The length of a source affects the work, but does not determine a proportionate running time for a film. A short story may require new connections; a novel may be concentrated around a single strand; a novella may extend the time devoted to encounters that pass quickly in the reading.
A long novel requires the selection of a trajectory, not just the cutting of episodes
The adaptation of Thackeray in Barry Lyndon shows that condensing a source does not simply mean removing pages until a workable running time is reached. Decisions must be made about which relationships will sustain the protagonist’s trajectory, which changes need a scene and which can be understood through their consequences. That selection establishes a new form of continuity between episodes, which the text develops in a different way.
The study of Thackeray and Barry Lyndon examines specific transformations. In terms of scale, removing one passage can increase the relative importance of another. A retained scene no longer occupies the same place within a different set of episodes. Its function must be assessed in the finished film, not solely by the presence of a similar situation in the book.
Cinema can also devote an extended duration to an action that written narrative summarises quickly. A duel, a wait or an exchange of glances needs time to unfold its positions and changes. Condensing the biography does not mean that every scene must be accelerated. Selection allows major omissions to be combined with close attention to moments that define relationships.
The balance between summary and experience therefore shifts in two directions. Periods are compressed and actions are extended. Measuring fidelity by the number of episodes retained overlooks this reorganisation. An element that is brief in the source can become the audiovisual centre of gravity; another, which is extensive, can be transformed into a comment, a transition or a visible consequence.
Dream Story: a short source can sustain extended encounters
Dream Story is a novella, not a screenplay that merely needs illustrating. Eyes Wide Shut uses a succession of encounters, returns and accounts whose duration on screen depends on the staging. Walking, waiting for a reply and negotiating an entrance can take time without necessarily adding a new adventure to the basic sequence of events.
The adaptation of Schnitzler makes it possible to distinguish an extension of duration from an expansion of the plot. A conversation can retain a recognisable function while unfolding through pauses, movements or resistance. The image makes perceptible the space separating the speakers; the sound lets us hear a hesitation. This material is not filler simply because it does not correspond to an additional sentence in the literary text.
Transposing the context also requires the construction of relationships that the source assumed would be familiar to its original readers. Forms of address, services and social spaces all play a part in that reconstruction. Dialogue that explains a world can provide information while organising the protagonist’s access. The adaptation decides how much needs to be made explicit and what can be understood through behaviour.
The point of view affects scale as much as the number of episodes. Keeping the audience close to a character may mean retaining their waits and checks. A version that showed all the actions of others in parallel would have a different length and a different distribution of knowledge. Expanding the visible world is not always the best way to preserve the experience of a source.
A short story as a starting point: expansion means creating new relationships
The development of A.I. began with Brian Aldiss’s short story Super-Toys Last All Summer Long and went through treatments that expanded its possibilities. The archive preserves working versions associated with different writers. This material documents a development process, not a film made by Kubrick. The film released in 2001 was directed by Steven Spielberg and should be distinguished from those earlier stages.
The development of A.I. and its treatments examines the contributions of its collaborators. In terms of scale, a short source may offer a situation, a relationship or a problem without containing all the connections needed for a feature film. Expanding it requires decisions about which events extend that question and which introduce a different direction. Adding duration is not simply a matter of describing what already exists in more detail.
The documentation for 2001 shows another relationship between the initial story, the novel and the screenplay. The collaboration between Kubrick and Clarke cannot be reduced to a linear translation of a completed book. Expansion and writing influenced one another during development. The example helps distinguish the starting source from the associated literary work: both can be part of the same project without occupying the same place in its history.
The literary adaptations by Kubrick bring together other changes of voice, structure and medium. The specific question here is what needs to be developed to sustain the chosen scale. A film needs temporal and spatial relationships, but can choose to leave certain explanations open. Expanding a source does not require resolving all its silences or turning every suggestion into an episode on screen.
Literary length therefore offers a starting point, not a conversion formula. Selection, condensation and expansion can coexist in the same adaptation. To describe the result, it is useful to identify which strand is followed, what is given more time and what new links allow the story to move from one situation to another. This comparison explains specific decisions without scoring the work against a supposed equivalence between pages and minutes.
Films discussed: Stanley Kubrick, Barry Lyndon (1975); Eyes Wide Shut (1999); 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968). Source texts: William Makepeace Thackeray, The Luck of Barry Lyndon; Arthur Schnitzler, Traumnovelle; Brian Aldiss, Super-Toys Last All Summer Long. University of the Arts London, Stanley Kubrick Archive, SK/18/3/1 and SK/18/3/1/3/11, treatments for A.I.; SK/12/1, development of 2001. Steven Spielberg, A.I. Artificial Intelligence (2001), credits.
View all articles in Narrative, screenwriting and adaptation in Kubrick
