Translating The Shining involves voices, written words and information that the viewer must recognise at a precise moment. The original Spanish dub is one specific solution, not the only possible version in Spanish.
What can be documented about the voices chosen
In the dub made in Spain, Joaquín Hinojosa voiced Jack and Verónica Forqué voiced Wendy; Carlos Saura directed the work and Vicente Molina Foix is credited as translator. These credits identify one version. They should not automatically be applied to every copy with Spanish audio, because a language label alone does not tell us the territory, date or team responsible for the track being heard.
There is attributable testimony about the choice of voices. In an interview revisited by RTVE in December 2021, Forqué recalled that Saura sent audition recordings and that Kubrick chose her voice because he felt its timbre resembled Shelley Duvall’s. Her account documents the experience she describes. It does not prove that the director personally made every decision in every session, nor does it allow us to reconstruct a working conversation that was not preserved.
On 16 December 2021, RTVE also published José Sacristán’s recollection of an audition for the dub that did not result in him being selected. This is a specific detail about an audition. Explaining why another actor was chosen would require further information. The existence of an unsuccessful audition is not enough to attribute a criterion to the team that the testimony does not state.
The performance itself should be examined at another level. Timbre, rhythm, breathing and emphasis affect how we perceive the character, but are not reducible to sounding physically like the original voice. Shelley Duvall’s performance involves her body, gaze and movements, which the dub receives already fixed in the image. The new voice has to relate to these elements without being able to change them in the same way as during filming.
The written phrase poses a different problem from dialogue
Jack’s manuscript requires the viewer to understand a repetition before turning their attention back to the approaching threat. The Spanish solution uses the proverb “No matter how early you get up, the sun won’t rise any sooner.” Molina Foix has discussed this choice in an interview. It is not a literal translation of the English proverb: it replaces one familiar expression with another that can work as mechanical, repeated writing within the scene.
The substitution changes the associations. The English phrase links work with the absence of play; the Spanish one questions the usefulness of getting ahead through effort that does not change the outcome. Both can create a clash between an everyday saying and its obsessive repetition, but they do not say exactly the same thing. Recognising the difference makes it possible to assess the narrative function that has been retained without pretending there is perfect semantic equivalence.
The medium carrying the text matters as much as its content. A Spanish-language written insert, a subtitle translating an English page and an explanation added by a voice provide different ways into the information. We cannot assume that every edition combines these resources in the same way. To describe a particular copy, we need to check what image appears, which track is playing and whether subtitles come into play at that point.
The sequence leading from the manuscript to the confrontation structures a visual discovery. If a translation gives away the meaning too soon or requires too much reading, it can alter how long the discovery feels. This is a localisation issue, distinct from deciding whether the proverb is more elegant. The solution has to work with the timing of the hands, the pages and the reactions already built into the edit.
Sounds that depend on another language
The play between the word Danny repeats and its reading in reverse in the mirror depends on English. Simply translating its meaning would not necessarily preserve the visual relationship between writing and reflection. The scene requires voice, text and image to be coordinated. The original mechanism can be explained without attributing the same solution to every Spanish version; the specific approach needs to be checked against the track and inserts in each edition.
The voice associated with Tony adds an interpretative problem. The change in register helps distinguish who seems to be responding within the same body. In another language, preserving that difference takes more than translating the words. Cadence, intensity and articulation must make an alteration perceptible that the image does not show by placing a second performer opposite Danny. The criterion for comparison is the contrast’s function, not simply the similarity of the timbre.
Other lines by Jack contain cultural references or playful registers that do not travel in the same way across all languages. A translation may retain a proper name but lose its immediate recognisability, or replace an expression to preserve the tone. There is no single procedure for every case. A joke, a command and a threat may call for different priorities because they occur at different points in the characters’ relationship.
The controversial reputation of the Spanish dub does not replace analysis either. It can be documented that certain voices have been debated, but that does not make their quality an objective measure or allow us to infer what the entire audience thinks. Listening to a whole scene offers more information than isolating a scream: it allows us to compare the build-up, pause, response and relationship with the visible body.
Dubbing, subtitles and inserts are different layers of the same experience. A copy may combine decisions made at different times, and a narrative version may also change which scenes are available. Identifying the different cuts helps keep these variables separate. Only once we have established what is heard and what is read can we explain how a Spanish solution retains, shifts or makes less accessible information from the original film.
References: Stanley Kubrick, The Shining (1980). Scenes exclusive to the US cut are identified in the text. RTVE, “José Sacristán has only ever had one audition (and they didn’t cast him)”, 16 December 2021; interview with Verónica Forqué revisited by RTVE on 13 December 2021; The Shining entry on eldoblaje.com. Ritmo magazine, interview with Vicente Molina Foix, Contrapunto section, published in 2024.
