A film can preserve an episode while completely changing the position from which we encounter it. Kubrick’s adaptations make it possible to study these transformations between book, screenplay and editing—not merely to list what was removed or added.
Changing the narrator changes our relationship with the protagonist
The comparison between Thackeray’s novel and Barry Lyndon offers a clear example. The literary narrative gives Barry a voice from which to present his own story; the film introduces an external narrator. This change alters who can justify a decision and who places it within a broader perspective. Even when some actions remain recognizable, readers and viewers are not necessarily given the same invitation to trust.
The image also gives duration to a gesture, a space and a reaction. A description can summarize a character’s attitude; a scene can show how they try to maintain it in front of others. The study of Thackeray’s transformation into Barry Lyndon develops its particular choices. As a comparative principle, it is useful to distinguish what is told from the agency that presents it and the conditions under which we can observe it.
In Lolita, retaining Humbert’s speeches does not mean reproducing the experience of his prose unchanged. The acting, framing and responses of other characters place his explanations alongside clues he cannot control verbally. The film can let us hear a self-serving version while offering reasons to question it. This result cannot be measured simply by asking how many lines from the book made it into the dialogue.
Narrators and voice-overs are one possible solution, not a requirement for every adaptation. An interior passage can become conversation, observable behaviour, silence or withheld information. Each alternative redistributes access. Removing an explanation does not always mean simplifying: it can also require the audience to infer a relationship that the text stated explicitly.
Structure reorganizes causes, expectations and narrative journeys
The opening of Lolita places a decisive action before the background that will help us understand it. This choice changes the question that accompanies the story’s development. The audience is not only watching to see where a relationship will lead; it is also looking for how the presented outcome came about. The transformation affects the order of discovery, even though many episodes retain a recognizable connection to the literary source.
Eyes Wide Shut retains relationships and situations from Dream Story while placing them in another context. The city, social conventions and everyday objects are part of the adaptation. They are not simply a backdrop surrounding an unchanged story. A professional credential, a payment or an invitation takes on meaning within a particular social world and changes how access or exclusion is experienced.
The comparison with Schnitzler makes it possible to examine these choices without treating every difference as a loss. A cinematic equivalent does not have to preserve the same object, line or location. We should examine which dramatic relationship it retains, which it changes and what consequences the change produces. Equivalence can be functional and partial: a device can serve a similar purpose while introducing a different tone or a new uncertainty.
Editing and ellipses play a part in this reorganization. A book can move forward through summary and pause within a consciousness; a film distributes time among bodies, sounds and spaces. Condensing an interval does not require speeding up the entire story. It can free up time for a scene that helps us understand a relationship without explaining it through a succession of consecutive episodes.
Novels, screenplays and films are not interchangeable documents
The screenplay is part of the transformation process, but it does not, by itself, certify what appears in the finished work. A written scene may be changed, removed or given a different function during production. To study a difference, we need to identify which versions are being compared. A draft, a published text and the dialogue heard in a print are not automatically of the same status.
Lolita credits Vladimir Nabokov as screenwriter; that credit should be distinguished from the study of the drafts and the decisions incorporated into the film. The relationship between Nabokov, the screenplays and the adaptation requires specific documents. Likewise, Diane Johnson’s credited contribution to The Shining makes it impossible to describe its writing as an activity carried out solely by the director.
2001 offers a different trajectory: development records preserve drafts of the novel, screenplays and correspondence between Kubrick and Arthur C. Clarke. It should not be presented as the simple filming of a novel already completed independently of the project. The writing of 2001 and its relationship to The Sentinel examines these connections. The publication order of two works does not, on its own, describe the order of all their creative decisions.
The work of screenwriters and collaborators also makes it necessary to distinguish the result from attribution. The fact that a change is visible does not automatically identify who proposed it. Formal comparison can establish what changed and make a case for its effect; reconstructing the process requires credits, versions and situated testimony. Keeping these questions separate makes it possible to study adaptations without reducing them to a fidelity contest or turning a viewer’s interpretation into a documented intention.
Films discussed: Stanley Kubrick, Barry Lyndon (1975); Lolita (1962); Eyes Wide Shut (1999); The Shining (1980); 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968). Sources: William Makepeace Thackeray, The Luck of Barry Lyndon; Vladimir Nabokov, Lolita; Arthur Schnitzler, Dream Story. University of the Arts London, Stanley Kubrick Archive, SK/12/1 and SK/12/8/1/12, 2001 development records. Credits for Lolita and The Shining.
View all articles in Narrative, Screenplay and Adaptation in Kubrick
