The preparation for Aryan Papers left behind concrete working documents. Reading them makes it possible to reconstruct tasks and partial decisions without treating every name, photograph or budget as confirmation that production was going ahead.
Preparation progressed across departments, each at a different pace
Aryan Papers was not merely an idea mentioned in an interview. The Stanley Kubrick Archive’s SK/18/2 collection preserves research, writing and organisational materials gathered during its development. Their variety demonstrates sustained activity. It also calls for a less uniform picture of the process: costume research could be progressing while questions about the script or the most suitable location for a sequence remained open.
The novel Wartime Lies and its adaptation provided characters and situations, but bringing them into a production meant breaking down what was needed. A place described in literary terms had to become a filming possibility. An era evoked in words needed clothing, objects and surfaces. These tasks could draw on the same text without all their solutions being approved at the same time.
The dates and types of documents help distinguish different stages of progress. An enquiry letter records a question; a reply may establish availability; a budget explores financial conditions. Grouping them all under the word ‘confirmed’ erases relevant information. Preparation can be extensive and still retain incompatible alternatives that would make sense only while awaiting a later decision.
The catalogue also contains incomplete writing materials. The existence of an art department or tests with an actress therefore does not mean that a final script was ready for every day of filming. For a film that was never made, the production history must be pieced together from these different paces, not from some supposed uniform countdown to the first day of shooting.
Cast, clothing and locations: evidence of different kinds
Johanna ter Steege appears in costume tests relating to Tania. These provide material evidence of work with the actress on that character. File SK/18/2/3/6/5 brings together costume research and photographs of tests arranged in relation to scenes. This association makes it possible to study how an appearance was being prepared, but it is not the same as Tania’s performance in a completed sequence.
There is a different kind of evidence for Joseph Mazzello. Document SK/18/2/4/3 is a fax dated 6 July 1993 concerning his schedule on Shadowlands, at a time when he was being considered for Maciek. Its historical value lies in showing that his availability was checked. It contains no performance of the character and does not prove that Mazzello and ter Steege filmed a Kubrick feature together.
The casting tapes catalogued in the collection should not automatically be confused with tests filmed for Aryan Papers. A selection made to assess a performer may include excerpts from earlier work. The label and description of each item matter: a face appearing on a tape associated with the project does not make every image on that tape material produced specifically for it.
Location documentation adds another area of research. Jan Schlubach’s correspondence from August 1991, preserved as SK/18/2/2/10, includes information about open-air museums in Berlin and Denmark, maps and photographs. This identifies a specific search task. It does not prove that all those places were selected for the film, nor does it justify assigning the correspondent any role that appears in another project.
From historical detail to a production that remained open-ended
The costume work calls for three questions to be kept separate: what a person from a particular period might wear, what a character needs in a scene, and what works in practical terms for filming. Magazine and catalogue clippings mainly address the first. Costume tests make it possible to move towards the other two, although their results cannot be assessed as if the film had already been edited.
The Cinémathèque française identifies Barbara Baum as being involved in costume preparation and describes an interest in original garments. This search did not eliminate the need for selection and adaptation. A period piece can provide information about material and cut, but it needs to be considered in relation to the character and the action. Its age alone does not guarantee that it is the right solution for every scene in the project.
Location photographs also serve as an intermediary. They make it possible to compare options without requiring the director to be physically present at every location. The framing may show a useful façade while leaving out access difficulties or modern features. A photograph is a decision-making tool, not a complete account of the conditions a day’s work would have involved.
The postponement of Aryan Papers interrupted the possibility of seeing how these tasks would have been coordinated during filming. What survives makes it possible to identify real preparatory work, but not to reconstruct a finished film. Plans and filmed results can differ for reasons that become apparent only when performers, locations and technical requirements come together in practice.
The archives of unrealised projects reveal this dimension of cinema: work exists before finished narrative images do. In Aryan Papers, that work left behind schedule enquiries, costume research, location studies and writing materials. Describing each item according to its function gives a more accurate measure of progress than simply claiming that everything was ready or that nothing had gone beyond the idea.
References: University of the Arts London, Stanley Kubrick Archive, SK/18/2; Tania research, SK/18/2/3/6/5; fax concerning Joseph Mazzello, SK/18/2/4/3; Schlubach correspondence, SK/18/2/2/10; casting tapes, SK/18/2/4/5. La Cinémathèque française, Aryan Papers: Method.
View all articles in Aryan Papers: the adaptation Kubrick never filmed
