Reading as a search for films in Kubrick

Reading a novel and deciding to film it are different processes. Between them come questions about characters, duration, images and collaboration that help us understand Kubrick’s choice of stories.

A first reading preserves something that later work can erase

In his 1980 conversation with Vicente Molina Foix, Kubrick explained that reading someone else’s narrative allowed him to remember the impression of a first encounter. That memory gave him a point of reference when the story had become too familiar through working on it. He added other questions: whether his interest endured, whether there were cinematic possibilities, and whether there were attractive roles for performers. The starting point was a personal response, not a catalogue of required themes.

The distinction matters because admiring a piece of writing is not the same as finding a film within it. A book may appeal because of its narrative voice, its verbal associations or a line of thought that needs little outward action. When it moves to the screen, those resources require new decisions. The choice starts to become cinematic when we ask what experience someone might have without access to the original prose or all its context.

Lolita and Barry Lyndon help us explore this problem without turning it into a single rule. Both films remain connected to the verbal narrative, but the voice exists alongside performances, framing and events that we can assess separately. Interest in a narrative does not require us to trust the person telling it without reservation. The screen can distribute across several cues what reading had concentrated in a single perspective.

That is why it is worth separating the choice of a story from the study of its specific transformation. The analysis of Kubrick’s literary adaptations compares the solutions already realised. Here, the focus is on the earlier moment: recognising a situation, a relationship or an uncertainty capable of sustaining cinematic attention. Neither a writer’s prestige guarantees this possibility, nor does the number of events in the plot ensure that they will work on screen.

Imagining scenes does not mean illustrating every paragraph

The Shining offers a clear case of spatial concentration. A family, a job and a hotel provide a way to organise relationships that can be seen and heard: someone works, someone interrupts, someone watches a door. This description of the result shows a cinematic possibility in the material. It does not prove that each of these actions was the initial reason Kubrick chose the book; to assert his personal motives, we need his testimony, not just our reading of the film.

In Eyes Wide Shut, a conversation between husband and wife produces mental images and subsequent movements. An apparently small action can open up an extensive journey when it changes what a character believes they know. The choice of literature need not favour only stories with major events. It can also find movement in a confession, a doubt or the gap between what is said and what someone else imagines.

Duration raises another question. A novel lets us return to a sentence, pause or turn pages at different speeds. A film sets the time for a look, a pause or a wait. Deciding what to retain means imagining how information is distributed during that continuous experience. Removing episodes can bring a relationship into focus; keeping them all can push it aside. The amount of material retained does not, by itself, measure the attention paid to the text.

Nor do characters arrive fully formed from the page. Their presence depends on bodies, voices and spatial relationships. A written conversation can change in weight when a performer takes time to reply or another figure remains in the frame. This openness explains why it is worth studying Kubrick’s screenwriters and collaborators as participants in the development process, rather than reducing them to messengers for the director’s private reading.

A literary candidate can change or never make it to the screen

Comparing completed and unfinished projects helps us avoid reconstructing the search as a series of inevitable decisions. The existence of a film lets us study the outcome of a selection. The survival of a treatment or a screenplay lets us study a different stage. An unrealised project may have required considerable work, but that effort is not the same as an audiovisual work available for analysis.

The development of A.I. highlights precisely the difference between a starting narrative, versions developed during preparation and the film ultimately directed by Spielberg. Interest in a premise does not determine its length or form once and for all. Changing a character’s journey, imagining new encounters or seeking a different structure for the ending are ways of testing what kind of film might emerge from that material.

With Wartime Lies and the Aryan Papers project, the distinction is even more necessary: the literary text and the adaptation work should not be described as scenes from a film Kubrick shot. We can study the problems involved in representing a narrated experience, but the absence of a completed film prevents us from assessing performances or edits that do not exist. The surviving documents tell us about the development; on their own, they cannot fill in the absent result.

The value of a note also changes depending on where it sits in the process. A discarded proposal shows that an option was considered; a later screenplay may show how it was revised. Without dates or connections between versions, assembling phrases from different documents creates an artificial project. Collaboration is better understood when each contribution retains its place, even if we cannot reconstruct every intermediate step.

Reading in search of a film therefore requires two kinds of attention that do not always coincide: receiving a story as a reader and imagining what another form might do with it. The course of each project lets us observe the negotiation between the two. The criterion is not whether the film makes everything written visible, but which relationships it preserves, transforms or makes accessible through means that literature does not use in the same way.

References: Vicente Molina Foix, interview with Stanley Kubrick, El País-Artes, 20 December 1980. Films: Lolita (1962), Barry Lyndon (1975), The Shining (1980), Eyes Wide Shut (1999) and A.I. Artificial Intelligence (Steven Spielberg, 2001). University of the Arts London, description of the Stanley Kubrick Archive and the A.I. and Aryan Papers collections.

View all articles in Kubrick’s artistic and literary influences