The Burning Secret: Kubrick and Harris’s project

Burning Secret was an adaptation project based on Stefan Zweig’s novella. A screenplay identified by Nathan Abrams documents the writing by Kubrick and Calder Willingham, with James B. Harris as the intended producer.

A dated screenplay changes the available evidence

The story of Burning Secret does not depend solely on a list of films Kubrick wanted to make. In 2018, Bangor University reported that Nathan Abrams had identified a screenplay dated 24 October 1956, bearing the MGM Screenplay Department stamp. The document was attributed to Kubrick and Calder Willingham, with Harris as producer and Kubrick as the intended director. It is evidence of writing, not of filming.

This distinction makes it possible to assess how far the project had progressed without exaggerating. A screenplay can be developed and still require financing, a cast or a production decision. The existence of dated pages does not prove that all those conditions had been met. Nor does it prove that every written scene would have remained unchanged during a subsequent production, since work on a film can continue to alter the text.

The project belongs to the partnership between James B. Harris and Kubrick. Placing it in that context helps recognise a shared search for works and opportunities, rather than describing it as an isolated idea of the director’s. The producer, the collaborating writer and the studio all form part of its history. The fact that a film was never made does not erase the roles that had already contributed to its preparation.

The news about the document also calls for a distinction between loss of access and the loss of a film. What was identified was a screenplay whose location or integrity was not sufficiently known to those researching the project. No footage from an unknown feature film came to light. Materials from unrealised projects can change our historical understanding without thereby becoming a secret filmography.

Zweig presents an unequal relationship between knowing and being used

The source is Zweig’s novella, published in 1913. Its central situation brings together a boy, his mother and a man who uses his approach to the son in an attempt to reach her. The friendship offered to the child has a purpose he does not fully share. This imbalance of information shapes the conflict before it becomes necessary to assign any character a complete psychological explanation.

The boy may interpret as personal interest what functions as a means for the adult. When the attention shifts, the relationship can no longer sustain the expectations it created. This structure makes it possible to explore exclusion, trust and manipulation. It should not be described as a seductive game without consequences: the child is in a vulnerable position because he does not have the same knowledge or the same ability to decide the rules.

The adaptation described by Abrams moved the action to a contemporary American setting and turned the source’s baron into an insurance salesman. This change affects the signs of authority and respectability available to the character. It is not enough to change place names; a version set in another environment must reconstruct what makes trust credible and how a person presents themselves to a family.

The analysis can set out these consequences without inventing dialogue from the screenplay. The change of setting is documented; the words, gestures and duration of a particular scene require consultation of that version. The writing of adaptations and treatments helps to distinguish a general decision from all the specific solutions it would have required. A research summary is no substitute for reading the document in full.

Cancellation does not turn the text into a completed work

The production associated with MGM did not go ahead. The available information supports the claim that adaptation work existed and was interrupted, but does not allow the decision to be reduced automatically to a single cause. The source’s sexual content, production conditions and contractual relationships may feature in accounts of the project; their precise significance must be attributed to specific documents or testimony, not inferred from the plot.

Nor can the question of why it was not filmed be answered by declaring that it would have been a masterpiece or a failure. Such judgements imagine a film that does not exist. A screenplay allows us to analyse structure and situations, but does not fully contain the experience of performance, sound and editing. The distinction remains necessary, even when the director’s name invites expectations of particular approaches.

The relationship with One-Eyed Jacks shows another form of interruption. In that case, a development collaboration took place, followed by a film directed by someone else. Burning Secret should not automatically be classified in the same way. Two projects close to one another in a professional career can leave different kinds of evidence and call for different historical accounts, even when they share writers or a period of seeking finance.

Lunatic at Large is also a different kind of material: a treatment associated with Jim Thompson. Comparing it with a dated screenplay helps to show that the category of unrealised work encompasses very different stages of development. None should be judged solely by the possibility of becoming a new production today, because that possibility does not change what happened during Kubrick’s time.

Burning Secret can be studied as an early adaptation decision: choosing Zweig, working with Willingham and moving a conflict of trust and desire into another social context. Any affinities a reader finds with later films are critical comparisons, not automatic proof of material being reused. The fact that secures its place in this history is a specific piece of writing, while the film that might have resulted from it remains unrealised.

References: Stefan Zweig, Brennendes Geheimnis / Burning Secret (1913). Nathan Abrams, research presented in ‘Professor Discovers Lost Kubrick Screenplay’, Bangor University, 16 July 2018; description of the screenplay dated 24 October 1956. This account distinguishes published information about the document from a reconstruction of scenes that have not been consulted.

View all articles in Other Scripts and Projects by Stanley Kubrick