The Shining’s framing: exhibition format and home-video versions

A copy can show more of a shot without containing an additional scene. The history of The Shining’s formats requires identifying the medium, edition and aspect ratio before comparing images.

Three documented aspect ratios, different questions

DVDBeaver’s published comparison of editions identifies different home-video presentations of The Shining. Warner’s 1999 and 2001 US DVDs are listed with an image of approximately 1.33:1; Warner’s 2007 Blu-ray, at 1.78:1. The Criterion Collection’s listing gives 1.85:1 for its presentation. These are details about specific materials, not grounds for attributing a single aspect ratio to every copy of the film.

The aspect ratio expresses the proportion between the width and height of the visible area. On its own, it does not identify how much information was recorded during filming or the area intended for a particular screening. A negative can retain image area that is not shown in a theatrical presentation. A home-video transfer can use a different boundary. Confusing these stages leads to treating any difference as either a mutilation or a recovery, even when it has not yet been established what is being compared.

A catalogue’s description of the original format also needs context. It may refer to the area photographed, a theatrical presentation or the way an edition has been prepared. These concepts are not equivalent. Supporting a claim about exhibition intent requires relevant instructions or documentation, not just a label repeated in a commercial review.

The comparison here is based on the listings and comparative captures of those editions. It does not assume an inspection of the negative or certify how each historical copy was projected in every theatre. This distinction makes it possible to describe verifiable differences in presentation without declaring one universally correct aspect ratio based on images whose origin is unknown. The question of intent requires a different kind of evidence than simply measuring a rectangle.

More height does not mean a longer narrative version

When two presentations derive from an image composed to accommodate different framing boundaries, one may retain more space at the top and bottom. This changes the relationship between figures, ceiling, floor and the edges of the shot. It does not necessarily mean recovering information at the sides or seeing a wider film. The impression of spaciousness depends on which area is shown and how it is presented on the screen used for comparison.

In the Overlook’s interiors, this variation can change the weight of the architecture around the bodies. More ceiling or more floor changes how much space surrounds a figure, even when the action and its duration are the same. The relationship between wide-angle lenses and sets raises another question: how depth was organized during filming. The home-video format defines the area through which we access that result.

The difference between 1.78:1 and 1.85:1 is smaller than the difference between either of them and 1.33:1, but it is still a difference in presentation. A number alone is not enough to make a quality judgement. Resolution, compression, colour, stability and the selected area can all vary independently. A copy with more pixels does not, by that fact alone, prove that its framing is the only one historically relevant.

Nor does a larger visible area add scenes. The US and international cuts differ in narrative content and duration, not simply through a vertical expansion of the frame. Transfers of the same cut can have different aspect ratios. The versions of The Shining page makes it possible to distinguish these differences in content from those affecting how each shot is presented.

How to compare without treating a still as conclusive proof

A useful comparison needs to identify the same moment in the action. Two images taken close together but from different frames can show an actor in different positions or a camera movement. Before attributing a difference to the format, it is worth locating stable reference points: a corner of the set, the position of a stationary object and the relationship between the visible edges. The aspect ratio of each still should be preserved, without stretching it to make the sizes match.

Cropping must also be distinguished from repositioning. A transfer may select an area of the image in a way that is not perfectly symmetrical relative to another. It is therefore not enough to superimpose centred rectangles and assume that all differences result from a single mask. When a claim depends on a specific peripheral detail, the result should be described shot by shot.

The player’s settings add another variable. A screen mode that enlarges the image to remove letterboxing can hide part of an edition even when the original file is not cropped that way. A capture made by photographing a screen also does not necessarily preserve the signal’s geometry. These precautions do not prevent comparison; they help avoid attributing to the master an alteration introduced during playback or when preparing the image being examined.

The supposed continuity errors in the Overlook call for particular attention to this issue. An object at the edge may no longer be visible because the copy’s framing has changed, not because it disappeared between two shots. Before proposing a narrative or production explanation, it is necessary to check whether both shots come from the same medium and were presented under comparable conditions.

The material history of The Shining therefore cannot be reduced to choosing one number and dismissing all the others. The documented editions show different uses of the photographed material. Analysis is more precise when it states which copy it uses, which area it compares and what conclusion the evidence can support. Additional information at an edge, the duration of a scene and the intent behind an exhibition are related questions, but they require different kinds of evidence.

References: DVDBeaver, comparison of the 1999, 2001, 2007 and 2019 Warner editions of The Shining; The Digital Bits, review of The Shining DVD. The Criterion Collection, technical details for The Shining; documentation for the Warner editions cited in the text.

View all articles in The Shining (1980): Film Guide