Kubrick and Jordan Peele’s horror: references and differences

Peele has identified an allusion to The Shining in Get Out. His testimony offers a verifiable example; comparisons with other spaces and doubles need their own arguments and careful attention to the differences.

A reference to the maze takes on a new context

In a 2017 interview with Yohana Desta published by Vanity Fair, Jordan Peele said that the mention of a hedge maze at the start of Get Out alluded to The Shining. His comment refers to a specific action by the character played by Lakeith Stanfield. It does not amount to saying that the entire sequence reproduces the spatial arrangement of Kubrick’s film.

The character walks through a residential area where he struggles to find his way. The threat emerges in a setting that might seem peaceful and orderly from the outside. The contrast between that appearance and the vulnerability of the person moving through it changes the meaning of the reference. There need not be a physical maze for the journey to become an experience of exposure and a loss of security.

In The Shining, the Overlook Hotel creates disorientation through spaces that are traversed and only partly recognised. In Get Out, the opening can build tension with a street and a vehicle. The allusion links one experience of being lost with another, but their visible conditions are different. Recognising the connection should not prevent us from describing what is distinctive about Peele’s scene.

This difference offers a useful way to study influence: start with the element the filmmaker identifies and observe what function it takes on in a different context. The recognition may enrich the experience of viewers who know The Shining, but the threat in Get Out does not depend on every viewer spotting the allusion. The scene must also work through its actions, distances and the information it withholds.

Courtesy can conceal threats that do not have the same origins

Chris’s arrival at the Armitage house creates unease through apparently friendly conversations. Comments about his body, his identity and his relationship with Rose turn him into an object of scrutiny. Hospitality does not erase that classification: it can be the means by which it is imposed. The viewer must pay attention to what happens within the cordial exchange, rather than waiting only for an open breach of social conventions.

The Overlook also offers forms of welcome and service that become unsettling, but it is unwise to equate their mechanisms. Jack’s relationship with the hotel develops alongside his authority within the family and his desire for recognition. Chris arrives as a guest among people who interpret and exploit his racial difference. These spaces may seem civilised while distributing the power to decide and leave unequally.

The comparison becomes more precise if we ask who has to maintain appearances. Chris has reason to moderate his responses to situations that make him uncomfortable. In several scenes in The Shining, the threat comes from someone demanding obedience within a family relationship. The tension does not always lie in what a building conceals, but also in the cost of contradicting those who control the situation.

The camera movements allow us to follow this negotiation, although no camera movement by itself proves an influence. Following someone can limit what we know; viewing them from another position can make it clear that they are being watched. To compare Peele and Kubrick, it is worth considering how that gaze is distributed. The geometric similarity of two corridors tells us less than the difference between moving through them freely and doing so under surveillance.

Doubles and humour: resemblance also creates differences

Us sets a family against figures who reproduce their appearances and undermine their sense of security. The doubling affects bodies, relationships and the possibility of recognition. Comparing it with the doubles and masks in Kubrick can help describe this estrangement, provided it is presented as a critical reading and not as a claim about origins that resemblance alone would prove.

The appearances of the girls before Danny concentrate a threat in an image and in its relationship to other visions. In Us, the doubles play a sustained part in actions and family conflicts. Visual repetition is no longer just an apparition to behold; it becomes a problem of living together, pursuit and replacement. Sharing a figure of doubling does not mean sharing the same narrative structure.

Humour introduces another difference. In Get Out, Rod offers a perspective that may seem exaggerated before taking on a different significance within the story. His interventions offer a moment to breathe, but also challenge reassuring interpretations. The comedy is bound up with a relationship of trust with Chris. It is not reduced to an outside comment that suspends the consequences of what is happening.

In Kubrick, black humour and irony can arise from an institution that continues to speak normally while causing a catastrophe, or from courtesy accompanying a threat. Comparing these uses with Peele’s means considering who gets to laugh, and at what. One joke can bring us closer to a vulnerable character; another can expose us to the cruelty of whoever dominates the scene.

The acknowledged reference, the comparison of spaces and the study of doubles offer different kinds of evidence. The criteria for evaluating an interpretation help to keep these distinctions clear. Peele’s films can be in dialogue with Kubrick while also organising other social conflicts, other emotional alliances and other forms of response. Comparison is more useful when it explains these processes than when it turns every resemblance into a sign of dependence.

References: Yohana Desta, ‘In Jordan Peele’s Gripping Get Out, “Humanity Is the Monster”’, Vanity Fair, 17 February 2017. Films compared: Stanley Kubrick, The Shining (1980); Jordan Peele, Get Out (2017) and Us (2019).

View all articles in Kubrick in other filmmakers’ work and visual culture