Costume fittings and portrait in Aryan Papers

Images of Johanna ter Steege associated with Aryan Papers may seem like fragments of a missing film. Their documentary value lies elsewhere: they allow us to study Tania’s visual preparation and the options being compared.

The function of a photograph changes what we can claim

A film still belongs to an audiovisual continuity: it has images before and after it, a duration and a relationship with sound. A costume test photograph may exist to compare a garment, a pose or an aspect of the face. Although both may show an actor in character, they do not contain the same information. The first is part of a scene; the second may help decide how to prepare that scene before it exists.

The Stanley Kubrick Archive holds costume research for Tania under SK/18/2/3/6/5. The catalogue links fashion references from the 1930s and 1940s with tests of Johanna ter Steege and alternative outfits. This organisation is significant: the image is not isolated as an independent portrait, but associated with a selection task in the preparation of the character.

A complete interpretation of Tania cannot be inferred from it. A fixed expression invites readings that movement and voice could change. A viewer looking at a photograph may imagine fear, reserve or determination, but that impression is not equivalent to an instruction from the director or an emotion fixed in a sequence. Confusing the two turns the observer’s response into a fact about the shoot.

The pre-production of Aryan Papers provides the context for these tests. Their existence demonstrates a specific collaboration with the actor and work on appearance. It does not demonstrate that a feature film was shot, that all the options were approved or that the preserved material corresponds to a single stage without changes. The date, grouping and annotations are part of the evidence.

Clothing is prepared in relation to situations, not as a decorative catalogue

The scene-by-scene organisation described in the file allows us to understand the costumes as a response to narrative needs. Tania was not meant to exist only in an introductory portrait. The literary source places the character in changing circumstances of displacement and concealment. Preparing clothing for those situations means considering continuity, recognition and the relationship with the surroundings, even though the archive does not allow us to reconstruct every final decision.

Magazine and catalogue references provide information about what could be seen or bought in a particular period. The tests add the relationship with a specific body. This difference matters because a garment that is drawn, photographed for sale or worn by a performer does not work in the same way. Its drape, proportion and association with other pieces need to be examined in use, not just in the reference image.

Film costume can also affect social interpretation. An appearance may suggest belonging, respectability or a desire to go unnoticed. In Aryan Papers, that question is relevant because of Tania’s situation, but it does not justify assigning a fixed code to every dress without documentation. To claim that a choice relates to a particular scene, it must be possible to connect the two sets of material, not merely perceive an affinity.

Comparing alternatives serves a different purpose from accumulating attractive images. A test may help reject a solution that seemed suitable on paper. The preservation of a photograph does not mean it was automatically approved. The archive preserves part of the process, including possibilities that may never have reached the shoot. Reading every image as a final decision removes precisely the capacity of the collection to show revision and exploration.

From preparatory document to a later work about the archive

Photographs from Aryan Papers later circulated in exhibitions and publications. When a test changes context, it may acquire an aesthetic autonomy it did not have in its initial use. The layout on a page, the size of the reproduction or its association with a text all guide the viewer’s gaze. This new presentation may be legitimate, but it must be distinguished from the function for which the material was produced.

Unfolding the Aryan Papers, by Jane and Louise Wilson, is a different case of engagement with the archive. Animate Projects and the BFI commissioned this work in collaboration with the Kubrick archive. It is not a recovery of the film Kubrick did not shoot, but a later creation responding to his materials. The authorship and date of this intervention must remain visible so that the two works are not conflated.

The study of Kubrick’s photographic storytelling helps distinguish an isolated image from its relationship with a selection and a sequence. Although his photographs for Look and the tests for Aryan Papers served different purposes, both require us to consider the context in which they are presented. A visitor may encounter an image before learning where it came from and attribute an imagined narrative continuity to it. The catalogue, caption and identification of the type of test help correct that impression without diminishing the image’s interest. Knowing what we are looking at broadens the questions we can ask about it.

The preserved materials from unrealised projects do not form a complete substitute for the missing film either. They can be studied as objects with their own uses: researching, comparing, remembering or creating a new work. Each use produces different relationships between actor, character and viewer. Maciek’s perspective would be another matter, because a photograph of Tania does not automatically establish how she would have been seen within the story.

The most precise reading preserves both the real presence of a performer at work and the absence of a definitive production. Johanna ter Steege took part in tests; Kubrick did not establish Tania in a completed feature film. Between these two statements there is room to study choices of appearance, alternatives and the later circulation of the images, without turning documented preparation into a cinematic interpretation that never came to exist.

References: University of the Arts London, Stanley Kubrick Archive, costume research for Tania and tests of Johanna ter Steege, SK/18/2/3/6/5. Animate Projects, entry for Unfolding the Aryan Papers, by Jane and Louise Wilson, a work made in response to the archive. The descriptions do not assume that scenes from Kubrick’s feature film were shot.

View all articles in Aryan Papers: the adaptation Kubrick never filmed