Alex North and Kubrick: from Spartacus to the rejected score for 2001

Alex North composed music featured in Spartacus and prepared a score for 2001 that was not used in the released film. Their different fates should be kept in mind when listening to and describing both works.

A composition credit does not describe every use of music in a film

Alex North is credited as the composer of Spartacus. His work features in a film where combat, movement, intimate relationships and collective organisation create different dramatic needs. The credit identifies a specific musical responsibility. It does not mean that every decision about when the music enters, how long it lasts or how it is mixed came exclusively from the composer. The soundtrack is integrated with images, dialogue and effects through a process involving other roles and production decisions.

Music can link separate scenes, alter a period of waiting or accompany a shift in the relationships between characters. Analysing these functions means listening for where the music appears and what it shares with other sounds. A description based solely on the melody would overlook its cinematic use. The same piece can create a different experience outside the film, because the framing, action and information available to the viewer at that point in the story are no longer present.

Nor should North’s collaboration with Kubrick be mistaken for either man having unlimited freedom. Spartacus had a production structure and responsibilities that extended beyond the relationship between director and composer. Testimony or documents are needed to attribute a particular instruction. The film allows us to study the result, but does not automatically reveal the negotiations that produced it. Recognising this distinction avoids treating an effective scene as proof of a conversation for which there is no documentation.

The existence of original music also does not rule out other possible sources within a soundtrack. Attribution should be based on identified materials, rather than simply extending a main credit to everything that can be heard. In North’s case, precision is particularly important when turning to 2001, where the relationship between the score that was prepared and the released film changes radically. The two projects cannot be described using the same formula of ‘music for the film’.

Composing for 2001 does not mean being present in its final cut

North prepared original music for 2001: A Space Odyssey, but the released film did not use his score. Kubrick retained pre-existing pieces selected for the soundtrack. The composer’s work existed and can be studied, although it is not part of what audiences hear in the feature film. Calling it simply the soundtrack to 2001 without further clarification confuses the commission, the recording and its use in the film.

The composer spoke about the experience in an interview by Leslie Zador and David Cloud, published by the Los Angeles Free Press in 1970. His testimony offers a participant’s perspective on the process and on how he received its outcome. That attribution should be retained. It does not give us complete access to all of Kubrick’s decisions, nor does it justify reconstructing every conversation when the source does not describe it specifically.

Unused music can be compared with the film as a hypothesis about the relationship between sound and image, but such a comparison needs a caveat. Later placing a recording over images does not automatically restore a finished version that once existed. Decisions about duration, editing and mixing may be missing. The experiment can show expressive possibilities, but cannot prove what an approved alternative film would have been like. A piece of working material does not, by itself, contain all the steps needed for its final presentation.

Nor does the decision to reject the score prove that the composition lacked value in its own right. A selection decision responds to a particular film and production process, whereas the music can be heard according to other criteria. The opposite claim would be equally imprecise: valuing the score outside the feature film does not prove that using it would have made a better film. These are different questions, with different subjects and criteria. Keeping them separate avoids turning history into an overly simple retrospective contest.

Later releases preserve recordings that need to be identified

When considering disc releases of unused music, it is important to establish the provenance of the recording. An original recording from the sessions and a later performance of the score are different objects, even if they share the same composed material. The publication date does not necessarily match the recording date, either. Without this distinction, a listener may attribute interpretative choices made decades later to 1968, or treat a reconstruction as if it were the copy prepared during production.

The Intrada edition announced for 2007 presents the original monaural recording of North’s work for 2001. Its notes credit Henry Brant with orchestration and conducting. These credits should be retained: composing, orchestrating and conducting a performance are not interchangeable activities. Brant’s contribution does not erase North’s composition, just as North’s name should not subsume all the roles of those who contributed to the recording.

The notes accompanying an edition establish what material it offers and how it has been presented, but they do not replace the complete history of the commission. Listening to the album also does not prove the final placement of every excerpt within a non-existent film version. Specific correspondence would require synchronisation documents or identified instructions. The music can be studied in detail without inventing an alternative edit or filling gaps through approximate matches in duration.

North’s work with Kubrick is thus defined by two different professional outcomes: a composition incorporated into Spartacus and work prepared for 2001 that was not used in the release. The comparison allows us to discuss collaboration, selection and later circulation without confusing their different stages. Credits, testimony and disc notes provide complementary evidence. Precision means always naming which music, which recording and what relationship to the film is being described before assessing its effects or proposing associations.

Sources: credits for Spartacus (1960) and 2001 (1968); Alex North, interview by Leslie Zador and David Cloud, Los Angeles Free Press, 27 November 1970; Intrada, announcement and notes for the 2007 release of the original recording of music unused in 2001.

View all articles in Kubrick’s composers and musical collaborators