Waltzes in Kubrick: movement, courtesy and distance

A waltz can accompany machines that do not dance or introduce an everyday life that soon becomes uncertain. Its pulse and phrases offer ways of relating to movement, but each film uses those possibilities differently.

2001: perceiving choreography among machines

Johann Strauss Jr.’s The Blue Danube accompanies movements through space in 2001. This association lets us perceive coordination among vehicles, trajectories and rotations. Not every turn has to correspond precisely to a dance figure. The music’s continuity shapes an experience in which technical operations take on a rhythm that viewers can follow as a relationship among moving bodies.

The study of the two Strausses in 2001 distinguishes this work from Richard Strauss’s Also sprach Zarathustra. Sharing a surname does not make the compositions variations of the same piece or turn them both into waltzes. Identifying the composer and the work prevents a musical comparison from being built on a coincidence of names.

The feeling of coordination also depends on the editing. The music can continue through changes in scale and position while the audience maintains a sense of continuous movement. A spacecraft first appears within a vast space and then in relation to another structure. The waltz helps link these images without replacing the visual information about approach, distance and orientation.

The association between future technology and an earlier work introduces a sense of temporal distance. It does not prove that the characters are listening to the music or that a complete dance has been transferred into space. Viewers recognize or perceive a musical organization that changes their experience of the machines. The impression of mechanical elegance or courtesy belongs to this audiovisual relationship, not to a literal statement by the vehicles.

Eyes Wide Shut: musical continuity across everyday gestures

Eyes Wide Shut uses Waltz No. 2 from Shostakovich’s Suite for Variety Orchestra. The publisher Boosey & Hawkes explains that the suite circulated for a time under the incorrectly attributed title Jazz Suite No. 2. Correctly identifying the work does not mean ignoring this history, but it does mean avoiding the impression that both names refer, without qualification, to the same original classification.

The analysis of the music in Eyes Wide Shut places its use within the film’s overall sound. In the introduction to Bill and Alice, the waltz is part of a sequence of bodies, rooms and preparations. The music can provide continuity across different actions even when the characters are not dancing. Its function relates to the organization of a social and domestic world, not just to the literal depiction of a dance floor.

The familiarity of a musical structure can make ordinary gestures seem to flow easily into one another. However, that initial impression does not confirm the stability of the relationship we encounter later. An opening can present an appearance of fluency that the story complicates. The analysis must preserve the distinction between the order of the visible movements and the limited knowledge of those performing them.

The later dance at the party presents a different situation. There, bodies negotiate closeness within a specific social interaction. Not all the music at the gathering should be confused with the waltz from the opening. Identifying each passage and its source makes it possible to compare musical organization and social interaction without turning the entire soundtrack into a single recurring piece.

Musical movement does not, on its own, explain the dramatic relationship

A waltz can offer regularity and continuity, but a film decides how to relate them to the action. A figure may move in keeping with its course, remain still or interrupt the expectation. Musical counterpoint examines cases where the image creates distance from what the music seems to promise. Not every use of a waltz is ironic, and not every instance of coordination amounts to harmony between characters.

The courtship of Barry and Lady Lyndon offers a useful contrast. The presence of music in a social scene and the focus on glances or movements are not enough to classify it as a waltz. The Schubert passage associated with the courtship has a different musical identity. Comparing its function with the earlier examples requires preserving that distinction rather than using waltz as an imprecise synonym for elegant music.

The marches and collective rhythms offer another point of comparison. A rhythm can coordinate a formation, mark a step or accompany an operation without dancing. The functions of regularity, turning and forward movement are not interchangeable. Music proposes a temporal organization; the bodies and the situation determine what kind of activity can be read alongside it.

The relationship between classical repertoire and recorded sound adds the question of performance. A composition is not fully identified by its name: timbre, tempo and articulation belong to a particular version. The film incorporates that recorded experience and selects its duration. For this reason, a comparison of waltzes should take the excerpt used into account, rather than relying only on the prestige or era of their composers.

In 2001, coordination accompanies a technological journey; in Eyes Wide Shut, it plays a part in presenting and recalling human relationships. The musical resemblance raises a question about movement and continuity. Differences in bodies, spaces and narrative position prevent us from reducing it to a shared intention that would automatically explain both uses.

Films discussed: Stanley Kubrick, 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968); Eyes Wide Shut (1999); Barry Lyndon (1975). Sources: Film music credits. Boosey & Hawkes, Dmitri Shostakovich entry, Suite for Variety Orchestra, note on the historical identification and Waltz No. 2.

View all articles in Music, Voices, and Sound Design in Kubrick