An invitation, a surname or a tunic can change what a character is able to do, but they do not guarantee belonging. Barry Lyndon, Eyes Wide Shut and Spartacus allow us to observe who grants access and who retains the right to withdraw it.
Barry Lyndon: learning the ways does not guarantee recognition
Barry learns to navigate environments that initially feel unfamiliar to him. His uniform, manners, gambling and personal relationships change how freely he can move about. Each new skill allows him to present himself differently to others, although that presentation depends on someone accepting it. His position cannot be measured solely by what he owns: it also matters who vouches for him, who welcomes him and which parts of his past are left out of the conversation.
His marriage to Lady Lyndon makes the difference between entry and recognition clear. Barry comes to live in an aristocratic house and adopts a name associated with it. However, Lady Lyndon’s son, Bullingdon, does not regard this change as giving Barry legitimate authority over his family. Within the same room, the formal address of ‘sir’ can coexist with resistance that reminds the newcomer of the limits of his position.
The pursuit of a title turns social access into an ongoing undertaking. Receptions, purchases and relationships with influential people require resources, without any automatic link between expenditure and outcome. The film shows the effort involved in maintaining an appearance, while the desired recognition remains in other people’s hands. The study of Redmond Barry’s rise and dependence continues that personal journey; here, the focus is on the structure that makes his visible success insufficient.
The concert scene shows just how much belonging depends on behaviour that others recognise. Bullingdon’s provocation ends with Barry assaulting him in public. This is not simply a momentary lapse in good manners: the drawing room contains people who can withdraw their acceptance. The violence makes visible a rupture that clothing, a surname and furnishings had allowed to remain within the bounds of a socially acceptable performance.
Eyes Wide Shut: Bill’s privilege also encounters a closed door
Bill Harford enjoys a position that makes it easier for him to mix with wealthy people. His profession gives him access to private lives and places that others would not enter. At Ziegler’s party, that openness comes with a specific condition: he must act as a doctor and keep things discreet. His presence does not necessarily put him on an equal footing with his host. He can be a guest at a gathering and, at another point in the same night, attend to the private needs of the person who welcomed him.
Somerton changes the rules Bill knows. Having the money for the journey and an appropriate disguise allows him to get close, but does not guarantee that he can maintain his presence. There are procedures for recognition there that he does not understand. The contrast distinguishes two forms of power: acquiring the visible elements of an identity, and having the authorisation that identity presupposes. The latter is not included in the price of the former.
The mask seems to erase differences, although the scene ultimately reveals that the participants do not enjoy the same degree of protection. Bill can be separated from the group and made to answer for himself. Anonymity is unequal: some retain the power to scrutinise him while he does not know who they are. The analysis of money, access and power in Eyes Wide Shut explores this journey without turning the gathering into evidence of real-world organisations outside the fiction.
Signs of status therefore need context. A suit may help someone move around at one party and prove insufficient at another. Costume as characterisation helps us recognise this variation, but does not provide a dictionary in which each garment always corresponds to the same class. It is the welcome, the questions and the restrictions a character encounters that show how much their appearance is worth in each place.
Spartacus: being inside can mean being at others’ disposal
In Spartacus, access to a house or a place of leisure does not mean belonging to those who govern it. Enslaved people are present because their labour, bodies or service make the owners’ way of life possible. Physical proximity to an elite can coexist with extreme exclusion. Sharing the frame or hearing a conversation does not give someone the power to decide whether they stay or on what terms the encounter takes place.
The display of gladiators makes it possible to distinguish the spectator who chooses from the person who is chosen. The combat depends on a decision made from a position of safety. The fighters’ skill increases the value of their performance, but does not end their subordination. This relationship differs from Barry’s ambitions and Bill’s foray: here, the initial aim is not to gain recognition from an elite, but to stop being subject to its will.
The leadership and community of Spartacus shifts the question towards the possibility of acting with others outside that relationship of ownership. The comparison does not equate enslavement, aristocracy and professional privilege. It allows us to ask, in different settings, who defines the rules of access and how much power each character has to reject them. It also requires us to distinguish a barrier of prestige from the material deprivation of freedom.
marriage agreements and financial relationships and dependence offer further routes in, but their effects need to be assessed in each scene. Barry can acquire possessions without obtaining the title he wants; Bill can pay without getting answers; a gladiator can be admired without ceasing to be someone else’s property. Recognition is distributed through decisions and relationships that visible signs of status alone cannot control.
References: Stanley Kubrick, Spartacus (1960), Barry Lyndon (1975) and Eyes Wide Shut (1999). A critical comparison of the situations depicted in the films.
View all articles in Themes and conflicts in Kubrick’s cinema
