to the attack being prepared. The figures at the sides are not merely elements of depth. Their waiting and exposure are part of what the journey lets us perceive. The continuous movement connects nearby places without ensuring that everyone shares the same experience or the same degree of control over what happens next.

The attack on Ant Hill transforms this spatial problem. Outside the trench, advancing means crossing an area where the body loses its protection. The camera relates movement, obstacles and danger, but does not turn the battlefield into a fully legible diagram. It can keep one trajectory visible while other actions are interrupted by smoke, distance or shifts in attention.

Comparing the journey beforehand with the attack helps us see the difference between continuity of recording and continuity of control. The fact that the camera can follow a movement does not mean the character is in control of their situation. Space offers resistance, and decisions made by those in command do not guarantee the required outcome. The visual technique makes an action understandable without erasing the limitations of those who must carry it out.

The study of camera movements distinguishes this function from an explanation based solely on the equipment used. The direction of movement, the distance from the body and the relationship with secondary characters all change what is being told. Calling two shots tracking shots is not enough to establish that they perform the same narrative function, even if both use a recognizable movement.

Entering a place can reveal privilege rather than obedience

The entrance to the Copacabana in Goodfellas offers a formal comparison with the journeys in Paths of Glory. Henry leads Karen through an entrance that passes through work areas before reaching the show space. The movement lets us observe a network of recognition and special access. The camera does not explain that access with a definition: it makes it perceptible through doors, greetings and positions.

The similarity to a Kubrick journey lies in how the movement links the character to a spatial and human organization. The difference lies in the relationship it reveals. At the Copacabana, Henry displays a degree of access that impresses Karen. In the trench, bodies and ranks point to obligations and risks. A technique of continuity can create fascination, exposure or criticism, depending on the scene.

This comparison should not be presented as documentary proof that Scorsese’s shot was based on Paths of Glory. His statement about what he learned does not automatically identify this particular connection. It is a critical proposal based on visible techniques. The criteria for evaluating interpretations help preserve its value without presenting it as a documented intention that was never expressed.

The difference can be confirmed by paying attention to the reactions. Karen takes part in an experience of access that she is still learning to interpret. The soldiers in the trench know the institution that regulates their responses and bodies. The continuity of the camera does not erase this inequality of information. On the contrary, it lets us observe how each character relates to an order that the movement gradually makes visible.

Scorsese’s account is therefore more specific than a general expression of admiration. It identifies a study practice and a question about storytelling. It can be connected to Spielberg’s acknowledged technical learning, but should not be stretched to explain his entire filmography. What is documented is an attentiveness to Kubrick; every subsequent comparison needs to show which technique it shares, what changes and where the available evidence ends.

References: Martin Scorsese, interview with Charlie Rose (2001), cited by Robert Koehler in “Kubrick’s Outsized Influence,” DGA Quarterly, Fall 2017. Films compared: Stanley Kubrick, Paths of Glory (1957); Martin Scorsese, Goodfellas (1990).

View all articles in Kubrick in Other Filmmakers and Visual Culture