Kubrick and Max Ophuls: admiration and camera movement

Kubrick’s admiration for Max Ophuls is explicitly supported by his own statements. The formal question comes afterwards: what does a moving camera do with bodies, and what differences emerge when comparing scenes by the two filmmakers?

Admiration that identifies techniques

In his interview with Joseph Gelmis, published in The Film Director as Superstar, Kubrick expressed his admiration for the fluidity of Ophuls’s camera. The statement points to a specific aspect of his interest. It does not offer a list of copied shots or claim that all his camera movements should be explained by this single point of reference.

The word ‘fluidity’ describes an impression of continuity, but it needs to be developed to be useful in analysis. A camera can follow someone, move ahead of them, leave them behind or connect their action with another space. Two equally continuous movements can distribute information in opposite ways. Acknowledging an influence opens up the comparison; it does not determine in advance what we will find.

The study of Kubrick’s camera movements distinguishes between these functions. Attributing every tracking shot to Ophuls would reduce a variety of situations to a single biographical explanation. It would also obscure the fact that a technique can be learnt, transformed and combined with decisions arising from other working contexts.

Admiring a director does not require reproducing their tone. One can value a solution that relates camera and performers, then use a similar principle to create distance, menace or comedy. The most interesting connection is not always the superficial resemblance between two images, but how a learnt possibility changes when it enters another story.

Movement can make a social relationship visible

In Ophuls’s The Earrings of Madame de…, movement through salons and social gatherings connects bodies with conventions that bring them together and keep them apart. Movement does not simply follow an action that would exist in the same way without the camera. It shifts our attention within the space and makes perceptible a relationship that changes while people maintain their public demeanour.

The succession of dance meetings allows us to see how a repeated social form can take on a different emotional weight. The continuity of movement and the variations between occasions connect time, proximity and desire. This description is based on Ophuls’s film. It should not be presented as an explanation Kubrick gave of that specific sequence.

Barry Lyndon offers a useful contrast. Its characters also occupy spaces governed by position and appearance, but the mise-en-scène can maintain a distance that makes their place within a composition visible. When the frame widens, an intimate relationship is set within a larger material world. The comparison does not require us to claim that the zoom is a direct substitute for an Ophuls tracking shot.

The composition that changes during a shot helps clarify the difference. Camera movement can change perspective and trajectory; a change in focal length alters the visible field from a different spatial relationship. Both can reveal context, but they do not produce the same experience of movement. Talking about fluidity without distinguishing between the two operations would obscure some of the formal work.

In Paths of Glory, the advance through a trench organises the relationship between an officer and the soldiers. Continuity takes us through a succession of bodies and moments of waiting. Unlike the social circulation of a salon, this route is shaped by confinement, danger and military hierarchy. The moving technique takes on a different pressure, even though we can compare its ability to relate individuals to their surroundings.

Actors are not figures carried by the frame

A moving camera has to negotiate with the performed action. A turn of the head can prepare a shift in attention; a pause can turn an accompaniment into a conversation. The coordination is clear when the viewer understands why the bodies draw nearer or move apart, not merely when the technical movement seems flawless.

The study of rehearsals and preparation helps distinguish the visible result from documented procedures. A fluid scene does not prove that it was filmed without difficulty or that the camera’s path was decided before work with the performers began. Nor does it allow us to attribute a specific instruction to a director without evidence. Analysis can describe the coordination without inventing its production history.

Acting introduces a temporal dimension that prevents influence from being reduced to geometry. Two characters may cross the same space at different speeds, respond after a delay or hold a gaze after the frame has changed. These variations affect the dramatic relationship. The camera’s fluidity can make them more visible rather than absorbing them into a uniform movement.

We must also distinguish documented admiration from an exclusive lineage. Kubrick’s statement confirms a connection with Ophuls in the aspect it identifies. It does not rule out other influences or prove that the intention of every later scene was to remind viewers of an earlier work. The reference can function as an awareness of possibilities without appearing as a recognisable quotation.

A specific comparison can therefore raise questions that can be tested: what information does the movement add, when does the character holding our attention change, what distance does the camera maintain, and how does the space respond to the acting? These questions allow us to recognise affinities and differences between Ophuls and Kubrick without turning expressed admiration into an automatic explanation of an entire filmography.

Testimonial source: Joseph Gelmis, interview with Stanley Kubrick in The Film Director as Superstar, 1970, based on conversations and correspondence from 1968–1969. Films compared: Max Ophuls, The Earrings of Madame de… (1953); Stanley Kubrick, Paths of Glory (1957) and Barry Lyndon (1975).

View all articles in Artistic and literary reference points for Kubrick