The music composed for The Shining is not the same as everything that is ultimately heard in the film. Wendy Carlos’s notes help distinguish the music prepared, the excerpts used and their later release.
A score prepared while the film was still taking shape
Wendy Carlos and Rachel Elkind are associated with the original music for The Shining, but that credit does not mean they wrote every piece heard in the film. The edit combines material prepared for the project with pre-existing recordings. This distinction matters because music may be conceived for one situation and end up in another, or be left out of the film even when work on it is well advanced. The soundtrack released is a selection, not a complete record of the commissioned work.
Carlos’s notes for Rediscovering Lost Scores, volume 1, describe the process from the perspective of someone involved. They introduce material connected with readings, conversations and stages of editing before the film’s release. They are a source for identifying what she prepared and how she remembers it. They do not replace the film itself when the question is which excerpt accompanies a particular scene. Nor can they, on their own, reconstruct all the decisions made during the final mix.
The case of Colorado illustrates the distance between a proposal and its fate. Carlos presents it as an initial, more luminous approach, linked to her reading of the novel, which did not make it into the film. Listening to it alongside the released opening reveals two different expectations of the landscape. An expansive invitation and an unsettling warning do not create the same entry into the story, even if both might be associated with mountains and journeys.
This comparison does not turn the discarded proposal into a lost version of the sequence. To speak of an alternative edit, the images, duration and synchronisation would need to be established. A musical recording preserves a possibility for the work, but does not prove that a finished film existed around it. The distinction is especially important when a later album brings together material conceived at different times and presents it as a continuous listening experience.
What remains in the released edit
The opening titles use the electronic treatment associated with Carlos and Elkind. Its presence establishes a relationship between landscape and threat before the Torrances appear as a family in conflict. The origin and function of this passage should be distinguished from a detailed analysis of its musical motif, explored in the opening sequence. Here, the point is that an original commission did leave an audible trace, even if it did not completely shape the film’s accompaniment.
Rocky Mountains is another example of partial use. Carlos explains in her notes that the released material allows listeners to hear a longer passage than the one incorporated into the feature film. The difference between a complete piece and its extraction for the film affects how its form is perceived. A development that seems to lead to a resolution on the album can function in the film as an open-ended passage, cut off by the arrival of voices, another scene or a change of atmosphere.
The musically treated voice, electronic layers and variations in density need not behave like a melody for the audience to hum. They can give a space an uncanny quality without locating a source within the hotel. This does not justify attributing every hard-to-identify sound to Carlos. Concert repertoire, effects and the mix also create textures that blur the intuitive distinction between music and noise.
The final result allows us to hear coexistence rather than complete replacement. The original contributions do not disappear because Bartók, Ligeti or Penderecki are used, and the presence of their names does not prove that the commissioned score was used throughout. The specific approach depends on entrances, cuts and combinations. Gordon Stainforth’s work on the music edit helps explain how material from different sources came together to form a sound sequence that could be used with the images.
A later album is not another version of The Shining
The release of unused material changes its availability, not its historical status. It makes compositions that were not previously available in the same way possible to hear, allows ideas to be compared and brings into view work that the film’s release left out. It does not retrospectively alter the credits for each scene or turn every track into an authorised alternative soundtrack. A piece’s title may suggest its intention, but it does not certify an exact point of insertion.
It is also worth distinguishing the film from the audiovisual material around it. Carlos’s notes link certain compositions to the promotional trailer or to Vivian Kubrick’s making-of documentary. The fact that music accompanies images from the project in one of these materials does not mean it is part of the feature film. A trailer has its own duration and structure; a documentary may reuse a piece to describe the work on a film whose mix is different.
Listening to the discarded material is particularly useful when we focus on the choices it opens up, rather than inventing the choices that were made. One sustained texture might support continuity; another, with more pronounced changes, might break an action into sections. These are possibilities suggested by listening, not evidence of what Kubrick might have secretly wanted to do. The album documents musical proposals and their author’s explanation, while the film preserves a particular audiovisual solution.
The shared credit should be read with the same precision. It recognises creative work, but does not automatically assign every sound to one of two people or explain every reason for rejecting material. The story of Carlos and Elkind in The Shining offers a view of a production in which composing, choosing and editing were related activities, though not equivalent ones. To hear the complete result, the soundtrack guide places these contributions alongside the other material actually used.
References: Stanley Kubrick, The Shining (1980). Scenes exclusive to the US cut are identified in the text. Wendy Carlos, Rediscovering Lost Scores, volume 1, composer’s notes on her official website. Gordon Stainforth, The Shining music – Introductory note, July 2015, account by the music editor.
