Children’s stories and pursuit in The Shining

Jack brings the voice of a fairy tale into his attack on the door. This explicit allusion can be compared with other forms of loss, refuge and orientation, while always distinguishing what is said on screen from a critical reading.

A reference spoken by the character

During the attack on the bathroom door, Jack uses phrases recognisable from the story of the three little pigs. The allusion does not depend on finding a hidden figure in the set design. It is built into the way he speaks and turns resistance to a domestic barrier into a verbal depiction of pursuit. Someone who should belong to the home takes on the role of a threat demanding to enter from the other side.

The familiarity of the tale changes the tone. The words may sound playful or theatrical while the accompanying action is dangerous. Their coexistence makes it impossible to comfortably separate a playful voice from violent behaviour. Jack seems to enjoy playing a recognisable role, but Wendy is not taking part in an agreed performance. The distance between the attacker’s tone and the situation of the person taking refuge creates a particular kind of unease.

The door gives the reference a visible correspondence. One person is trying to preserve an interior space, while another insists on crossing its boundary. However, the film does not need to recreate every episode of the tale for the allusion to work. There are no three equivalent houses, nor a complete adaptation of its characters. The connection is concentrated in a situation and a few words, not in a system that explains every object in the Overlook.

The location of the danger also changes. In many children’s stories, the house separates the protected world from the threatening outdoors. Here, the pursuit begins within family life and forces people to seek ever smaller refuges. The comparison is useful because it describes a specific reversal, not because it turns every member of the Torrance family into a fixed character in a fable. The objects involved in the confrontation retain material functions that go beyond the literary reference.

Getting lost, leaving traces and learning a space

The film also introduces the vocabulary of orientation through Wendy’s reference to leaving a trail of breadcrumbs during a visit to the service areas. The association with Hansel and Gretel is recognisable, but it initially appears as a joke about the abundance of routes. The verbal gesture does not prove that the film is secretly adapting that tale. It does, however, show that the problem of finding one’s way can already be expressed through an image from childhood.

That initial lightness contrasts with the importance that finding one’s way later acquires. A building that seemed to offer comfort and resources becomes difficult to inhabit when the family needs to locate someone, avoid an encounter or find an exit. The resemblance to a tale of being lost belongs to the way the experience is structured. It does not require every corridor to correspond to a forest, or an interpretation to turn the entire hotel into a literal equivalent.

The maze makes it possible to distinguish learning from retrospective interpretation. Danny and Wendy walk through it before the place takes on its final function. The viewer may recall that experience when the boy once again needs to find his way. The connection with fairy tales then emerges as a comparison between narrative problems: getting lost, recognising signs and making use of what one has learnt. Danny’s actions retain their logic within the film without needing an external explanation to replace it.

A careful reading must also acknowledge differences. The boy does not have a complete verbal map given to him by a protective adult, and the escape does not simply restore an unblemished normality. The film holds on to uncertainty and loss. Comparing it with a form of children’s story does not require us to attribute to it an equivalent moral ending or a single lesson intended for the audience to decipher.

The familiar can become threatening without losing its form

Diane Johnson has recalled discussions during the writing process about fear and reading related to the Gothic and the uncanny. This testimony helps situate certain questions in the process of development, but does not certify that every resemblance to a fairy tale came from an explicit, recorded decision. Production documentation and later analysis are distinct levels. The article on the Gothic and the uncanny explores this distinction between documented antecedents and interpretative frameworks.

Jack’s voice shows concretely how something familiar can be altered. There is no need to invent an incomprehensible phrase to unsettle us: it is enough to use a familiar register in a situation where it no longer offers security. The viewer recognises the pattern and, at the same time, realises that its tone does not respond to Wendy’s fear. Shared language no longer guarantees a shared experience of the event.

Childhood therefore does not appear as a purely innocent realm to which the story could return. Danny already knows unpleasant stories, receives images that he struggles to communicate, and has to decide what to do with them. Fairy tales are one possible way of organising danger, not a closed world existing apart from it. Danny’s experience brings together knowledge and perceptions that cannot be reduced to a single narrative tradition.

Nor does every double figure, toy or drawing require a literary key. The strength of a comparison depends on defining the connection precisely: a recognisable phrase, a similar situation or a shared narrative device. When that precision is lost, anything can seem to confirm a theory. Distinguishing between degrees of evidence allows us to retain suggestive associations without presenting them as the film’s secret explanation.

References to children’s stories make the pursuit particularly unsettling because they use forms that the audience can recognise immediately. Refuge, the door and the path belong to widely shared narrative experiences. The Shining places them within a family and a hotel where promises of protection deteriorate. The reading becomes more precise when it follows these local transformations and accepts that none of them exhausts what happens on screen.

References: Stanley Kubrick, The Shining (1980). Scenes exclusive to the US cut are identified in the text. Diane Johnson, interview with The Terror Trap, The Shining Adapted; interview published by Jung Page.

View all articles in The Shining (1980): film guide