The critical reception of The Shining: disagreements and interpretive criteria

The reception of The Shining cannot be reduced to an initial rejection followed by unanimous approval. Critical writing raises different questions about the acting, horror, structure and adaptation.

The opening reviews did not speak with one voice

Richard Combs’s review, preserved by Sight and Sound, offers a way to begin with a contemporary text rather than reconstructing 1980 through the lens of a later reputation. His analysis asks where the film sits within Kubrick’s cinema and attends to a tension between isolation and expansiveness. The hotel does not merely confine its inhabitants: it also places them in spaces that seem to exceed their scale and their capacity for understanding.

This approach shifts the criteria for evaluation. A film can be judged by the psychological continuity of its characters, the effectiveness of its shocks or the spatial experience it creates. Combs does not reduce his reading to counting how many scares it delivers. The question of whether Kubrick may have changed allows for critical uncertainty without automatically turning it into rejection. A text can debate, find problems and recognise interest at the same time.

Nicholson’s performance offers an example of this difference in criteria. A deliberately heightened performance may be considered excessive if a gradual, naturalistic transformation is expected. It can also be studied as a way of introducing menace, humour and distance from the outset. Nicholson’s voice and shifts in register allow these two approaches to be compared through specific techniques, without deciding that volume or gesture has a fixed value regardless of the scene.

To discuss the initial reception, it would be necessary to bring together texts and contexts, rather than using a single review as the spokesperson for all viewers. Combs’s criticism offers an identifiable argument. It does not provide an audience survey or a complete measure of the film’s commercial performance. Distinguishing between these kinds of evidence prevents an aesthetic judgement from becoming a claim about how many people enjoyed or rejected the film.

Later readings that change the questions

Roger Ebert included The Shining in his Great Movies series on 18 June 2006. In that essay, he focuses on the difficulty of establishing a fully reliable perspective on what has happened. His reading places the story’s uncertainty among the reasons for its power to unsettle. It is a dated critical intervention, not proof that all earlier comments were negative or that an entire country changed its mind at once.

The passage of time can change the conditions of interpretation. Returning to a film makes it possible to recognise repetitions, compare edits or notice elements that a first viewing left in the background. However, the possibility of reassessment does not guarantee a favourable judgement. It may also make decisions more visible that a critic continues to question. A history of the film’s reception should preserve these differences rather than arranging the texts as an inevitable march towards admiration.

The debate about the adaptation has its own criteria. Stephen King has objected to changes to Jack, Wendy and the ending, while other readings value precisely the distance from the novel. The dispute is not always about the same details. Someone looking for a particular emotional experience of the book may judge the same scene differently from someone who considers it as part of the film’s visual and sound design.

Separating these two questions helps avoid a false dilemma. An adaptation can depart from its source and work convincingly for one viewer; it can also lose aspects another viewer considers essential while still holding their interest as a film. Comparing the two works provides evidence of the changes. Criticism adds a hierarchy of values, which must be made explicit for the disagreement to be understood.

Awards, reassessments and the limits of labels

Nominations and awards belong to specific institutions, with their own criteria and participants. Shelley Duvall was nominated for worst actress at the first Razzies ceremony, and the organisation withdrew that nomination in 2022. Its statement linked the decision to a reconsideration of the production circumstances. This documents an institutional reassessment; it does not turn the original nomination into an objective measure of her work, or its withdrawal into a universal opinion about the film.

This case calls for a distinction between a nomination and a win. Describing Duvall as having won that category would alter the facts. It is also worth distinguishing the organisers’ statement from a complete account of the shoot. Their explanation shows why they changed their decision, but does not replace testimony, documents and specific analysis of working conditions. Accuracy in naming prevents a repeated anecdote from eventually serving as a false history.

Retrospective selections raise a similar limitation. A film’s inclusion in a series of great works or in a programme reveals the position of those making the selection. It does not prove that earlier objections have disappeared. Nor can an average of reviews gathered many years later be used as if it were the exact response at the time of release. The publication date, provenance and subject being evaluated are all part of what each record means.

Disagreements about horror can also persist because not all fear works in the same way. The length of a journey through a space, uncertainty about an apparition or the discomfort of a conversation produce experiences different from an immediate jump scare. One critic may consider that delay unproductive, while another finds the film’s core in it. Analysis should show which technique is being evaluated before reducing both responses to matters of taste or incomprehension.

Combs, Ebert, King and the Razzies do not form a homogeneous sample: they write or act at different times and with different responsibilities. That is precisely why they help separate issues that are often conflated. The critical history of The Shining becomes more legible when it retains authors, dates and arguments. It needs no tale of failure turned into triumph to explain why the film continues to provoke disagreement about family, performance and the ways of constructing a threat.

References: Richard Combs, review of The Shining at the time of its release, reproduced by Sight and Sound/BFI in 2017. Roger Ebert, ‘Isolated Madness’, Great Movies series, 18 June 2006. Andy Greene, ‘Stephen King: The Rolling Stone Interview’, 2014. Golden Raspberry Awards, statement on the withdrawal of Shelley Duvall’s nomination, 2022, and official Own Your Bad section.

View all articles in The Shining (1980): film guide