The Killing and The Asphalt Jungle: two groups planning a heist

John Huston’s The Asphalt Jungle and Stanley Kubrick’s The Killing share an interest in a heist organised by a group of men. They differ in how information is distributed, how closely the accomplices are portrayed, and how time is handled.

Two groups that do not form a true community

Directed by John Huston and released in 1950, The Asphalt Jungle brings together criminals who work together to steal jewellery. The Killing, released in 1956, organises its participants around the takings from a racecourse. Both films reveal the fragility of a criminal enterprise built on complementary abilities. No single member has all the means required; each contributes access, strength, knowledge or a specific role. This similarity belongs to the heist-story tradition and does not prove a direct line of influence.

In Huston’s film, the audience learns about the lives and weaknesses of several participants as the operation is being planned. Private needs, ambition and hidden commitments prevent the gang from behaving as a stable unit. Kubrick also shows individuals with different aims, but distributes some of this information through a fragmented timeline. In both cases, the trust needed to carry out the heist is less than the trust needed to enjoy its spoils.

The comparison is especially clear in the relationships between the criminals and those who are not formally involved in the heist. Debts, partners and personal expectations do not vanish when a gang comes together. On the contrary, they become pressure points within the operation. The money and needs of the accomplices offers an economic map of The Killing. The Asphalt Jungle can be considered through the same question, without mechanically equating the characters’ problems or importing its plot point by point.

An operation seen at different paces

Huston devotes attention to the preparations and the obstacles that follow the execution. His characters seem to move through a world of ongoing relationships, where the consequences of one decision carry over into the next episode. Kubrick orders the story differently: he can return to the same interval to show a task that was previously kept off-screen. The audience sees the mechanism through successive parts, as if reconstructing an operation after learning about some of its movements.

This difference changes the suspense. In The Asphalt Jungle, the question of whether an action will succeed tends to remain within a more linear narrative progression. In The Killing, as well as wondering whether the heist will work, the audience has to work out how the fragments fit together. Betty Steinberg’s editing makes it possible to study the mechanism without turning the entire comparison into a technical examination. Two films can create tension through similar preparations while offering very different experiences of time.

A careful comparison should also consider where each film places the audience’s sympathy. In a gang story, learning about the criminals’ private lives can create a sense of closeness without removing their responsibility for their actions. Huston shows vulnerabilities and aspirations that persist beyond the heist; Kubrick offers individual motives within a temporal device that emphasises coordination. Interest in the characters need not amount to moral absolution. It can help us understand why very different people agree to work together. When the plan fails, the audience loses both the anticipated haul and the possibility of seeing desires they had learnt to recognise come to fruition. Film noir uses this double frustration in different ways. It is more precise to analyse what is known about the accomplices at each point than to claim a supposed direct dependence between the two films simply because they share the subject of robbery.

The use of settings also has an influence. The interiors and private rooms in both films allow agreements to be shown that would not withstand the light of day. But Kubrick pays particular attention to the racecourse entrances and the coordinated movements around a race. The Asphalt Jungle sets its robbery within a different kind of infrastructure and gives a different weight to the crime’s consequences for its protagonists’ everyday lives. The specificity of each place prevents the comparison from being reduced to the mere presence of a gang.

Fate, genre and the limits of influence

The failure of a criminal operation is a recognisable feature of film noir. In both films, plans come up against desires that cannot be controlled by instructions. Ambition, need and personal ties survive any scheme. However, these forces are treated differently: Kubrick directs the irony towards temporal repetition and the physicality of money, while Huston is interested in the gradual exposure of his criminals’ vulnerability.

It is worth distinguishing influence, genre kinship and critical comparison. The fact that The Killing recalls The Asphalt Jungle in its gang structure is not enough to claim that Kubrick copied scenes, characters or visual solutions. To support a specific relationship, one would need to consult statements or production documents. The similarity allows us to examine how two directors use similar conventions to achieve different effects, but does not in itself establish a causal link.

Comparing the films deepens our understanding of their choices. It lets us see robbery as a provisional organisation of strangers, money as a promise of freedom, and the social environment as a source of pressures that no one can control. But each work retains its own form: one structures its drama through the progression of a criminal network, while the other makes temporal reconstruction a central problem for the viewer. The comparison is useful when it illuminates that difference, not when it claims that one film invented or perfected the genre in its entirety.

View all articles in The Killing: film guide