How Kubrick selects and edits music

Music in a film may have been written for it, selected from an existing repertoire or transformed through an arrangement. The result also depends on what is discarded, how much is used and how it is placed alongside voices and images.

A collaboration can end in different ways

Alex North composed the music for Spartacus and later worked on a score for 2001 that was not included in the released film. The two projects help distinguish the existence of a commission from the presence of its result in the final cut. A credit, a preserved recording and music audible in the edit are not equivalent evidence of the same stage of the work.

The music North wrote for Spartacus has a study of its own. The case shows a composition linked to the needs of a particular production. In 2001, by contrast, audiences hear a collection of pre-existing works. The American Film Institute catalogue documents the rejection of the score recorded by North. This finding does not allow us to imagine how each discarded passage would have worked without identifying the scenes and versions for which it was intended.

Reference tracks can accompany an edit in progress. They provide rhythms, durations and sound qualities to work with, although their provisional presence does not guarantee the final result. The commission and rejection of North’s music for 2001 examines that particular process. The distinction prevents us from treating all music heard during preparation as a decision already made.

Comparing a musical alternative requires the conditions of comparison to be preserved. Laying a recording over images edited for different music creates a later experiment, not an automatic recovery of the film that might have existed. The order of the cuts, the silences and the mix may have responded to the material ultimately selected. A rejected score documents a possibility in the working process, not necessarily a complete edit ready to replace the released one.

Selecting a work also means deciding which part and which version to use

Pre-existing music does not enter a film without decisions being made. An interpretation, an excerpt and a position must be chosen. The piece may continue uninterrupted across several shots or stop before completing its musical course. This selection changes the viewer’s experience and the relationship with the sounds that remain around it. Recognising the title is the beginning of the analysis, not the end.

Barry Lyndon combines musical repertoires and treatments that play a part in situations of courtship, conflict and loss. The music of Barry Lyndon distinguishes the works and their uses. More generally, an earlier composition can be given a new arrangement and dramatic position. The composer of the original work, the person who adapts it and those who perform the recording have different roles.

The editing also determines where our listening begins in relation to an action. An entrance before a cut can prepare for the change; an entrance afterwards can alter a situation we had already begun to interpret without it. Carrying music across several images creates a continuity that does not depend solely on the places shown being near one another.

Selection does not require every gesture to be explained by a musical accent, either. A piece can follow its own course while the action introduces tensions or mismatches. Musical counterpoint explores these relationships. To attribute them to a documented intention would require testimony; describing the audible and visible contrast is part of analysing the finished work.

The film and the album preserve different objects

The Shining brings together music by Wendy Carlos and Rachel Elkind with pre-existing compositions. Carlos’s published notes on her recovered materials make it possible to distinguish work that was done from work that was used. The music of The Shining explores this relationship. The fact that a piece was composed during the project does not guarantee that it can be heard in a scene in the released version.

An album may present complete materials, alternatives, restored recordings or a selection intended for independent listening. The film, for its part, preserves dialogue, noises, entrances and cuts that organise the audiovisual experience. Both may come from the same work and still be different objects. Any comparison needs to identify which one is being heard and avoid using a track’s duration as an automatic measure of its presence on screen.

The work of Carlos and Elkind makes it possible to recognise composition, vocal treatment and other contributions without reducing a collaboration to a single name. An author’s documentation must also be read within its scope: it provides information about the materials it describes, not an explanation of all Kubrick’s musical decisions in films beyond that collaboration.

The final mix adds another layer of selection. Music may share the foreground with a voice or be partly covered by noise. Its function changes even if the excerpt used is the same. The analysis of silence, breathing and ambience reminds us that a soundtrack contains more than musical repertoire, and that removing a piece does not necessarily leave a void.

To reconstruct a decision, it is useful to bring together the title of the work, the recorded version, its use in the film and the document that evidences the process. This chain makes it possible to separate what can be verified from an interpretation of the effect. The result is not a list of the director’s favourites, but a description of how materials from different sources came to occupy a specific place within the narrative.

Films analysed: Stanley Kubrick, Spartacus (1960); 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968); Barry Lyndon (1975); The Shining (1980). Documentation: American Film Institute, AFI Catalog, entry for 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968), notes on Alex North’s score. Wendy Carlos, notes for Rediscovering Lost Scores, Volume 1, the composer’s website.

View all articles in Music, voices and sound design in Kubrick