In the circus photographs from 1948, the public performance sits alongside rehearsals and periods of waiting. The body appears both as a tool of work and as the focus of attention.
A feature on what happens around the performance
The Museum of the City of New York holds the Circus series, made by Stanley Kubrick for Look in 1948. The museum’s presentation links these photographs to a feature published on 25 May and describes activities including rehearsals, animal training, card games and children’s games. This variety shifts the focus of the story: the circus appears as a place of work and social life, as well as a spectacle presented to an audience.
The distinction becomes clear when comparing two moments. The performance concentrates attention on a recognisable skill and the instant in which it can be displayed. Preparation involves holding positions, waiting or repeating an action that does not yet have the framework of a performance. Photographing both moments allows us to think of skill as something practised. The spectacular image no longer seems like an event that emerges without material preparation.
This does not turn every photograph into a denunciation of working conditions. The series shows activities; other documents would be needed to describe wages, contracts or power relations. Its interest lies in making work visible without deciding in advance how it should be judged. A demanding pose can be studied as an organisation of the body, but an isolated expression does not prove satisfaction, lasting exhaustion or rejection of the profession.
The contrast with Walter Cartier’s photographs is useful because both series bring together physical exposure and preparation. There is no need to assume that boxing and the circus are identical. What can be compared is the shift in attention: from the result the public will see to the actions that make it possible. Each feature nonetheless retains its own spaces, relationships and particular ways of presenting its participants.
Depth brings together the ringmaster and the acrobats
One image from the series, reproduced by the institutions organising Through a Different Lens, places a man in a suit and hat in the foreground, with several acrobats in the background. The catalogue identifies him as a ringmaster. He holds one hand beside his mouth, while behind him a bicycle on a wire and other suspended bodies can be seen. The framing allows us to observe two tasks at once, occupying different heights and scales.
The ringmaster’s proximity makes his gesture easy to read. The acrobats, smaller within the image, call for a different kind of attention: we have to follow wires, supports and the directions of their bodies. Depth thus distributes two centres of interest. The viewer can begin with the nearby face and continue towards the aerial act, without the photograph imposing a precise duration for either route.
The hand beside the mouth suggests that he is speaking, but the photograph does not preserve his words. Nor does it show whom he is addressing at that moment. It is worth maintaining this distinction: we see a pose consistent with announcing or calling out, but we do not hear an instruction. The gesture is interesting because it introduces a vocal action into a silent image and relates it to an activity taking place on another plane.
The sky sets off the acrobats’ silhouettes and makes their positions easier to recognise. At the same time, the wires and platform remind us that movement depends on a structure. The visual effect does not come solely from bodies apparently free in the air. It needs points of support and relationships of balance. The image allows us to study this cooperation without calculating heights or inferring undocumented safety conditions.
Calling the scene spontaneous would not explain how it was constructed, either. The photographer has chosen a position from which both actions fit within the same frame. That choice can be analysed even though we do not know whether he gave the participants instructions. The difference between framing a relationship and directing it completely is one of the issues explored in the selection and staging of Kubrick’s photographs.
A body can work, rest and be watched
The leisure activities described by the museum broaden the representation of the profession. A card game does not cancel out the professional identity of its participants, but shifts the focus of the image to another kind of relationship: spending time together, attending to small objects and organising a group around an activity. The spectacle is no longer the only situation in which the people photographed become visible.
The presence of children also introduces a different temporality from that of the performance. It does not allow us to reconstruct family relationships or personal histories without documentary identification. It does, however, prevent us from reducing the series to a collection of acts in the ring. In a reading of the series, work and everyday life sit close together, although no single photograph can explain exactly how they were divided over a full working day.
It also matters who is looking. A performer may look towards the camera, concentrate on an exercise or attend to someone else. These are different relationships with the act of photography. We should not turn everyone portrayed into an example of the same attitude. The comparison with Rosemary Williams’s public presentation helps us frame this question, although the circus setting should not be explained through the biography of another show-business figure.
Finally, later selection changes the series. An exhibition that privileges acrobatics will produce a different circus from one that arranges a sequence of rehearsals and breaks. To assess the printed feature, its pages must be consulted rather than replaced by a contemporary gallery. The surviving images allow us to study specific relationships between body, task and display; their original order, captions and omissions require checking against the edition under analysis.
Sources: Allyson Ross, Circus, Museum of the City of New York, 19 July 2011; Circus collection, 1948, group X2011.4.11327. Skirball Cultural Center and Museum of the City of New York, materials for Through a Different Lens: Stanley Kubrick Photographs, photograph How the Circus Gets Set, 1948.
View all articles in Kubrick the photographer: his work for Look magazine
