An additional take may address a movement, a line or a choice that still isn’t working. Counting takes without knowing what the problem was leaves out much of the work and doesn’t show how a performance was achieved.
Rehearsing means trying out a scene under specific conditions
In Joseph Gelmis’s interview published in The Film Director as Superstar, Kubrick linked the usefulness of rehearsal to the opportunity to work in the physical space of the scene. He also distinguished the consistency he observed in George C. Scott from Peter Sellers’s variability. These are the director’s impressions of specific collaborators, not a universal classification of two ways of acting.
Space matters because a line doesn’t happen in isolation. The person delivering it is a certain distance from someone else, may be sitting or moving around, and has objects at hand that can help or interrupt their action. Trying out the dialogue alone doesn’t resolve all those relationships. When the set is in place, an imagined solution may become awkward or reveal a different possibility.
In his conversation with Philip Strick and Penelope Houston, Kubrick described rehearsing a new scene as a time when the material could change as it was put into practice. The earlier preparation was still necessary, but it didn’t guarantee that everything would work when performed. That account supports talking about revision, not a fixed plan that performers were expected to carry out without variation.
The preparation and revision of the work addresses the method more broadly. Here, the focus is on a specific unit: the scene that must establish an understandable relationship. Before repeating it, it helps to identify what needs to be tested. A problem with pacing, an unclear path through the scene or a muddled dramatic intention calls for different interventions.
Repetition has no single cause or guaranteed result
In his 1987 interview with Tim Cahill, Kubrick rejected the idea of a fixed number of takes applied to every scene and linked some problems to knowing the dialogue. That explanation is his account of the work. It doesn’t allow us to attribute every repetition in his filmography to the cast’s lack of preparation, nor does it replace the experiences of those who performed.
A repeat may preserve the scene and change only one element: speed, position, timing of a response or coordination with the camera. It may also capture a more substantial alternative. From the outside, both processes produce another take; dramatically, they aren’t equivalent. Production records and first-hand accounts can help distinguish between them when available.
The work of the Full Metal Jacket cast provides specific context for the account of R. Lee Ermey. His familiarity with the language of a drill instructor didn’t eliminate the need to learn, coordinate and record a scene. A performer’s prior experience can provide material, but the film still has to turn it into actions that work with the other bodies and the camera.
Variation can also affect scene partners. A different pause changes when someone else responds; a different path changes the position from which they’re seen. That’s why a take doesn’t belong only to the person in the foreground. Acting takes place within a coordination, and repeating one part may require the whole group to reorganize.
Accounts of the production of The Shining should be kept in their specific scene, moment and point of view. A difficult experience isn’t explained by a general formula about perfectionism. Nor does a viewer’s assessment of the result’s quality prove that every working condition was necessary or justifiable. Process and aesthetic evaluation call for different questions.
The final performance is also determined in the selection process
James B. Harris told DGA Quarterly that during his collaboration with Kubrick, contributions were tried out in rehearsal and then incorporated into the text. His recollection distinguishes the moment of discovery from the moment of recording. A solution that emerges from a trial may reach the shoot as prepared material, ready to be repeated with a more clearly defined rhythm.
The collaboration with Peter Sellers is useful for understanding that distinction, but it shouldn’t be reduced to an opposition between freedom and control. An actor can make a suggestion and the director can select it; a scene partner can change the response; the edit can keep only part of it. The source of an idea alone doesn’t describe all the stages that turn it into a scene.
The finished film lets us observe a gesture, a pause and a reaction, but it doesn’t always reveal whether they come from the same take. A dialogue scene may combine different recordings. The continuity we perceive is the result of selection and the relationships between shots. Identifying a performance with a single, uninterrupted execution can obscure that work.
The study of Paths of Glory and the collaboration with Kirk Douglas places another production experience in context. Comparing accounts from different films is useful if their conditions are kept in view: cast, era, resources and specific problems. Applying an anecdote from one shoot to all the others turns a particular experience into a rule that the sources haven’t established.
A number of takes only becomes meaningful when we know what unit is being counted. It may refer to a shot, a scene, a day or a selection of footage, and those levels aren’t interchangeable. It also matters who provides the figure and when they recall it. Without that precision, the number’s apparent exactness may conceal a very imprecise description of the process.
The result can be analysed without reconstructing every repetition. The question is how a visible performance is organized and what relationships it creates. Explaining how it was made requires additional documents and accounts. Keeping those questions separate makes it possible to study rehearsal, repetition and selection as concrete forms of work, without turning them into a record-breaking contest or assuming that more takes guarantee a better scene.
Accounts: Joseph Gelmis, The Film Director as Superstar (1970); Philip Strick and Penelope Houston, Modern Times: An Interview with Stanley Kubrick, Sight and Sound (1972); Tim Cahill, The Rolling Stone Interview: Stanley Kubrick (1987); James B. Harris, In the Trenches with Stanley Kubrick, DGA Quarterly (2013).
View all articles in Directing actors and staging in Kubrick
