Anthony Burgess prepared an adaptation of his novel before Kubrick filmed A Clockwork Orange. That screenplay represents a distinct stage in the project, not the final shooting script.
The 1969 draft as an independent document
The story of A Clockwork Orange includes a screenplay associated with Anthony Burgess and dated 1969. Its existence makes it possible to distinguish the novelist’s involvement in attempts to adapt the book from the film Kubrick completed in 1971. An author’s draft may propose dialogue, scenes and visual solutions, but it does not prove that those proposals were accepted, filmed or retained in the final cut.
Archive catalogues and studies describing the document provide information about its identification, chronology and relationship to other materials. This information is valuable, but it is not the same as reading every handwritten or typed page in full. Where a specific difference has not been verified against the complete text, it should be presented as a possibility for further research, not as a lost scene from the film.
The pre-production context includes attempts to bring the novel to the screen that did not come to fruition. The history of rights and projects in the 1960s helps explain why different proposals may have circulated. Burgess’s screenplay should be identified by its author and date, without automatically attributing to it decisions made during a later production.
A literary proposal is not a shooting record
Adapting a novel involves choices about the narrator, language, scenes and length. Burgess knew Alex’s world from writing the original and could carry some of that voice into a dramatic format. However, film requires actions, settings and timings to be resolved in ways that literary prose can describe differently. An earlier screenplay documents one possible solution to those problems, not a film that physically existed.
The distinction between written, filmed, cut and released is particularly important in this case. A scene in a draft may have been rejected before filming; a scene may have been filmed and then removed; a text may be published later with changes. Each claim requires a different kind of evidence. The absence of a passage from the final cut does not prove that it was filmed or that an institution censored it.
The screenplay worked on by Kubrick has its own history of versions and annotations. Comparing the two requires identified documents, not merely a similarity between their titles. Burgess’s work helps us understand the range of adaptation possibilities, while Kubrick’s text belongs to later writing and production decisions.
What can be compared with the film
A responsible comparison begins by establishing the document: its author, attributed date, archive, version and the extent to which it has been consulted. A sequence described in the document can then be compared with the corresponding episode in the film, if both are known directly. Changes to Alex’s voice, the choice of characters or the setting of a scene would be relevant observations, provided they are supported by verifiable passages.
Discussion of the novel’s final chapter has become a separate issue. The film ending and Chapter 21 are at the heart of that debate, and prevent an earlier screenplay from being used as automatic proof of what Kubrick intended to do with the ending. The relationship between book and screen has more dimensions than this well-known difference.
Burgess’s draft is above all evidence of earlier creative work. It makes it possible to study how the work circulated and the possibility of a different adaptation, but it does not authorise the reconstruction of unseen scenes or the attribution of all its proposals to Kubrick. Documentary accuracy depends on keeping the project’s stages separate and stating which materials have actually been consulted.
An adaptation screenplay may preserve solutions responding to imagined production conditions, rather than those that ultimately existed. For example, a location direction does not prove that the building was booked; complete dialogue does not prove that actors rehearsed it. This distinction is particularly important for projects with several creative leads over the years. The history of a document should not be written retrospectively as if it knew the film’s eventual fate.
A dated version must also be distinguished from a copy archived at a later date. Collections may receive materials through donation, purchase or reorganisation, and their current descriptions may use standardised titles that do not appear exactly in the original. The catalogue entry helps locate the document and establish its general characteristics; comparing specific phrases requires access to the text and verification that it is complete.
Research into drafts is valuable even when it cannot reconstruct an alternative film. It helps identify adaptation questions that were already present before filming: how to translate an inner voice, which scenes require visual representation and how to sustain a cinematic pace. These questions can be verified as working problems without attributing to Burgess solutions that have not been read in his manuscript.
Comparisons between versions should also record whether a difference concerns the content or the document’s physical presentation. Different pagination, a new cover or a typographical correction do not necessarily amount to a revision of the scene. Identifying such variations avoids exaggerating the importance of changes that do not affect the narrative.
View all articles in A Clockwork Orange: characters, violence and cinematic form
