The debate was not limited to deciding whether people liked the film. Reviews discussed how training, reporting in Vietnam and combat related to one another, and what kind of experience their differences produced.
Three reviews from their time, not a collective verdict
Roger Ebert published his review on 26 June 1987. He particularly valued the training and the performances of R. Lee Ermey and Vincent D’Onofrio, but felt the film as a whole lost cohesion and that the final section relied on familiar situations from war films. His comparison with other films about Vietnam located the problem in the strength and novelty of the experience on offer. His negative assessment of the film as a whole therefore coexisted with recognition of specific passages.
Adrian Martin dated his piece September 1987. He also acknowledged the strength of the training section, although his objection was not simply that what followed was inferior. He questioned a formal system that, in his view, built up tension only to release it, subordinating the story of Vietnam to that mechanism. He was interested in the verbal character of the training, but saw it as inseparable from an overly closed style of direction. The problem lay in how the film regulated the viewer’s response.
Ángel Fernández-Santos published Corsé de celuloide in El País on 24 January 1988. He distinguished three movements: training, the reporting section and combat. He felt their styles obstructed one another and made it difficult to become emotionally involved in the ending, while still recognising its visual skill. His criticism was directed at a unity he considered unsuccessful, not at an absolute lack of resources or accomplished moments.
The dates make it impossible to bring the three pieces together as if they belonged to the same opening-night session. They are texts from different editorial contexts and express individual arguments. Nor are they enough to reconstruct a worldwide reception. Their value lies in allowing a limited comparison: how three critics recognised similar divisions in the film and what expectations they formulated in response. This selection does not turn their points of agreement into a survey of all viewers.
Disagreement begins with deciding what should hold the sections together
The structure of training and war allows a first question: should the parts extend a continuous dramatic progression, or can their discontinuity produce meaning? A response in favour of the second option does not automatically refute the criticism. To do that, it would be necessary to show how specific relationships between voice, behaviour and experience work. Saying that the fragmentation is deliberate does not prove that it is convincing for every viewer, nor does it explain its effects on its own.
The strength of the first section can be used as a measure of the others or as a contrast with them. That difference in approach is decisive. Someone who expects the concentrated conflict between instructor and recruit to continue with equivalent intensity may experience the change as a loss. Someone who pays attention to the later dispersal may find another organisation of the narrative in it. Both readings start from visible elements; what changes is the relationship between those elements that they consider productive.
The leap from training to Vietnam makes the problem more precise. We do not see a transition that explains, step by step, the transformation of all the recruits. Some faces and names link the settings, but the intervening journeys are missing. That absence requires us to work with partial continuity. Critical debate can examine whether the ellipsis makes comparison more demanding or weakens involvement, without turning either response into an objective and universal description of the film’s reception.
The recognisable images of war films raise another distinction. A familiar situation can be read as tired repetition or as material given a new arrangement. The mere presence of a female sniper, a wounded comrade or an advance through ruins does not decide which reading is better. We need to consider duration, point of view and outcome. This distinction makes it possible to discuss a critic’s judgement without reducing it to a failure to understand the film.
It is also worth distinguishing technical recognition from emotion. Admiring the visual organisation of spaces does not require feeling close to the characters. A review can consider the camera work precise and, at the same time, judge the experience created by that precision to be insufficient. The language of craft and the language of involvement address different questions. Confusing them makes an argument seem contradictory when it may be carefully distinguishing between the two levels.
A later reassessment preserves the difference in dates
In the introduction added in 2022, Martin acknowledges that his initial reaction was reductive and depended on an opposition between open and closed cinema that he was using at the time. He retains the 1987 text, but says he would approach the film with greater sympathy. This does not make it one of his favourite Kubrick films. The reconsideration changes his position without erasing the earlier document or pretending that he always held the same view.
This approach makes it possible to observe a change in one person’s criteria. On its own, it does not prove that all criticism has travelled the same path or that the passage of time guarantees a better assessment. The reassessment is interesting precisely because it keeps both positions visible. Readers can identify which objections belong to the film’s release and what distance the author brings to them when returning to them decades later.
Institutional recognition belongs to another register. The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences nominated Stanley Kubrick, Michael Herr and Gustav Hasford for adapted screenplay at the 1988 ceremony. The nomination documents a decision by that institution; it neither cancels out the criticism cited nor amounts to a win. Nor can we infer how voters assessed each narrative section, because the list of nominations does not provide an individual argument comparable to a review.
The history of this discussion is more precise when it preserves authors, dates and questions. There may be agreement about the power of the training and disagreement about what that power demands of the rest of the film. An assessment can change without every reservation disappearing. Keeping these differences in view makes it possible to read the reviews as reasoned contributions, open to discussion, rather than use them as proof of the director’s intention or of a consensus not established by the selected documents.
References: Roger Ebert, Full Metal Jacket, 26 June 1987. Adrian Martin, Full Metal Jacket, September 1987, with an introduction from 2022. Ángel Fernández-Santos, Corsé de celuloide, El País, 24 January 1988. Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, record of the 1988 ceremony.
View all articles in Full Metal Jacket (1987): a guide to the film
