2001 was initially shown in a longer version and was cut shortly after its release. To compare running times, it is necessary to distinguish narrative footage from presentation elements shown in the cinema.
Release and changes in the first few days
Press sources gathered by the AFI catalogue document that Kubrick made cuts after the first screenings in April 1968. Various contemporary records mention approximately nineteen minutes being removed, although published running times do not always refer to the same set of elements. This information must be presented in context: a figure on its own may include or exclude the overture, intermission or exit music. The organisation of the screening explains why these components are not equivalent to fictional scenes.
The changes were made at a time when the film was already being seen by critics and audiences. This makes it possible to compare reactions to different presentations, but does not justify claiming that every attendee saw the same initial version. The distribution of prints and cinema programming introduced differences. A historical reconstruction should identify the date, place and running time when referring to a specific screening. The structure of the movements belongs to narrative analysis and should not be confused with the material history of these changes.
What can be said about the deleted scenes
Contemporary press reports and accounts from viewers at the first screenings described differences in passages involving the Discovery and the conflict with HAL. These accounts are valuable, but need to be attributed. A viewer may remember a scene only partially or mix their experience with information learned later. Editing documents and surviving prints offer another kind of evidence. To claim that a sequence was filmed, it is not enough to find it in a script; to claim that it was screened, evidence linked to an exhibited version is needed.
The history of the cuts must also distinguish material prepared for release from proposals discarded before the final version. The scientific interviews planned as a prologue belong to a different process. A scene removed after a screening and an idea that was never filmed cannot be added together as though they formed one and the same lost version. Caution prevents the difference in running time from becoming an imaginary catalogue of scenes whose existence has not been verified.
Comparing versions requires distinguishing at least four possible states of a scene: written, prepared for filming, filmed and screened. A script may retain material that was never filmed. A filmed scene may be absent from every known edit. A passage shown at an early screening may disappear from later prints. The evidence required differs in each case. The April 1968 press reports document cuts made after the release, but do not automatically turn every draft of the project into a lost scene. The material history of the film requires these distinctions to be preserved.
Contemporary reports mentioned changes to scenes involving the Discovery and the conflict with HAL. These references can be compared with audience recollections and production documents. However, a reconstruction should not treat an isolated account as an exact description of all the footage removed. Memories of a screening may be partial, and surviving prints do not always date from the same time. Identifying the location and the medium helps to put each claim in context. The difference between versions is a documentation problem, not an invitation to invent scenes to make up a running time.
The overture, intermission and exit music add a further complication to the calculations. Two records may show different running times because one includes elements of the screening that the other omits. A responsible comparison must separate these components before calculating the number of minutes removed. The history of 2001 allows us to say that cuts were made, but calls for caution when specifying their extent and content. The aim is not to reconstruct an imaginary version from figures, but to identify which changes are supported by concrete evidence.
Running time, preservation and responsible comparison
A home-video copy, a 70 mm screening and a catalogue entry may give different running times for reasons that do not imply narrative changes. The intermission may or may not be counted; presentation music may be added to the figure; even cataloguing practices may vary. The photochemical print presented by Nolan raises further questions about which version was intended to be recreated and how that aim was documented. Comparison requires identifying the medium and the elements included, not subtracting two figures and automatically attributing the result to lost scenes.
The history of 2001 allows for documented changes without the need to create a legend around a hidden definitive cut. The released film and its modifications are concrete historical objects. Research can acknowledge the limits of the available information and leave open questions about materials that have not been consulted. This precision makes it possible to study how a long film was adapted for commercial circulation without confusing recollections, scripts, prints and published running times.
Information about the first screenings should retain the provenance of each figure. A running time taken from a review and one from a screening record may measure different elements. Without identifying the screening, the medium and the components included, subtracting one from the other cannot reliably establish which images disappeared.
View all articles in 2001: A Space Odyssey: characters, images and the making of the journey
