Kubrick in Breaking Bad and Better Call Saul: techniques Gilligan has acknowledged

A general claim of influence needs specific examples. Gilligan has pointed to particular techniques; examining them does not mean attributing every shot in his series to Kubrick.

The first image poses a question before explaining the scene

In DGA Quarterly in 2017, Vince Gilligan linked to Kubrick the attention paid to a scene’s first image, central perspective, certain slow pull-backs and the ironic use of music. His statement identifies techniques, not an exhaustive list of episodes. The first step is to distinguish this acknowledged influence from the comparisons we can suggest when watching the series.

The opening of the Breaking Bad pilot offers an example of how an image can foreshadow a situation without making it immediately understandable. The trousers falling in the landscape and the vehicle crossing the space introduce an event whose causes we do not yet know. The sequence does not begin by explaining who Walter White is. It presents effects and makes us reconstruct later the path that led to them.

The question of the first image does not mean that every scene must begin with a close-up. It is the first element the viewer receives, whatever its scale. A landscape, an object or a face can set up a different expectation. Confusing the first image with a tight shot would reduce a narrative decision to a technical choice that does not, by itself, contain the same problem.

The opening of A Clockwork Orange offers a comparison with another way of managing revelation: a figure that initially dominates the frame is placed within a space and a group. Movement changes what we know about them. The link to Breaking Bad here is analytical, not a claim that one opening copies the other. In both, what matters is how an image gains context; the information added and the effect produced are different.

The framing can reveal a relationship without changing scene

The perspective and symmetry organise attention before a character acts. A central axis can make an institutional space legible or turn a figure into part of a structure that seems to exceed them. But the same order can be used for a joke, a wait or a threat. Geometry needs to be considered in relation to duration and to the positions of those who appear.

The pull-back zoom offers another possibility: widening the context without breaking temporal continuity. The viewer starts close to a detail and gradually discovers the conditions around it. The revelation does not necessarily depend on introducing completely new information. It can change the balance between something already known and the space that now contains it, altering how we assess the situation.

One documented case makes it important to avoid automatic attributions. In a 2022 conversation with David Canfield, Gilligan and cinematographer Paul Donachie explained that the pull-back in the scene with Jimmy and Kim in Carrot and Stick referred to the opening of The Godfather. The domestic setting transforms the initial solemnity. A technique that also brings Kubrick to mind has a different acknowledged reference here.

The distinction matters because it prevents technical similarity from becoming an infallible detector of influence. A slow zoom does not belong exclusively to one director. What one scene shares with another might be the technique, the contrast between beginning and end, or the dramatic situation. To attribute a specific homage, it is worth retaining the relevant testimony rather than replacing it with the reference that feels most familiar to the critic.

Collaboration is also visible in this example. Discussing a solution considered by Gilligan and Donachie is not the same as assigning every decision between them in advance, but it does avoid describing the result as an image produced without a team. Series bring together direction, cinematography, performance, design and editing. Acknowledging Kubrick within that process does not erase the contribution of those who turn an idea into a scene that can be made.

Music can separate what we see from how it is presented

The musical counterpoint allows an action to take on a different tone from the one its images would produce on their own. A laborious activity can seem effortless; harmful behaviour can be presented with a pleasing surface. A comparison with Kubrick should specify this relationship rather than call any familiar song ironic. The contrast can affect the rhythm, the lyrics, the situation or the song’s cultural associations.

The montage of Jimmy and Kim accompanied by ‘Something Stupid’ in Better Call Saul offers a useful comparison. The split screen lets us watch parallel routines while the song establishes continuity through sound. Sharing the same listening time is not the same as fully sharing an experience. The visual organisation makes connections and separations perceptible, but the accompaniment does not automatically resolve them.

At the end of Dr. Strangelove, the song and images can also conflict, but the scale and function are different. There, a familiar promise is set against collective destruction; in the Saul sequence, a relationship is explored through everyday habits. This comparison describes techniques and differences. It does not claim that the series’ montage is a documented reproduction of that ending.

The editing and rhythm make this interplay between techniques possible. A song does not work alone: what matters is which actions are selected, how long they last and when the sequence moves from one to another. The same is true of perspective or a zoom. Gilligan’s account allows us to recognise a conversation with Kubrick; the specific scenes show that this conversation coexists with other influences and with the particular demands of an ongoing television narrative.

References: Robert Koehler, ‘Kubrick’s Outsized Influence’, DGA Quarterly, Autumn 2017. David Canfield, ‘The Images of Better Call Saul: Vince Gilligan on Homage, Patience, and Payoffs’, Vanity Fair, 21 June 2022. Works discussed: Breaking Bad, pilot (2008); Better Call Saul, ‘Something Stupid’ (2018) and ‘Carrot and Stick’ (2022); A Clockwork Orange (1971); Dr. Strangelove (1964).

View all articles in Kubrick in other filmmakers’ work and visual culture