Working as a press photographer before directing films

A photograph for a magazine had to find its place within a story fit for publication. His experience at Look brought Kubrick into contact with the relationship between an individual shot and an editorial decision.

The assignment sets a question and a purpose for the images

Stanley Kubrick’s work for Look did not simply involve going out with a camera and waiting for an image. A magazine needs subjects it can present to its readers, and enough material to build a story around them. The assignment therefore establishes a purpose in advance, although the outcome may change as the work progresses. It is important to distinguish the initiative of proposing a subject from the conditions under which it is accepted, developed and published.

The Library of Congress organises this material by assignment, or ‘job’, and preserves negatives and contact sheets. This unit is more informative than an isolated photograph: it places the image within a piece of work for which other possibilities were also produced. A photograph later circulated as a work in its own right may have been just one of the options available for a sequence or to illustrate an aspect of the story.

The variety of tasks demands a change of method. Following an activity, preparing a portrait or showing a workspace does not call for the same relationship with people. Nor does it guarantee the same degree of access. The overview of the Look collection reveals this variety without ascribing to all the images a supposedly singular technique based on capturing events as they unfold, without intervention.

Professional training includes anticipating what might be missing from a story. An image of an action may need another to establish the setting or identify a relationship. The aim is not to repeat a subject until a more striking shot is obtained, but to produce material with different functions. This work helps us understand photojournalism as a combination of decisions, not simply as a collection of successful photographs.

Selection changes the meaning of a shot

A contact sheet brings together images that make it possible to compare variations: a position changes, a gaze shifts or an action reaches a different moment. This proximity reveals different ways of recording events, but it does not automatically tell us who chose the published image. To attribute a choice to the editor, we need relevant markings, correspondence or testimony. The existence of a sequence of negatives does not make the photographer solely responsible for the final order.

Once placed on the page, a shot is given a size, position and neighbours. A large image may establish the subject, while smaller ones add actions or contrasts. Readers do not perceive these elements as if they were isolated in an archive. The construction of narratives through selection and sequencing makes it possible to examine how a photograph changes when it takes on a role within a larger whole.

Cropping also changes relationships. It can bring a figure closer, remove information from the surroundings or strengthen the connection between two gestures. Not every later reproduction preserves the same area of the original page. That is why an analysis of composition should identify which version it uses: the negative, a print, the published photograph or a contemporary reproduction. The difference is material and may directly affect the critical argument.

Nor does the absence of publication amount to a failure of the image. Editorial decisions may have had nothing to do with its visual quality. Without documentation, we should not invent a reason for its exclusion. To study the work produced, unpublished material may reveal alternatives; to study what Look’s readers saw, we need to return to the magazine issue and examine what was actually selected.

The case of Shoe Shine Boy helps maintain this distinction between preserved material and the form in which it circulated. A collection brought together for an exhibition may acquire a unity that does not match its original editorial history. Retrospective publications make images available, but they also reorganise them around a different question: the photographer is now a well-known director, and that status may shape the selection.

Image and text share the information

The title and caption do not necessarily repeat what is visible. They may provide a date, identify an activity or connect separate moments. This information changes how the image is read, but its provenance must be assessed. A caption written decades later does not have the same temporal relationship to the photograph as one prepared for the magazine. Both are editorial texts, and neither should be mistaken for the spontaneous voice of the person photographed.

The photograph, in turn, may show elements that the text does not develop. A peripheral gesture or the arrangement of the space may prompt new questions. Analysis need not choose between believing the caption completely and ignoring it. It can distinguish what comes from the image, what comes from the text and what relationship the two propose together. This distinction makes it possible to study a photo essay without reducing it to its verbal argument.

The exhibition programme for Through a Different Lens notes that some of Kubrick’s work involved staged situations and participants acting out events. This fact rules out using an everyday appearance as universal proof of spontaneity. Intervention must be established for each work; it would also be wrong to reverse the mistake and declare all his photographs staged because some were.

The contribution of this experience to filmmaking training can be described with caution. Producing options, anticipating relationships between images and working to an editorial structure are skills that have points of contact with cinema. They are not equivalent to already mastering sound or directing actors. Professional continuity does not erase the differences between a page that readers move through and a film whose duration is fixed.

New York provides the setting for many of these assignments, but Look adds a specific organisation: commissions, materials and publication. Attending to that organisation allows us to recognise Kubrick’s work without erasing the people who wrote, selected or designed the pages. His photographic authorship can be studied precisely because it is not confused with absolute authorship of every page on which his name appeared.

Sources: Library of Congress, Look Collection, ‘Background and Scope’ and ‘Stanley Kubrick’s Photographs for LOOK Magazine, Searching & Viewing Materials’. Skirball Cultural Center, exhibition introduction for Through a Different Lens: Stanley Kubrick Photographs, 2019. University of the Arts London, Stanley Kubrick Archive, Look Magazine, SK/2.

View all articles in Stanley Kubrick’s origins and training