Landscape and nature in Kubrick: refuge, frontier and threat

A landscape can shield someone from view and make it harder to find one’s bearings; it can also offer open space and leave a body without cover. In Kubrick, its function depends on what the characters are trying to do within it.

Forest and plain: hiding or being exposed

Fear and Desire places its soldiers in a territory whose national identity remains undetermined. The forest creates obstacles between the eye and whatever someone is trying to locate. Trees and vegetation provide cover, but they also prevent a complete view of the surroundings. The same space that can conceal a group allows presences to exist beyond its field of perception. Refuge and threat depend on who is looking, and from where.

Movement requires decisions made with incomplete information. A route can bring someone closer to an exit while exposing them to an unforeseen encounter. The war without a country in Fear and Desire examines this indeterminacy of conflict; from the perspective of landscape, what matters is that the territory does not function as a surface the characters have already mastered. What lies beyond an obstacle matters precisely because it is not immediately visible to them.

Barry Lyndon offers scenes in which open space changes the problem. Its breadth makes it possible to see military formations and recognise their order, but that order makes bodies visible and vulnerable. Advancing in a regular formation does not remove exposure to fire. The landscape reveals a distance that must be crossed, while discipline requires a particular form of movement to be maintained across it. The clarity of the composition does not mean that those within it are safe.

The analysis of formations, discipline and exposure in Barry Lyndon’s war helps distinguish this experience from concealment in the forest. In one case, perception is hindered by too many obstacles; in the other, the body has little protection from a gaze or a shot. There is no need to assign natural goodness to the forest or permanent hostility to the plain. Their function changes with the action and with the power relations that organise the space.

The Overlook’s snow: an environment that makes escape difficult and records movement

The Shining connects the hotel with an exterior that is difficult to access and changes over the winter. Snow affects movement and makes suitable means of crossing it necessary. This material condition affects the possibility of calling for help and of anyone reaching the hotel. The landscape does not act as a will that punishes the characters, but it changes the practical options within which they must make decisions.

Nor does the contrast between inside and outside establish a fixed equivalence between refuge and danger. The building provides shelter from the weather while containing a direct threat. Going outside may mean exposure to the cold and, at the same time, offer a chance to escape the person in pursuit. The meaning of a space depends on the risk being considered at any given moment. A door can separate temperature, visibility and access to other people in ways that do not coincide.

Snow preserves tracks and turns movement into information for whoever arrives later. A body leaves a mark that can be followed, but this relationship also makes it possible to act on what the pursuer expects to find. The analysis of the maze and ending of The Shining explores the specific sequence. What matters here is that the surface is not an indifferent backdrop: it records movements and plays a part in a confrontation between interpreting the trail and the pursued person’s actions.

The maze also introduces a limit to the opposition between nature and construction. Its plant life forms a designed route, and the snow alters the conditions of that design. What appears to be a natural environment is part of a human organisation of space. family relationships of protection run through this place, but they do not in themselves explain how it works materially: orientation, tracks and distance continue to pose problems that each body must resolve as it moves.

2001: changing scale without turning landscape into an explanation

The opening of 2001 places animal bodies and groups of hominids in an environment where water, food and territory condition their actions. The scale of the landscape makes it possible to observe a relationship with resources and threats before any discourse appears to explain it. The Dawn of Man analyses the change associated with the tool; from the perspective of the environment, what matters is how a place acquires value because it offers something necessary and can be contested.

The lunar landscape changes this relationship. Human bodies need suits and equipment in order to remain and act there. The surface is presented through routes, vehicles and an excavation site organised by people. This is not nature entirely separate from human intervention: the frame brings together terrain, infrastructure and research activity. The scale makes the technical dependence of those who have arrived perceptible, even though they are able to work there.

Describing this space as a lunar landscape within the fiction does not mean claiming that it was filmed on the Moon or reconstructing how it was made from its appearance. Narrative analysis attends to what the place makes possible to see and do. The comparison between technical progress and relations of domination opens up another question: travelling further changes the means available, but does not automatically eliminate hierarchical organisation or the withholding of information among those exploring.

Forest, plain, snow and lunar surface offer different relationships between body and scale. To compare them, it is useful to consider cover, freedom of movement, marks and resources, as well as the distance from which they are filmed. A wide shot can show freedom of movement or make vulnerability visible; an enclosed area can protect and disorient. Meaning comes from these relationships with the action, not from attributing to each landscape a directorial intention that its mere presence does not prove.

References: Stanley Kubrick, Fear and Desire (1953), 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968), Barry Lyndon (1975) and The Shining (1980). The landscapes depicted in the films are discussed, not travel destinations.

View all articles in Themes and conflicts in Kubrick’s cinema