The beggar first appears as a victim of Alex and returns later in a different situation. The repetition shows that violence leaves a memory and changes relationships.
A first encounter marked by inequality
On one of their first nights out, Alex and his companions encounter a homeless man. The scene presents a clear imbalance of power: the group can act collectively, while the beggar is in a vulnerable position. The violence inflicted on him cannot be explained as a dispute between equal opponents. The episode establishes a relationship that the viewer will remember when the characters cross paths again.
The beggar’s voice matters because he does not appear merely as an anonymous figure in the urban setting. He speaks, reacts and expresses a position towards those who threaten him. This intervention allows us to recognise him as a person within the story. The film may use his situation to show Alex’s behaviour, but a critical reading should not erase his experience. The character’s social circumstances do not justify the aggression or make it inevitable.
The analysis of Alex examines the protagonist’s violent initiative. What matters here is that the beggar remembers the encounter and that his position later will not be the same. Repeating a secondary character allows the narrative to show consequences without introducing a lengthy explanation. The viewer already has enough information to recognise the connection between the episodes.
Alex’s return changes the balance of power
After the Ludovico treatment and his release from prison, Alex encounters the beggar again. Now the protagonist cannot respond as he did before to certain acts of aggression. The man recognises the person who attacked him, and the situation takes on a sense of return. The main difference is not that the past has disappeared, but that their present capabilities have changed. The memory of the harm allows the second encounter to be read in the light of the first.
Other people are involved in the scene, changing the balance of power. Alex goes from acting as part of an aggressive group to finding himself defenceless. The encounter with the former droogs who are now police officers presents another later reversal of authority; there is no need to merge the two episodes into a single explanation of his return. Each uses different characters and circumstances to show the consequences of losing autonomy.
Understanding the beggar’s resentment does not mean that the film automatically justifies revenge. A reading can acknowledge the earlier harm while also examining the later violence as a new act. The narrative avoids a simple moral accounting in which suffering harm grants an unlimited right to inflict it again. The return of the memory is unsettling precisely because the viewer remembers both moments.
Voice, recognition and the viewer’s position
The beggar’s identification depends on narrative continuity. His voice and presence connect scenes with different functions. In the first, the audience watches Alex commit an assault; in the second, it sees a vulnerable protagonist facing someone who remembers. The viewer’s emotional position may vary, but the film does not require everyone to respond in the same way. The shift in perspective is part of the story’s design.
The return of Alex to his home shows another kind of loss of belonging, while the encounter with the beggar takes place in a public space. That difference matters: exclusion at home depends on family relationships; the beggar’s reaction stems from a memory of earlier violence. The study of sound can expand on the role of voices and the setting, but here the focus is the continuity between a character’s two appearances.
The beggar does not need an invented biographical backstory to serve his purpose. The film gives him a concrete relationship with Alex, an earlier injury and a later response. These elements are enough to examine how the narrative reverses positions and how memory prevents violence from being confined to an isolated scene. Repetition does not make revenge automatically just; it shows that the protagonist’s actions return under conditions he no longer controls.
The beggar’s voice takes on particular significance in the second encounter because it allows the memory of the first to become present again. Recognition does not need to rely on a formal investigation or an admission from Alex. The film uses the continuity of a character to connect separate events. The later reaction can be understood as the consequence of remembered harm, but that causal link does not settle its ethical value. The audience can recognise that the man was unjustly assaulted and, at the same time, watch with unease as violence is now inflicted on someone defenceless. This tension avoids a reading of perfectly proportionate punishment. The scene shows that a secondary character’s personal story continues beyond the narrative’s focus on Alex and can return when the balance of power changes. The memory of an assault does not disappear because the protagonist has undergone treatment in an institution.
View all articles in A Clockwork Orange: characters, violence and cinematic form
