Optical and mechanical effects in Kubrick

A spacecraft can be an object photographed and share a shot with footage captured separately. A body can appear to climb a wall while the set rotates. The image brings together techniques that are best identified by their function and by the available documentation.

Photographing an object does not mean that the whole shot exists together

The spacecraft in 2001 have a material appearance that allows their surfaces, volumes and changes in lighting to be examined. The use of physical models is part of effects work, but a miniature is not, in itself, a complete image. It must be positioned, lit, its movement relative to other elements recorded, and related to the background. The perceived scale comes from this collaboration, not simply from the amount of detail built into the object.

The study of miniatures and the sense of scale explores these issues. When classifying techniques, it is important to distinguish what is built in front of the camera from what is assembled using different exposures or recordings. An image may contain both kinds of work. Calling it practical does not prove that all its elements were present at the same time during a single take.

The 1968 American Cinematographer feature describes repeated exposures and precisely recorded movements used to bring elements of the spacecraft together. This process retains real photographic material, but requires a temporal construction that the viewer does not see. The final movement may appear continuous even though its components were obtained separately and at different times during filming.

Lighting helps make these elements appear to share an environment. If their directions and contrasts are incompatible, the spatial relationship is weakened. Coherence is not simply a matter of hiding an edge: surfaces and movements must also be interpretable as part of the same situation. The effect is judged by its perceived continuity, while understanding how it was made requires knowledge of operations that are not visible in the finished print.

Projecting a background and moving a set solve different problems

The Dawn of Man uses front projection to bring performers and elements of the set together with landscapes photographed in advance. Front projection in 2001 is discussed in detail elsewhere. Its function helps distinguish a represented location from one visited by the crew: visual continuity in the landscape does not prove that all the bodies and surfaces were filmed in the same outdoor location.

The screen is part of a physical arrangement. The result depends on the positioning of the camera, projection, performers and foreground elements. For the viewer, what matters is that the background is integrated into the represented depth. A description of the shot can note this continuity without confusing it with the claim that there is a traversable geography behind every visible element.

The Discovery's rotating sets pose a different problem. Here, a mechanism physically changes the orientation of the space in relation to the bodies and the camera. American Cinematographer documented different relationships between the movements of these components. The effect cannot be explained simply by saying that the actor walks on a wall, because that describes what is represented, not the conditions that make it possible to film.

The orientation we perceive depends on the points of reference retained in the image. If the framing keeps part of the set steady, the body's movement can appear different from what the crew experiences outside it. The camera does not record a universal direction of up and down: it organises a field of references that the viewer uses to interpret what is happening.

Creating a recording and recognising collaborative work

The Stargate introduces images whose purpose is not to reproduce an everyday set. The Kubrick Archive preserves a document titled Slit scan outline. This material helps situate slit-scan among the project's techniques without attributing an improvised recipe to a visual impression. The analysis of the construction of the Stargate distinguishes its techniques and how the result is assembled through editing.

The example helps broaden the idea of an optical effect. It is not always a matter of adding a figure to an existing background. An image can also be constructed through the way light and movement are recorded. The audience receives an audiovisual space whose journey need not correspond to a visitable location. Colour, scale and speed create perceptual relationships that belong to this created image.

Categories overlap when a physical mechanism is involved in an optical recording, or a miniature is incorporated into a composition. It is therefore more useful to identify the operations than to divide every shot between two mutually exclusive categories. We can ask what was built, what was moved, what was projected and which recordings were combined. The answers may relate to different stages and teams.

The technical feature names, among other collaborators, Wally Veevers, Douglas Trumbull, Con Pederson and Tom Howard. Their contributions should be recognised when studying the effects. Kubrick's control of the project does not make every device his individual invention. Nor does the presence of a name in the credits, on its own, justify attributing the complete creation of any shot to that person.

The formats of recording and exhibition add another stage to the history of the image. A negative, a composite and a print are not interchangeable records of the work. Examining the sources alongside the result makes it possible to recognise the precision of the techniques without turning the analysis into an assumed tutorial. The difference between what the shot leads us to believe and what the documentation allows us to demonstrate is part of what makes the effects interesting.

Films discussed: Stanley Kubrick, 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968). Documentation: University of the Arts London, Stanley Kubrick Archive, SK/12/8/1/78, “Slit scan outline”; Herb A. Lightman, “Filming 2001: A Space Odyssey”, American Cinematographer, June 1968.

View all articles in Kubrick’s photography, camera and cinematic effects