The cinephile relationship between Kubrick and Kurosawa is known in part through recollections by colleagues. These testimonies have value in their own right, but they do not justify reproducing letters whose text has not been consulted or inventing a dialogue between the two.
A testimony of admiration is not a signed list
Anthony Frewin described Kurosawa as a filmmaker whom Kubrick followed with sustained admiration. His testimony is recorded by Nick Wrigley in Stanley Kubrick, cinephile. This attribution allows us to speak of an opinion recalled by an identified colleague, not of a preference reconstructed solely from similarities between films.
In the same context, Frewin imagined which titles Kubrick might choose in a hypothetical situation of isolation. The form of the answer matters: it is the witness’s conjecture. Turning it into a new list of favourites compiled by Kubrick would change both the author of the selection and the degree of certainty with which it is presented.
The verification of attributions of taste requires those grammatical and documentary distinctions to be preserved. A statement about what someone would probably have chosen is not equivalent to a declaration of what they chose. Precision does not mean eliminating the recollection, but presenting it within the scope it had before being summarised.
It is also worth avoiding turning sustained admiration into outright approval. Following a filmmaker does not mean valuing all their films in the same way. The testimony points to an ongoing interest, but does not reconstruct every screening, every comment or all the changes in a personal view over time.
Recalled correspondence and correspondence consulted
Frewin recounted that Kubrick received a letter from Kurosawa in the 1990s and prepared a reply that he did not send before the Japanese filmmaker’s death. Here, the available source is Frewin’s published recollection. The text of those letters is not reproduced, nor is it claimed that their drafts have been examined.
This distinction makes it possible to ask precise questions without filling the gap. The account identifies the sender, recipient and general circumstances of a reply. It does not, by itself, establish every compliment, question or cinematic reference that the documents might have contained. Attributing specific words would require a reliable transcript or consultation of the relevant items.
The Kubrick Archive provides a context for researching correspondence and working materials, but the existence of an archive does not prove that an accessible, identified document exists there for every anecdote. A collection description and a letter that has been read are different levels of evidence. Research must indicate when a reference has been located and when its contents are actually known.
The testimonies of colleagues such as Jan Harlan and Frewin must also be kept separate. Their closeness to the director does not make them interchangeable voices speaking collectively. When information comes from one of them, attributing it simply to Kubrick’s circle removes the possibility of checking what was said and from what experience the speaker could have known it.
The difficulty of replying that Frewin describes needs no added dramatisation. We do not know what inner conversation accompanied each draft, or what would have happened if the letter had been sent. Acknowledging this limit preserves the human value of the account without turning reported correspondence into an invented biographical scene.
Possible comparisons that do not prove derivation
Rashomon and The Killing allow us to compare narratives that revisit events from different positions. The initial similarity is useful, but it can also mislead. In Rashomon, the versions introduce a problem of discrepancies between testimonies. In The Killing, temporal shifts help reconstruct an operation spread across several participants. Repetition does not serve exactly the same function in each film.
The voice-over in The Killing provides temporal coordinates that help locate the returns. In Rashomon, revisiting an event means hearing versions whose authority remains in dispute. It is not the number of returns that defines the device, but the relationship each one establishes between new information, trust and contradiction.
That difference changes the viewer’s role. In one case, they must assess accounts that do not fit together consistently; in the other, they must relate tasks and moments to understand how they connect. The comparison shows the possibilities of multiple narratives. It does not prove that Kubrick used one film as a template for the other, nor does it make his admiration for Kurosawa sufficient proof of such a relationship.
Seven Samurai and Paths of Glory offer another focused comparison: the organisation of a group facing violence. The conditions of belonging, the ability to make decisions and the relationship between those who command and those who face danger are different. An analysis of war and obedience needs to preserve these historical and narrative differences, rather than reducing both groups to the same structure.
In Kurosawa’s film, preparing a defence allows us to observe how cooperation and responsibility are negotiated between people in different positions. In Paths of Glory, the military hierarchy and the allocation of blame establish different relationships. We can compare how space and mise-en-scène make these conditions visible without attributing a single origin to each choice.
The relationship with Bergman serves, by contrast, as a reminder of the value of a published epistolary document. Not all of Kubrick’s expressions of admiration are supported by the same kind of available evidence. Responsible reading should not artificially equate them. It can recognise solid testimony as testimony, keep questions about correspondence open, and develop comparisons that explain both affinities and differences between the works.
Testimonial source: Anthony Frewin, statements recorded by Nick Wrigley in Stanley Kubrick, cinephile, Sight and Sound/BFI. The correspondence is presented as reported by this witness, without transcribing documents that have not been consulted. Films compared: Akira Kurosawa, Rashomon (1950) and Seven Samurai (1954); Stanley Kubrick, The Killing (1956) and Paths of Glory (1957).
View all articles in Artistic and literary reference points for Kubrick
