Paths of Glory shows the effects of German gunfire without turning enemy soldiers into visible protagonists of the battle. Their absence contrasts with the final appearance of a young German woman, first seen as an adversary and then heard as a person.
An adversary known through its effects
The offensive against Ant Hill is directed at a German position. The viewer learns that the enemy is there through orders, information from superiors and the effects of the gunfire on French soldiers. However, the film pays little attention to portraying those firing from the opposing position as individuals. The danger is manifested in explosions, people falling and the inability to advance. The enemy can remain off-screen while still being a material presence in the war.
This distribution of visual attention has a narrative consequence. By not constantly switching between the commanders of both armies, the film focuses attention on the behaviour of the French officers towards their own men. The attack is not explained through a complete portrait of German strategy; it is experienced from the position of those who have received an order that is difficult to carry out. The Regiment’s Offensive examines its stages without reconstructing an adversary’s military plan that the story does not provide.
The lack of enemy faces during the battle does not mean that the film denies history or turns war into a phenomenon without opposing forces. Within the fiction, the French are fighting a specific German force. The choice is to show the internal relationships of one side in greater detail. This point of view means that the conflict that matters most to the characters is not just the fire they face, but how their own superiors will judge their ability to endure it.
Visual absences and visible responsibilities
When General Mireau accuses the soldiers of not having fought hard enough, the viewer retains the images of the battle. We do not need to know the enemy gunners to understand that the conditions of the mission were extreme. The film thus turns the visible effects of the attack into a basis for discussing the judgement that follows. The command tries to reduce a defeat against a fortified position to a question of individual willpower. The absence of a personalised enemy prevents attention from being diverted to the wickedness of an external adversary.
Decisions within the French army therefore occupy a considerable part of the story. The generals argue, Colonel Dax tries to defend his men, Roget protects his earlier conduct, and the court decides what evidence to admit. The viewer sees the faces and gestures of those making these decisions, while the Germans remain, for the most part, a distant military presence. This asymmetry does not erase their status as combatants; it defines the sphere of responsibility the narrative is investigating.
The treatment of the enemy also has consequences for how compassion is distributed. During the offensive, the camera needs the viewer to recognise the danger facing the French; it does not demand that they imagine the individual life of every German soldier who might be firing. At the end, by contrast, the young singer makes us look at a person whose nationality had previously marked her out as an adversary. This shift does not show that victims on the other side did not exist, nor that the story has deliberately forgotten their historical circumstances. It changes the narrative perspective from an abstract military force to a visible individual. Music makes it possible for the French soldiers to sense a connection without knowing the young woman’s life in full. The contrast works precisely because the film does not offer a complete ideological conversion: it shows a moment of recognition within a war that continues.
Sound contributes to the same effect. Gunshots and explosions come from positions that the image does not need to show at close range. The source of the noise establishes the direction of the threat, but offers no human conversation with whoever is making it. The Night Patrol is another instance of incomplete perception, in which danger is created through darkness, noises and mistaken responses. In both episodes, not seeing the enemy is not the same as knowing precisely everything they do.
The young German woman changes the scale of the encounter
At the end, a young German woman appears before French soldiers in a tavern. Her presence is very different from that of the adversary during the offensive. She no longer represents a position from which fire comes, but a person exposed to the gaze and mockery of men who consider themselves the victors in their small-scale encounter. The scene allows the enemy to stop being a distant military category and acquire a face and a voice.
The audience’s reaction changes when the woman sings. Some soldiers begin to listen and join in with the melody, even though the language barrier and the war do not disappear. The Song and the Ending explores this transformation in detail. Here, what matters is its place within the earlier distribution of presences: after a film dominated by internal French conflict, a German woman appears and changes how we see someone who belongs to the other side.
The contrast avoids an overly simple reading in which the enemy was always invisible as part of an abstract message of brotherhood. During the battle, what matters is their military impact; at the end, what matters is the vulnerability of a particular person. Both choices are compatible without resolving the entire conflict. The film changes the scale of representation and makes it possible to recognise that a collective category, ‘the enemy’, can conceal individuals whose human experience is not exhausted by the place they occupy in the war.
View all articles in Paths of Glory (Paths of Glory): film guide
