Valles and Bill Thomas: the costumes of Spartacus

In Spartacus, clothing distinguishes forced labour, the spectacle of gladiators and Roman privilege. Costume design communicates hierarchies and freedom of movement; responsibility is shared among credited professionals.

Design credits and surviving working documents

The production credits list Valles for costumes and Bill Thomas for the specific work associated with Jean Simmons. This distinction matters because it prevents all the garments from being attributed to one person. It also separates the responsibility stated in a production credit from the day-to-day making of each piece: construction, fittings, alterations, continuity and maintenance are all part of a production involving different workers. A credit establishes professional responsibility, but on its own it does not reconstruct the making of every tunic, cape or suit of armour in the film.

Material documentation of Bill Thomas’s designs for Varinia survives, including sketches held in museum collections. A drawing of a garment can show the colour, drape and ornament, as well as the silhouette that informed its preparation. However, verifying a sketch is not the same as proving that the version seen on screen retained every detail. Any comparison must consider the specific costume, the scene in which it appears and any adjustments made during filming. Varinia’s story provides the dramatic context for these visible transformations.

The costumes received recognition in the world of film awards, but their formal interest does not depend on the distinction they received. Clothing is a tool for communicating social differences without turning every conversation into an explanation of the Roman economy. A character may make a stronger visual impression on entering a room because of the volume or finish of their clothes, while another is defined by clothing associated with physical exertion and dependency. This distribution is repeated with variations as the protagonists’ positions change.

The film does not aim to be an archaeological catalogue in which every fabric can be identified with a specific date and region. Film design draws on conventions familiar to audiences in 1960, accommodates the demands of filming and seeks to maintain visual continuity between locations. A costume is appropriate if it helps tell the story, even if its relationship to historical dress requires a different kind of study. Confusing dramatic plausibility with documentary accuracy would lead to claims that the image alone cannot support.

Labour, spectacle and public representation

The clothing worn by enslaved people in the mines and at the school in Capua is associated with physical activity, limited autonomy and exposure of the body to the orders of others. The clothes allow them to move their arms, carry weights or train, but that practicality does not imply freedom. At the school, moreover, the body is the product its owner wants to display. Costume can reinforce this status through differences between workwear and dress for presenting the gladiators to visitors. The school’s architecture helps explain how clothing and space work together to separate observers from those being observed.

Roman clothing communicates other uses of the body. Togas, cloaks, ornamented garments and insignia of command can make rank apparent before a character states their position. Richer materials and the trappings of public representation also affect gestures and movement: a ceremonial seat is not occupied in the same way as a training yard. There is no need to assign a fixed ideology to every colour. Differences in texture, cleanliness or volume are often enough to establish a contrast with the lives of the subjugated workers.

Varinia occupies an especially complex position because she changes surroundings while continuing to face others’ expectations of her body. What she wears can signal who holds social control at a given moment, but Jean Simmons’s performance also shows a person who responds and makes decisions within narrow limits. Reducing the design of her dresses to romantic decoration would erase this tension. The contrast between clothing and behaviour shows that an appearance fashioned by others does not entirely determine the character’s subjectivity.

Extras also need distinct costumes. In a big-budget production featuring crowds, the repetition of certain garments and silhouettes helps distinguish armies, communities and positions of command at a distance. Uniformity can communicate discipline; variations within the rebel group can recall its diverse origins. This reading should be based on specific scenes and should not assume that every character belonging to a faction wears exactly the same outfit. A cinematic crowd becomes legible through a combination of costume, position, movement and framing.

Changes of clothing and the reading of power

Leaving Capua changes the function of the bodies. The gladiators stop training for display and must organise their own survival. Costume plays a part in this change, but it should not be interpreted as an instant transformation in which every former sign of enslavement disappears. The fugitives’ material limitations persist; their resources and clothes come from a world still controlled by Rome. Examining the clothing reveals the distance between gaining some room to act and having all the means needed to live without dependence.

Comparing costume and set design clarifies their effect. A garment may stand out against the marble of a Roman room and take on a different meaning on a dusty road. The use of colour in Spartacus examines these relationships between colours; here, the focus is also on how fabric sits on the body, the freedom to move and the difference between ornamenting a character and equipping them for a task. The film makes changes of setting intelligible in part through the way human figures are presented.

The work of Valles and Bill Thomas helps identify specific responsibilities in creating the visible world of Spartacus. The surviving sketches are evidence of a design process, not automatic photographs of the final result. The most useful reading brings together credits, garments actually seen on screen and narrative functions: who appears able to give orders, who has to work for others, and when costume stops communicating hierarchy alone and accompanies a personal decision.

View all articles in Spartacus: film guide