From Kubrick to Spielberg: authorship and continuity in A.I.

A.I. cannot reliably be divided into a cold part attributed to Kubrick and a sentimental part attributed to Spielberg. The story of its making is supported by materials and testimony, not personality labels.

Spielberg directed a film connected to an earlier development

A.I. Artificial Intelligence, released in 2001, was directed by Steven Spielberg, who also wrote the screenplay. Ian Watson is credited with the screen story, and Brian Aldiss with the original story. These details identify the work that exists. Kubrick developed the project for years, but he did not direct a filmed version that Spielberg merely finished through editing.

Their relationship began before Kubrick’s death. Amblin’s production notes and Jan Harlan’s recollections describe discussions about the possibility of Spielberg directing. The association was therefore not simply a later decision to exploit a discovered archive. There was a working relationship around a shared project, although the proposals at the time did not immediately become a production.

After Kubrick’s death in 1999, the surviving development materials became part of the preparation for Spielberg’s film. Harlan described handing over narrative versions and a large amount of visual material. The handover provided earlier decisions and open questions. It was not an instruction to copy every document, nor did it remove the need to write, organise and make a specific film.

The development of the A.I. screenplay helps distinguish these stages. A treatment can establish a trajectory and still leave scenes, dialogue and transitions unresolved. Continuity of a story is not the same as identity of screenplay. Nor does rewriting prove that the earlier project disappeared: both claims require comparing specific elements rather than assigning a single authorship to the whole process.

An earlier idea can have a different effect when realised

The origin of a situation and the form it takes on screen are separate questions. The same scene can create a different impression through its duration, acting, lighting or music. So recognising an idea from Kubrick’s development is not enough to attribute every effect of its later realisation to him. The film organises earlier material through decisions made by Spielberg and his team.

The history of A.I.’s design and effects offers a tangible example of this transformed continuity. Some collaborators and visual proposals span both stages, but the 2001 production has identifiable technical responsibilities. The existence of an earlier drawing does not remove the work needed to turn it into a filmed space or a composited image. Nor does it prove that all its features were retained.

The ending is often used as an intuitive test of authorship. In his 2001 interview with Quint, Harlan said that Spielberg retained the distant time jump that was already part of the earlier project. This testimony contradicts the idea of automatically assigning that entire section to some supposed sentimentality added later. It does not, however, establish that every shot, line or musical decision had been set in advance by Kubrick.

Nor does a scene’s emotional quality function as an unmistakable signature. Sadness, the desire for comfort and unease can coexist within the same situation. One viewer may interpret it as a form of repair, while another sees it as the limited fulfilment of an impossible need. That difference in interpretation does not, by itself, divide the work between two directors. Production evidence is needed to turn an aesthetic impression into a historical attribution.

Respecting a project does not mean removing all intervention

Spielberg’s involvement meant taking on decisions that the earlier development could not resolve without an actual production. Casting performers, working with them and shaping the film are acts of filmmaking. Presenting them as mere execution would diminish cinema’s collaborative nature and turn a collection of preparations into a complete work that existed before its images.

At the same time, acknowledging Spielberg’s direction does not require treating Kubrick as a decorative presence in the credits or publicity. The project’s origins, its years of writing and the materials passed on are all part of a verifiable history. The task is to describe Kubrick’s contribution precisely: development, source selection, discussion of possibilities and preparation, rather than a posthumous direction that cannot be verified shot by shot.

The screenplays and treatments must also be read in light of their dates. An earlier document may contain an element that later changed, while a later one may come close to the film. Choosing only the document that fits a hypothesis produces a partial history. To claim continuity or change, it is necessary to identify which version is being compared and what specific aspect is under examination.

When assessing interpretations of Kubrick, it is worth avoiding an explanation of this relationship based solely on opposing personalities. That framework is convenient because it turns every decision into confirmation of a label: the dark elements would belong to one director, and the emotional ones to the other. The documentation shows a less tidy process, involving a literary source, several writers, discussions between directors and a team that ultimately brought the film before the cameras.

There is no Kubrick cut that would let us check how he might have directed A.I. The 2001 film can be studied for what it shows and for its production history, without filling that absence with an imagined version. The most precise comparison holds on to two compatible facts: Spielberg is the director and screenwriter of the feature film that was made, and that film grew out of a development to which Kubrick and his collaborators devoted substantial work.

References: Amblin, A.I. Artificial Intelligence (2001) production notes and credits. Jan Harlan, interview with Quint, Ain’t It Cool News, 29 October 2001, on narrative continuity and the ending; interview with Geoffrey Kleinman, DVD Talk, on the handover of materials. University of the Arts London, Stanley Kubrick Archive, SK/18/3.

View all articles in A.I.: Kubrick’s development and Spielberg’s film