Masculinity appears as a relationship that must be upheld in front of others: peers, subordinates, partners or rivals. Kubrick’s characters do not offer a description of all men, but rather situated behaviours that can be compared.
The group defines which behaviour deserves recognition
In Full Metal Jacket, Hartman associates belonging to the military with a repertoire of responses, acts of resistance and public displays. Humiliation uses differences between recruits to impose a common standard. Masculine identity takes shape within that discipline, not as a natural quality that everyone would express in the same way. The group learns what must be displayed and what can become grounds for punishment.
The language of Sergeant Hartman turns shame into a tool of control. His categories are not neutral descriptions of those to whom they are applied. They establish a hierarchy between acceptable and discredited behaviours, and position the instructor as the authority who names them. The pressure also comes from having to respond in front of peers who observe and may later reproduce that judgement.
The group’s participation complicates the distinction between victim and agent. A recruit may suffer discipline and help enforce it on someone else. This circulation does not erase the inequality between instructor and subordinates, but it shows that authority depends on shared practices. The relationship between power and institutions makes it possible to study this mechanism without attributing identical responsibility or a single motivation to every member.
Comparison with war and militarism also prevents toughness from being confused with effectiveness in every situation. Behaviour rewarded during training may prove inadequate in the face of incomplete information, fear or the need for care. The film makes it possible to examine this difference without turning soldiers into examples of an immutable masculine essence or inferring a psychology of the director from them.
Domestic authority may depend on recognition that it cannot control
Jack Torrance asserts his position as a writer, worker and father in The Shining, but his actions do not guarantee the responsibilities those positions entail. The gap between the rights he claims and the care he offers makes it possible to analyse his domestic authority. There is no need to diagnose him to recognise threats, contempt or demands for obedience in his relationship with Wendy and Danny.
The analysis of Jack Torrance examines this particular trajectory. From a gender perspective, what matters is that the failure of a personal expectation can be turned into an accusation against those who depend on him. Frustration does not compel or excuse violence. The film shows behaviour that should be described as such, rather than presented as the inevitable reaction of any man who feels that his position is under threat.
Bill Harford offers another case. His professional and social confidence does not give him complete access to Alice’s desires. When she speaks of an imagined experience, she unsettles a certainty he had treated as his own. The crisis does not stem from literally losing his job or his resources, but from discovering a limit to what he believed he knew about his partner.
The trajectory of Bill Harford makes it possible to observe how he tries to regain his bearings through credentials, money and the search for information. These tools work to varying degrees. Comparing him with Jack does not make them equivalent characters: the scale of their actions, their relationships and the forms of harm differ. What they have in common is a question about what happens when the authority someone claims for themselves ceases to be affirmed.
Vulnerability does not have a single response
Barry Lyndon associates masculine recognition with social forms such as duelling, reputation and belonging to certain circles. The rules offer the appearance of equality between participants, even though their positions and resources are not identical. The duels in the film make it possible to examine how a public display of courage can put the body at risk and produce consequences that go beyond the immediate encounter.
Vulnerability can be acknowledged, concealed or turned against someone else. There is no single response that follows from feeling fear or shame. This distinction prevents every scene from being read as confirmation that male characters know only how to dominate. The films also show hesitation, help, dependence and decisions that interrupt expected behaviour, although these actions do not automatically erase what happened before.
Alex adds a different combination of taste, display and violence. His musical sensitivity does not make him a considerate person. The study of Alex’s character makes it possible to distinguish the capacity to enjoy an art form from moral conduct. His group’s masculinity is organised through hierarchy and aggression, but that structure should not be confused with all the masculine relationships found in other films.
Desire and jealousy extend the comparison to intimate relationships. Having access to a partner is not the same as possessing their thoughts; receiving recognition from a group does not guarantee inner security. These tensions can be analysed through words, actions and shifts in position. They do not require a general biological explanation that turns every character into a variation on the same inevitable impulse.
Comparative analysis is more precise when it asks in front of whom something must be demonstrated and what happens if that demonstration fails. An instructor needs responses, a father demands obedience, a husband seeks certainty and a social aspirant needs acceptance. Other people’s responses set the limits of these aspirations. Masculinity then appears as a set of relationships and conflicting expectations, not as a stable identity that explains every behaviour in advance.
References: Stanley Kubrick, A Clockwork Orange (1971), Barry Lyndon (1975), The Shining (1980), Full Metal Jacket (1987) and Eyes Wide Shut (1999). Comparative interpretation of roles and relationships; the characters’ behaviour is not generalised to all men or to the director’s life.
View all articles in Themes and conflicts in Kubrick’s cinema
