How a critical reading of Kubrick changes

A reappraisal is demonstrated by comparing arguments, dates and versions. Opening reviews and retrospective pieces can shift their focus without a simple conversion from rejection to admiration.

Two readings of 2001, published twenty-nine years apart

Roger Ebert’s review of 2001: A Space Odyssey, published on April 12, 1968, offers a way to verify a nuance that is often lost in accounts of initial incomprehension. Ebert recognized the force of its cosmic scale and pointed to a limitation in the characters’ human dimension. He was not dismissing the film outright. His assessment distinguished aspects that could produce different impressions within the same viewing experience.

In his March 27, 1997, piece for the Great Movies series, Ebert paid particular attention to duration, contemplation and the relationship between music and images. The scarcity of dialogue and departure from conventional storytelling appeared as conditions of the effect the film sought to create. In comparing the two pieces, what matters is the change in critical vocabulary: what was measured in terms of human connection is later examined as the organization of an audiovisual experience.

This comparison does not require claiming that the critic had hated the work and then changed his mind. The documents do not support that account. They do allow us to study how the question changes: from what the characters offer as recognizable figures to what a film does with scale, time and imagination. A reappraisal may consist of reprioritizing aspects within an assessment that was already favourable. The shift is less dramatic than a conversion, but more precise.

To verify this, it helps to return to a specific moment, such as the journey and the docking of the spacecraft. The 2001 guide helps place it within the whole. A reading centred on the progress of the action may find its duration excessive; another may examine how that duration builds relationships between bodies, machines and music. The disagreement becomes open to discussion when both explain what they expect from the sequence, rather than treating their preferences as universal evidence.

A retrospective does not reproduce the conditions of a film’s release

Ebert’s piece on Barry Lyndon, dated September 9, 2009, should also be read according to its actual date. Although the page URL includes 1975, that number identifies the year of the film, not the year of the review published there. Confusing the two would create false evidence of an opening review. This seemingly minor detail changes the kind of evidence: we are reading a retrospective assessment, written when the film already had a public history.

The difference in context does not invalidate the later analysis. It allows us to ask questions that an immediate review may not have explored, compare other works or revisit a performance. It can also encourage an overly tidy retrospective account, in which initial disagreements are reduced to an inability to understand. To study Barry Lyndon it is more useful to identify what is argued about its narrator, duration or social relationships than to repeat that time proved it right.

A retrospective also brings together a selection. The programme, the introductory text and the availability of prints shape the encounter with the film. They are not equivalent to a sample of all the opinions that exist. A work may receive more attention without earlier objections disappearing, and two favourable readings may value incompatible aspects. Critical history includes these internal differences; it does not have to be summed up by an average score that rises steadily.

Lists and polls provide another kind of data: they show a choice made within a specific process. Interpreting them requires knowing the year, the participating group and the question asked. They do not replace the arguments in a review. Nor do they prove that a film was rejected on its release or that all its scenes have been reappraised in the same way. A high ranking documents a place in a selection, not intellectual unanimity or agreement about the work’s meaning.

Comparing arguments without turning change into a rule

A useful comparison starts by preserving each text’s identity: author, publication, date and subject. Then it helps to separate the description of the scene, the criterion used and the resulting judgement. Two critics may describe the same pacing and disagree about its effectiveness. They may also seem to be at odds when they are actually discussing different versions or screening conditions. The criteria for evidence in an interpretation help pinpoint exactly where the difference lies.

Circulation adds a variable that should not be confused with taste. A film that is withdrawn from a territory, distributed with changes or viewed in another version offers different conditions of reception. The study of censorship, classification and withdrawal helps identify these mechanisms before interpreting an absence as a lack of public interest. Difficulty accessing a film does not prove rejection, just as a re-release alone does not demonstrate a reassessment of every opinion.

The kind of knowledge a viewer brings also changes. In stories about war or a particular era, new historical questions may direct attention towards institutions, bodies or exclusions that were discussed less before. That does not justify claiming that the film predicted later concerns. The relationship between fiction and history requires distinguishing the work, its production context and the present from which it is interpreted. All three layers play a part without becoming one and the same.

Ebert’s case shows a specific form of continuity and change: his assessment of 2001 remains while the way he explains its experience changes. Other cases may show persistent rejection, partial revision or disagreement among critics of the same period. Documenting them requires preserving that diversity. Kubrick’s reception is more readily understood as a succession of identifiable arguments than as a rule that every film first confounds people and then wins general approval.

References: Roger Ebert, 2001: A Space Odyssey, April 12, 1968; 2001: A Space Odyssey, Great Movies, March 27, 1997; “Technically awesome, emotionally distant, and classically Kubrick,” on Barry Lyndon, September 9, 2009. Comparisons between his criteria are analyses of those texts.

View all articles in Critical Reception and Debates About Kubrick