Institutional aggression involves more than the person who carries it out. Orders, procedures and public demonstrations distribute responsibility and determine how harm is named. Paths of Glory, Full Metal Jacket and A Clockwork Orange show different mechanisms.
Paths of Glory: turning a command decision into procedure
The court martial in Paths of Glory does not begin from a neutral position. The decision to punish follows the failure of an attack and the need to assign responsibility downwards. The soldiers selected for trial arrive after a process of selection that has already shaped what can be considered an acceptable response. The judicial form does not eliminate this prior direction: it gives it a setting, roles and a recognisable sequence of interventions.
Dax tries to introduce circumstances that might allow what happened to be judged differently. The difficulty is not simply a matter of finding persuasive words. He must speak within a procedure that limits which arguments receive attention and how much they can alter the anticipated conclusion. The analysis of the court martial distinguishes these specific constraints. Violence is linked to the power to decide what counts as evidence and what is treated as a disruption of order.
The order to fire on their own positions offers a contrast. The artillery officer demands written confirmation and does not immediately carry out what has been requested over the telephone. That demand interrupts the passage from commander's intent to material action. The document would not be a mere formality: it would make responsibility identifiable, something the urgency of a verbal order seeks to shift elsewhere. The film shows a point at which procedure can prevent harm, even though in other scenes it organises it.
The execution requires distributed cooperation. After the sentence, preparations, escorts and clearly defined roles come into play. Each participant can perform a limited task without having made the initial decision, but the division of roles does not make the links between their actions disappear. The distance between authorising and carrying out the sentence makes it difficult to attribute the outcome to a single act, while still allowing us to trace the chain that makes it possible.
Full Metal Jacket: a rule sustained by voices and fellow soldiers
Hartman exercises authority through orders that regulate bodies, names, responses and movements. The barrack room is not a space where recruits can freely choose the terms of the conversation. Repeated formulas turn obedience into a visible and audible practice. Verbal violence is integrated into this everyday organisation, so it does not always appear as an exception to training, but as one of the ways it operates.
Collective punishment for Pyle's mistakes changes the relationships between the recruits. One person's difficulty becomes a burden for the others. This distribution creates an incentive for the group to monitor and pressure whoever it considers responsible for its suffering. Hartman's language and discipline must be examined alongside this change: authority also operates when it gets subordinates to administer some of the coercion among themselves.
The nighttime assault on Pyle should not be confused with an explicit order from Hartman shown on screen. It is carried out by the other recruits. This distinction matters because it allows responsibility to be examined without erasing individual initiative. The system of punishments provides a context and a direction for hostility, but the scene retains the specific actions of those who take part, hesitate or watch. Institution and agents are not mutually exclusive explanations, nor interchangeable excuses.
Nor does learning to use the rifle, by itself, resolve the situation that has arisen. Improvement in a valued skill may be recognised while other forms of harm go unaddressed. The film separates the measurable outcome of interest to the training from the relationships that accompany it. Describing this separation does not require diagnosing Pyle: it is enough to compare which behaviours are corrected, which are celebrated and which have no channel through which to elicit a response.
A Clockwork Orange: presenting harm as proof of effectiveness
The Ludovico Technique turns Alex into the subject of a treatment whose administrators present its results. His restraint and forced exposure to images form part of a procedure administered by specialists. The scene is organised around instruments, observers and a stated purpose. This organisation allows suffering to be described as a stage in an intervention, shifting attention away from what the subject experiences and towards what is expected of him.
The public demonstration adds a second operation. Alex is assaulted and put on display before an audience to prove that he no longer reacts as he did before. His inability to respond becomes evidence in favour of the treatment. The analysis of the Ludovico Technique explores the question of choice; from the perspective of institutional violence, the key issue is who defines the criteria for success. What the character experiences as helplessness can be presented to others as the technique working correctly.
The chaplain's objection shows that an institution does not necessarily speak with one voice. His moral question does not align with the minister's assessment of usefulness. The disagreement makes visible the criteria that the demonstration attempts to bring together under a simple conclusion. Asking about the relationship between progress and harm requires attention to this conflict, rather than accepting a procedure simply because its promoters present it as an improvement.
The three films allow us to trace decisions, mediation and responses without reducing all authority to a single form. The court, the instructor and the treatment distribute harm in different ways. Obedience and disobedience appear at specific points in these chains, while the spectator's position in relation to violence depends on which stages they can observe. Naming an institution explains the framework; identifying who decides, carries out, resists or remains silent allows us to examine how that framework comes to produce actions.
References: Stanley Kubrick, Paths of Glory (1957), A Clockwork Orange (1971) and Full Metal Jacket (1987). A comparative reading of the procedures and actions depicted.
View all articles in Themes and conflicts in Kubrick’s cinema
