Spielberg and Kubrick: visual learning and professional friendship

Spielberg identified a specific sequence from Dr. Strangelove when discussing his war camera work. Their relationship combines learning as a filmgoer, technical comparison and conversations between filmmakers.

A recognised influence can refer to a specific sequence

In remarks to Paul Joyce in 1999, reproduced by DGA Quarterly, Spielberg recalled that Kubrick asked him about the cinematography of Saving Private Ryan. His answer linked that work both to Signal Corps military documentaries and to the assault on the base in Dr. Strangelove. The account identifies two points of reference, not a single exclusive origin.

The precision of the example matters. Dr. Strangelove contains very different spaces and visual treatments. Attributing a uniform appearance to the whole film would obscure the contrast between the base, the bomber and the War Room. The sequence Spielberg recalled belongs to one of those contexts: a ground action in which the image seems to have to adapt to movements, obstacles and events that overwhelm it.

The work of Gilbert Taylor in Dr. Strangelove allows us to study this aspect within its original production. Spielberg’s later statement adds something else: another filmmaker received and remembered a solution as a resource available to him. It does not prove that every shot in Saving Private Ryan derives from a specific shot, nor does it rule out the other references mentioned by the witness himself.

The retrospective nature of the recollection should also be preserved. Spielberg recounts a conversation and explains how he connects two work experiences. This source allows us to attribute the recognition to him, but it is no substitute for a production breakdown of either film. To move from testimony to formal comparison, it is worth looking at what information the camera organises in each sequence and what relationship it establishes with the bodies.

The war camera takes on a different meaning within each story

In the assault on the base in Dr. Strangelove, visual instability and obstacles in the terrain contrast with the abstraction of the command centres. Orders and procedures have consequences that other scenes present at a distance. The film can alternate between exposed bodies and characters discussing matters through maps, codes or communications. The change in treatment makes this separation perceptible.

The War Room, for example, allows us to observe positions and relationships within a wide composition. The battle outside demands a different kind of attention: locating a threat, following a movement and understanding an action that is partly interrupted. The contrast does not mean that one image is true and the other false. They are ways of organising the fiction that give the viewer different degrees of stability and orientation.

In the D-Day landing in Saving Private Ryan, the soldiers’ immediate experience is at the centre of an extended sequence. Movement, interruptions and the relationship between image and sound make it difficult to take in the whole calmly. The viewer receives fragments of action before being able to arrange them into a complete map. Confusion is part of the problem being represented, although the film carefully selects what it allows us to see at each moment.

Comparing these scenes makes it possible to recognise a technique without equating their purposes. Dr. Strangelove incorporates the action into a satire in which the institution turns its own rules into a danger. Spielberg’s film places the landing within a story of survival, loss and military mission. A documentary-style technique can contribute to both, but it does not automatically produce the same judgement about what is shown.

A study of Kubrick’s camera movements helps avoid an overly general description. Hand-held camera work, following a figure and changing the distance are not interchangeable terms. Moreover, the impression of urgency depends on the editing, the performances and the sound. Identifying a reference made by Spielberg does not justify attributing the whole experience of his sequence to the camera alone.

Professional conversation does not erase the difference between the filmmakers

The exchange Spielberg recalled shows a shift in position: someone who had learnt by watching a film later talks with its director about his own work. The relationship is no longer simply that of a viewer receiving a film. There is a specific question about how a result was achieved, and an answer that credits Kubrick with part of that learning, without presenting the new film as a reproduction of the model.

That kind of conversation does not require both filmmakers to share all their decisions, either. Recognising a solution can coexist with differences in pace, emotional construction or the relationship with the characters. Influence becomes more interesting when it helps us understand a particular choice, rather than being used to erase what separates the films. Admiring a technique is not the same as embracing an entire aesthetic programme.

The later professional relationship includes the development of A.I., but this case requires us to distinguish between the project’s different stages and the credits for the completed film, directed by Spielberg. The study of A.I.’s continuity and authorship addresses that specific issue. Its existence should not be used to attribute every decision in Spielberg’s cinema retrospectively to Kubrick, or to turn every conversation between them into a formal creative collaboration.

The remarks by Scorsese on Kubrick’s framing allow us to observe another kind of learning: attention to how a camera position organises a story. Spielberg’s account, by contrast, defines a combat sequence and its technical reception. Comparing them does not establish a hierarchy between influences; it shows that the same filmography can be read through different questions by those who later make their own films.

To assess the relationship, it is worth keeping three strands distinct: what Spielberg says, what the films allow us to compare and what documents a collaboration. The criteria for interpretation and evidence help ensure that none stands in for the others. The camera work in the assault on the base is a recognisable point of contact; the meaning it takes on in another story should be studied within that story and its own relationships between image, sound and action.

References: Steven Spielberg, remarks to Paul Joyce (1999), reproduced by Robert Koehler in ‘Kubrick’s Outsized Influence’, DGA Quarterly, autumn 2017. Films compared: Stanley Kubrick, Dr. Strangelove (1964); Steven Spielberg, Saving Private Ryan (1998). A.I. Artificial Intelligence (2001), directing credit.

View all articles in Kubrick in other filmmakers’ work and visual culture