The relationship between Nolan and Kubrick has a documented starting point: the experience of watching 2001. Comparing their films then requires looking at what they do differently with space, time and information.
Remembering a screening is a situated statement
At the 2018 Cannes meeting, Christopher Nolan recalled watching 2001 with his father, in 70 mm, at the Leicester Square Theatre in London. He also explained his involvement in presenting a 70 mm print to bring audiences closer to that screening experience. His statement connects a specific film with a way of seeing it; it does not merely express admiration for a name.
That starting point helps explain why format belongs in the discussion. The relationship between screen size, detail and duration affects how an image is explored. A spacecraft can take up little space within the frame and yet retain recognisable detail. The viewer needs time to appreciate the distance between its parts, its movement and its surroundings. Scale does not depend solely on an object appearing large.
The 2001 guide places these questions within Kubrick’s film. Nolan’s account adds a history of reception: someone remembers a screening that expanded their expectations of what cinema could do. That experience does not prove that every format Nolan subsequently chose had a single cause, or that a particular technology alone guarantees the same effect.
It is also worth distinguishing the film from its medium. Presenting a work in 70 mm does not make all its scenes equivalent images, and watching a different print does not automatically erase its editing relationships. The material presentation matters, but it works alongside composition, rhythm and sound. An acknowledged influence can guide an aspiration for the audience’s experience without dictating an identical formula for every decision.
Two approaches to a spacecraft can create different tensions
The orbital approach accompanied by the waltz in 2001 and the emergency docking in Interstellar offer a specific comparison. Both make legible the relationship between mechanical bodies that need to coordinate. In the first, movement is presented as an organised operation; in the second, rotation and danger turn that coordination into an urgent task. A similarity in situation reveals differences in rhythm and focus.
In 2001, the music and duration allow us to contemplate movements that seem to form a stable system. Scale is perceived through the relationship between objects and the continuity of their trajectories. The spacecraft and effects work explains how these images were specifically constructed. The comparison with Nolan does not justify automatically transferring one film’s production methods to the other.
Interstellar gives more immediate weight to the risk of the manoeuvre and the decisions of those carrying it out. The characters’ faces and responses, and changes in distance, all contribute to a shared sense of urgency. The viewer is given information to understand that a wrong move could interrupt the action. Space is not just something to look at: it becomes a problem that must be solved before it is too late.
This comparison describes visible results; it does not identify a shot-for-shot borrowing. To establish a stricter correspondence, it would be necessary to define the framing, duration and order, as well as provide documentation when claiming intention. The organisation of perspective in Kubrick makes it possible to pose these questions precisely. A centred spacecraft or a recognisable vanishing line is not, on its own, enough to prove a historical connection.
The role of editing also changes. An operation can be made comprehensible through extended continuity or through the distribution of information across simultaneous actions. Studying editing and ellipses helps distinguish between them. Nolan and Kubrick may share an interest in demanding experiences of time without organising expectation, verbal explanation and the moment when the audience understands a situation in the same way.
HAL and TARS do not establish the same relationship with trust
Comparing HAL with TARS helps clarify another common resemblance: the presence of artificial intelligence on a space journey. In 2001, HAL’s voice seems integrated into the everyday operation of the spacecraft, ultimately making that trust problematic. In Interstellar, TARS takes part in exchanges where its settings and humour can be discussed. The films ask different questions about how a relationship with a machine is negotiated.
The contrast affects the information available. HAL speaks with a confidence that can be at odds with what the humans are able to verify. TARS makes certain adjustments an explicit part of the conversation. Neither observation allows one character to be reduced to the other’s answer. The shared theme of machines and human routines allows for treatments that distribute suspicion and cooperation differently.
Interstellar’s family relationships also introduce a specific emotional focus. The messages and temporal distance matter because of what happens between father and daughter. Bowman’s journey in 2001 is not organised around the same bond. Comparing the two films as journeys into the unknown is productive when it preserves this difference, rather than assuming that every emotion or mystery serves an interchangeable function.
Nolan’s statement establishes an acknowledged influence; formal analysis proposes relationships that still need to be argued. Keeping these two levels separate makes it possible to describe continuity without obscuring transformation. The memory of a screening, a choice of format and a narrative solution may be related, but they are not three names for the same fact. Each answers a different question about how a viewer’s experience comes to inform another filmmaker’s work.
References: Eugénie Malinjod, Rendez-vous with… Christopher Nolan, Cannes Film Festival, 12 May 2018. Films compared: Stanley Kubrick, 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968); Christopher Nolan, Interstellar (2014).
View all articles in Kubrick in other filmmakers’ work and visual culture
