Why 2001 lets actions run their course: tasks, waiting and the perception of time

2001 devotes long stretches to actions that other films would sum up, while at the same time removing vast periods with cuts. This combination defines a particular experience of time.

Actions the editing allows us to observe

The orbital docking provides an example of sustained duration. The film shows a manoeuvre from different points of view and allows the viewer to observe gradual changes in position. The narrative information could be conveyed with a brief shot and a sentence, but Kubrick chooses to turn the process into an experience. The analysis of the docking examines its relationship with the waltz; here, what matters is that the action retains its own sense of time and that the audience can perceive the scale of the movement. Waiting does not necessarily mean that nothing is happening: small variations acquire significance when the framing gives them attention.

Something similar happens with the Discovery’s routines. Exercise, meals, observation and movement are shown as actions that take time. The film does not require us to interpret every second as a symbol. It lets us see how the characters occupy an environment designed to sustain a prolonged mission. Repetition establishes a normality that will be needed for the later crisis to have perceptible consequences. Without prior experience of that routine, the disruption of a procedure would have less impact.

Vast ellipses set against minute gestures

The scale of certain scenes contrasts with extraordinary leaps in time. The story can omit vast periods of human history and then pause over a specific manoeuvre. This difference makes it impossible to measure the pace of 2001 solely by how quickly its plot advances. The film alternates between two scales: a history of transformations separated by enormous distances, and an experience of actions observed at almost their everyday duration. The study of its major movements helps to place these changes within the overall structure.

The scene of Poole’s birthday shows another use of time. The message introduces neither a malfunction nor an immediate threat, but it offers a human measure of isolation. Attention shifts to an emotional relationship mediated by a screen. The film can spend time on it because life on board is not simply a matter of progressing towards a narrative goal. It is also made up of activities whose repetition helps us understand what it means to live aboard the spacecraft for months.

The duration of an action changes what information the viewer can obtain. A brief shot allows us to recognise an object or a general movement; a longer one lets us observe changes in speed, position and relationship with the surroundings. In 2001, the movements of spacecraft and the routines inside them benefit from this sustained attention. The audience can appreciate details that a faster narrative would have reduced to passing cues. The film uses time as part of space: the distance between two objects is also perceived through how long it takes for their relationship within the frame to change.

Vast ellipses produce the opposite effect. The story can omit entire processes and let a cut establish a connection between eras. This difference requires us to distinguish represented time from running time. A leap of millions of years can take only an instant, while an everyday manoeuvre is given several shots. The film does not seek to maintain a constant proportion between these two measures. It uses their contrast to change the way we look. The viewer moves from a rapid association to slow observation without the work needing to justify every change verbally.

How this rhythm is received depends on specific circumstances. A large-format screening, a home screen or an interrupted viewing can all affect attention, even though the editing remains the same. The film offers identifiable formal devices, but does not dictate a universal response. To analyse duration, it is worth describing scenes and transitions before passing judgement on slowness. What matters is how time allows us to perceive routines, scale and silence, and how these elements prepare the later rupture of a normality that the audience has had the chance to get to know.

The viewer’s time is not a universal measure

Duration can produce concentration, unease, impatience or contemplation, depending on the audience and the viewing conditions. There is no obligatory response that can be attributed to all viewers. The staging does, however, allow us to describe specific devices: shots that are held, movements that progress slowly, little dialogue and cuts that omit entire transitions. These devices change which details become visible and how much effort viewers must contribute to interpret what is happening.

The dossier on the release versions examines cuts and differences in running time, a separate issue from the perception of time within a particular print. A judgement about slowness should not be confused with an objective measurement of total running time. The rhythm of 2001 depends on the relationship between the times shown and the times omitted. The film can make a brief manoeuvre seem lengthy and make an enormous historical transformation happen in an instant. This tension is part of its narrative form, not a flaw or virtue that can be established with a stopwatch alone.

View all articles in 2001: A Space Odyssey: characters, images and the making of the journey