Betty Steinberg is credited as the editor of The Killing. Her work can be studied through the alternation of timelines, the repetition of the same interval and the way the cuts manage the viewer’s knowledge.
The editing credit and the limits of attribution
The credits for The Killing identify Betty Steinberg as responsible for the editing. This places her contribution in the post-production process, but does not justify attributing every observed choice to her alone. Stanley Kubrick directed the film, worked on the screenplay and took part in the overall decisions about its narrative construction; moreover, film editing is a collaborative process involving revision. When studying a particular cut, it is worth distinguishing what is visible on screen from what can be established about its authorship.
The film adapts Lionel White’s novel Clean Break and establishes a distinctive relationship between the order of events and the order in which they are presented. It does not move steadily forwards. It returns to shared moments to show what another participant did while an already familiar action was unfolding. Editing turns this procedure into an experience: sequences that appear to repeat time do not necessarily repeat information. A new entrance, a gesture in the background or a previously unnoticed preparation changes how what has already been shown is understood.
The effect is not one of endless confusion. The film uses time references and narration to guide the viewer. It is precisely because this verbal framework is in place that the editing can shift attention from one character to another without using too many shots to reconstruct the transitions. Art Gilmore’s voice regulates some of this guidance, while the arrangement of shots determines what is experienced as simultaneous, premature or delayed. Technical analysis should consider both devices without conflating their functions.
Two ways of perceiving the same stretch of time
At the racecourse, the episodes involving Maurice’s fight, Nikki’s shooting and Johnny’s entry into the offices are understood as coordinated actions. The viewer first learns certain consequences, then gets another piece of the mechanism. The repetition of the interval gives the horse races, corridors and work areas a double temporality: they are settings that move forwards in each sequence, and reference points for earlier moments within the story.
The perceived duration of an action depends on the shots around it. A brief preparation can take on weight once its consequence is known, while a dangerous manoeuvre unfolds so quickly that there is no time to stop and assess its risks. The editing alternates between moments of functional observation and sudden accelerations, particularly when the operation ceases to be a sequence of controlled tasks. The tension comes from these variations, not from a consistently high cutting rate.
The repetition of an event across different narrative periods also requires us to distinguish between two forms of duration. The first is the time that passes within the story between one action and another. The second is the time the film spends showing them. A brief interval can occupy several scenes if each adds a new perspective; a long journey can disappear in a cut. The editing makes use of this difference to ensure that the operation does not seem like a mere list of instructions. Attention shifts to each participant’s efforts and to what they do not know while carrying out their task. The viewer need not check the exact timing of every event to appreciate the result. It is enough to notice that the image constructs relationships of simultaneity that do not always come from showing two actions in parallel. A succession of fragments can reconstruct the same moment with a precision that a linear account would not offer.
A second useful comparison is between the assembly of the heist and the gang’s final meeting. During the operation, the editing organises separate tasks that seem to coincide; in the flat, it suddenly brings together characters with incompatible interests. Narrative time becomes less dependent on explanation and hurtles towards simultaneous violence. The meeting episode offers a way to examine this dramatic difference, while this article focuses on the experience of duration, continuity and rupture.
Cuts that create knowledge and cuts that withhold it
A cut can provide new information without showing more details of an action already seen. Ellipsis saves showing the journey between places and obliges the viewer to reconstruct the connections. At other moments, the film holds on to a reaction long enough for the viewer to notice the gap between a character who is still waiting and another who already knows about the disaster. The editing does more than convey facts about the plan: it shapes the viewer’s emotional relationship with the participants.
Continuity within an interior and ruptures between spaces serve different purposes. A camera move through rooms can maintain a visible relationship between people; a cut to another setting breaks that proximity and selects a line of action. It is therefore useful to compare the editing with the camera movements between rooms. These are complementary procedures, but they are not interchangeable. The precision of the whole comes from deciding when to show the spatial connection and when to leave it to the imagination.
To attribute the fragmented structure solely to one person’s talent would oversimplify the history of film-making. What can be documented is Steinberg’s credit and the visible result: a film that repeats intervals with different information and transforms the order of the narrative into a source of tension. Studying these effects makes it possible to recognise the importance of editing without inventing editing-room conversations, specific decisions or instructions for which there is no evidence.
