Protagonists who lose control of their story

A protagonist can initiate an action and then lose the ability to determine its terms. Johnny, Barry and Bill have different plans, but their stories require us to distinguish between will, resources and control over other people’s responses.

Johnny Clay: organising roles does not eliminate other people’s initiative

In The Killing, Johnny devises a plan that depends on coordinated actions. The allocation of tasks turns different people into parts of a shared operation. This organisation makes it possible to anticipate steps and requirements, but it does not turn the participants into lifeless mechanisms. Each retains their own relationships, concerns and conversations, which can introduce information from outside the planned circuit.

The study of Johnny and the limits of control develops the heist. In terms of the protagonist’s structure, what matters is that his initial centrality comes from his organisational ability. He is the one who brings people together, makes decisions and proposes a future. The film can acknowledge this competence without granting him control over all the conditions that will make the outcome possible or impossible.

The threat need not come solely from a technical error. Someone might reveal something, reinterpret a promise or act because of a relationship that the plan had not accounted for. The audience gains access to some of these initiatives through scenes in which Johnny is absent. The narrative thus retains a broader scope than its organiser’s perspective.

When conditions change, the protagonist has to respond to problems he did not choose. Initiative turns into reaction. This does not mean he immediately stops making decisions, but his options are constrained by consequences and other people’s actions. The analysis distinguishes between continuing to act and retaining the ability to define the situation that needs to be resolved.

Barry: moving forward can increase dependency

Barry Lyndon traces a journey in which changing one’s position requires ties with people and institutions. The protagonist learns, improvises and seizes opportunities, but the resources he gains are not always at his disposal. A uniform, protection or marriage places him within systems with rules of their own. His rise can expand his capacity to act while multiplying the conditions he has to uphold.

The education and dependency of Redmond Barry allow us to examine this paradox without summarising his entire biography. The appearance of belonging does not guarantee lasting recognition. The character can influence his immediate behaviour, but cannot decide for himself how those who control titles, relationships or property will classify him. Ambition encounters limits that cannot be reduced to a lack of will.

The internal divisions of the film give the audience a perspective on the trajectory. Barry experiences particular opportunities, while the organisation of the narrative makes it possible to observe a broader direction. The difference between these two scales does not make every decision futile. It shows that an action can have local consequences and yet fail to secure the life project in which it was imagined.

Family relationships add goals that do not align exactly with social ambition. Caring, impressing, protecting or retaining a position can demand incompatible behaviours. The protagonist does not lose control only because an external force opposes him; he also loses it because his aims no longer fit together without conflict. The narrative can shift its focus when something that seemed a means acquires its own emotional consequences.

Bill: seeking answers can hand the journey over to others

In Eyes Wide Shut, Bill sets out into the city after a conversation that changes his view of his relationship with Alice. His journey is not organised around a plan as clearly defined as Johnny’s. Finding, exploring, checking or regaining a sense of security are impulses that shift with each encounter. The film preserves this fluidity without requiring a single goal to explain all his actions.

The character of Bill and his privileges allow us to recognise the resources he does have: money, credentials and familiarity with certain services. These means facilitate some responses, but do not make the rules of every space transparent. Gaining access can lead to another door, another condition or a situation in which someone else decides what he has to do.

The search becomes reactive when encounters raise new questions. Bill returns to places, asks for explanations and tries to verify accounts. Each step may depend on information that others choose to provide or withhold. The fact that the camera follows him does not mean that he directs the chain of events. His centrality to the audience and his authority within the represented world are two different things.

The power of institutions helps compare these cases without claiming that the same organisation lies behind them all. Johnny depends on collaborators; Barry on networks and social rules; Bill on access and partial accounts. The specific conflict emerges where someone else’s response alters the scope available to the protagonist. There is no need to classify all three stories under a single form of tragedy to observe this shift.

The beginnings can establish different relationships between intention and outcome. An explained plan creates expectations of execution; a biography opens up a trajectory; an intimate conversation sets a journey in motion. To follow the loss of initiative, we need to recognise what each beginning promised. This makes it possible to distinguish a frustrated goal from a transformed one, and a decision of one’s own from a response imposed by new circumstances.

Films discussed: Stanley Kubrick, The Killing (1956); Barry Lyndon (1975); Eyes Wide Shut (1999).

View all articles in Narrative, screenwriting and adaptation in Kubrick