The collaboration between Kubrick and Frederic Raphael left behind pages, phone calls and revisions, not a single session in which the screenplay was settled. The written materials need to be placed in context before they are compared with the film.
The conversation continues once the pages have been written
Frederic Raphael recalled a collaboration sustained mainly by telephone and by sending pages by fax. His account sets the writing apart from the familiar image of two authors working at the same time at one desk. A proposal could be written, sent, read and discussed again. The interval between these steps is part of the process: it allows a scene to be assessed before deciding whether to keep it, expand it or rewrite it.
The co-writer’s recollection is a source about his experience, not a complete transcript of every conversation. His retrospective assessments should be distinguished from dated documents. The archive preserves a series of correspondence and screenplay pages that includes comments, requests for revisions and submissions. Taken together, these materials reveal an iterative collaboration without giving one person’s memory absolute control over the chronology or every final decision.
The catalogue description mentions a letter from Kubrick in June 1995 about various sequences, followed by later submissions from Raphael. It is evidence of revision, but the catalogue is no substitute for reading each page. Knowing that a scene was discussed does not prove which version was accepted or whether it was filmed. The documentation needs to be followed through its various stages: proposal, comment, new draft and possible connection with the shooting material.
The comparison between Schnitzler and the film examines two works that can be read or watched in their entirety. The screenplay process raises a different question: how possible solutions were explored between them. An adaptation decision may have gone through several alternatives before taking its released form. An idea’s presence in a draft remains of interest even if it later disappears, but it should not be presented as a deleted scene from a completed cut.
Inventing a past for Ziegler does not create a real case file
Raphael said that he wrote a fictional dossier, made to look like an FBI report, to give Ziegler a backstory. The anecdote describes a tool of invention: constructing information about a character that helps to explore his position and possible actions. The document was not an authentic case file discovered by the team, nor evidence of real people’s activities. Its form imitated a documentary genre in order to develop a fiction.
Material of this kind can be useful without being incorporated literally into the screenplay. A writer can explore relationships, motives or background that will never be explained to the viewer. Preparatory writing is not the same as canonical information about the released story. To establish which parts of Ziegler’s past belong to the film, we must look at what it shows and at what its characters claim, while keeping the two distinct.
The final conversation between Ziegler and Bill offers an interested explanation within the fiction. The fact that the screenwriter prepared background material does not turn that explanation into an omniscient voice. A scene can be written to make a character persuasive while still leaving room for doubt. Preparatory work helps create a coherent presence, but it does not require the viewer to take every word as true.
There is also a difference between a proposed scene and its execution. Dialogue can change as it is revised, performed and edited. Raphael’s recollection of alternatives shows that the exchange was not fixed from the outset. It does not justify assigning exact percentages of authorship or deciding which line would have remained unchanged throughout every version without consulting the relevant texts.
Adapting a narrative voice calls for formal decisions
The transformation of Traumnovelle’s narrator illustrates a problem the screenplay had to solve: how to make thoughts and doubts perceptible without simply turning the prose into a running commentary. A response might take the form of dialogue, reaction or situation. Writing a visible action does not mean mechanically replacing each sentence with a shot. It changes what the viewer can verify and what they must infer from behaviour.
The title is also part of this process of selection. Raphael recalled an alternative he proposed before Kubrick made his choice. The page on the title Eyes Wide Shut examines that recollection and the ways it can be interpreted. The existence of another title does not imply that there was another completed film. It is an example of how a work can seek its mode of presentation while its scenes and relationships are still being discussed.
The catalogued materials make it possible to trace stages without pretending to have read documents that are missing. If a reference mentions enclosed pages that are not preserved in that file, their contents cannot be reconstructed from the subject of a letter. Similarly, a request for a rewrite attests to a need expressed at a particular time, not to the solution ultimately adopted. Research into the screenplay must preserve these documentary gaps.
The writing of Eyes Wide Shut can therefore be described as a succession of considered decisions: starting from a work, proposing changes, discussing them and returning to the pages. The released screenplay does not automatically reveal all its alternatives; the archive does not turn every alternative into filmed images. Distinguishing between these objects makes it possible to study Raphael and Kubrick’s work without turning an anecdote about invention into a historical revelation, or an ordinary revision in the process into evidence of a hidden film.
References: Stanley Kubrick, Eyes Wide Shut (1999), original English version and film credits. Frederic Raphael, conversation with James Bell published in Sight and Sound, 13 November 2019. University of the Arts London, Stanley Kubrick Archive, SK/17/1/17, ‘FR SK Correspondence and Script Pages’, catalogue description.
View all articles in Eyes Wide Shut (1999): a guide to the film
