Discarded material: what it can tell us about a film

The term deleted scene can conceal different situations. A passage written but never filmed does not offer the same evidence as a sequence that was shot or a clip removed after a screening.

A written alternative does not contain an invisible film

A screenplay lets us learn about a proposed set of actions and dialogue when its version can be identified. It does not prove that everything written was filmed. Between the written text and production, a scene’s duration, cast, location and organization can change. To talk about discarded material, we must first specify what kind of material exists, rather than imagining a complete film behind every page that differs from the theatrical release.

The screenplay versions help distinguish these possibilities. A scene present in a draft and absent from a revision may document a change in the writing. Another source of evidence is needed to claim that it was filmed. Nor is it enough to find a scene number in a schedule: a schedule records an intention, not necessarily what was carried out.

The search for locations raises a similar limitation. A photograph prepared to assess a space may be related to a scene that was never made. The object exists and has documentary value, but it should not be turned into a frame from an alternative version. Preserving its original purpose lets us explain what was considered without inventing a later stage.

This distinction does not lessen the interest of preparatory materials. A written alternative may show a different distribution of information or a different relationship between characters. These differences can be analysed as narrative possibilities. What they cannot do is describe the performance, editing rhythm or sound mix of a sequence known only through words.

Filmed material, prepared sound and working versions

The Dr. Strangelove pie fight is a case of filmed material that was later removed. The archive catalogue describes a late version of the screenplay that no longer includes the sequence. This record helps establish a difference between materials, but it does not, on its own, reproduce the scene’s edit or determine all the reasons for its removal.

A still photograph from a production does not preserve its duration either. It may show performers, objects and a situation, but not the order of the shots, the pauses or their relationship to the sound. Reconstructing a sequence requires materials that can establish these connections. Assembling known images in a plausible order creates a researcher’s proposal; it does not automatically recover a historical version.

2001 offers a catalogued difference between continuity documents. The British copies from March 1968 include transcripts of scientists for a planned prologue; the American copies from July do not. The comparison identifies a documentary variation. It is not enough to claim that each corresponds exactly to a copy shown to the public or to reconstruct how the prologue would have been integrated.

The unused score by Alex North for 2001 represents another kind of discarded material: music prepared for a film whose final soundtrack took a different direction. Comparing a recording with images can be useful, but it requires knowing the version, excerpt and synchronization. Setting music to a scene on one’s own initiative does not make the result an authorized reconstruction of the edit that would have been released.

The sound stage also matters. A filmed scene may retain guide voices or lack a finished mix. Its provisional appearance should not be judged as though it were necessarily the final result the team would have chosen. At the same time, recognizing that it is incomplete does not justify attributing hypothetical improvements to it to argue that it would have been better than the released version.

Removal from an edit does not mean disappearance from history

The versions of The Shining remind us that comparisons can be made between edits with different public release histories. In that case, the question changes: it is no longer only about what was planned or filmed, but about identifying which version was shown, where and when. A duration on its own does not resolve the comparison when presentation or playback-speed differences are involved.

Our vocabulary must preserve these stages. Written, prepared, filmed, edited and released are not synonyms. A scene may pass through some stages but not others. To support a claim that something was removed after a screening, we need to document the screening and the change, not infer them solely from the material’s apparently advanced finish.

The archive may bring together traces of several stages without offering a complete sequence. A letter may explain a decision; a screenplay may reflect its result; a photograph may preserve an earlier moment. None should become universal proof of the entire process. Their strength lies in what they actually record and in the relationships that can be established in a verifiable way.

Artistic evaluation is a separate question. A deleted scene may change the rhythm, information or tone, but its existence does not prove that the final edit is mutilated or that removing it was necessarily the right choice. A comparison needs to describe what changes and acknowledge which parts of the alternative material are not preserved or not known with sufficient precision.

Working with discarded material means resisting the promise of a secret film that can always be recovered. Materials can shed light on decisions and possibilities without forming a complete version. Identifying their status, attributing reasons when testimony exists, and separating reconstruction from documentation make it possible to study real alternatives. This also preserves the value of what is incomplete: partial evidence can answer a specific question without resolving the entire history of a film.

Sources: Stanley Kubrick Archive, UAL, SK/11/1/26, late script of Dr. Strangelove; SK/12/4/2/1, Dialogue Continuity Scripts – Printed in England, March 1968; SK/12/4/2/2, Continuity Scripts – Printed in the USA, July 10, 1968; SK/12/8/1/42, correspondence about music for 2001; film versions of The Shining.

View all articles in Kubrick’s Working Method, Documents, and Archive