Kubrick during the development of One-Eyed Jacks

Kubrick worked on One-Eyed Jacks for months, but he did not direct the film released in 1961. His involvement was during development before filming, and accounts of his departure should not be confused with the credits of the finished work.

The collaboration took place before the film we know

One-Eyed Jacks was based on Charles Neider’s novel The Authentic Death of Hendry Jones. The American Film Institute catalogue traces a development process involving several writers and changes to the schedule. Kubrick joined as the intended director, but left the project before Brando took over the directing. The finished film has a longer backstory than its cast and final credits suggest.

In his 1969 interview with Joseph Gelmis, Kubrick recalled spending six months working on the screenplay with Marlon Brando and Calder Willingham. This describes his own involvement; it is not a claim that he directed scenes that were later retained. A considerable amount of time can be spent writing without the director having filmed any narrative footage.

The screenwriting process helps distinguish responsibilities that summarised accounts often lump together. Developing a structure, discussing characters and preparing to direct are related tasks, but they are not the same. Kubrick’s presence at that stage explains his historical association with the title; it does not automatically change who directed the film that followed, nor make him a credited writer of every scene.

The credits for the 1961 film name Marlon Brando as director and Guy Trosper and Calder Willingham as screenwriters. These are the reference point for attributing the finished work. The earlier development can be studied alongside them, but not substituted for them on the assumption that a famous figure must have been responsible for the images that most interest viewers.

Accounts of the departure should remain attributed

Kubrick told Gelmis that the relationship ended amicably, a few weeks before Brando began directing. That account comes from a retrospective interview with one of the participants. It can be cited as Kubrick’s version without treating it as proof that there were no disagreements in the preceding months. A parting described publicly as cordial can still follow a period of tense work.

The AFI cites reports from November 1958 that offer another level of evidence. The official explanation referred to a scheduling conflict and Kubrick’s work on Lolita; at the same time, the press mentioned creative differences. It is important to preserve the distinction between an announced reason and the rumours in circulation. Those rumours should not be turned into a reconstructed confrontation scene with invented dialogue.

The phrases ‘he was fired’ and ‘he left’ can condense different accounts of the same professional outcome. Choosing between them requires a specific source and an assessment of what it knows. It is not enough to pick the more dramatic version because it fits an image of Brando or Kubrick. The documentation supports the fact of Kubrick’s departure and the context of disagreement; more detailed private circumstances require equally precise attribution.

The relationship between Kubrick and Kirk Douglas offers another example of negotiation between acting, production and directing, but does not by itself explain what happened with Brando. An actor who also controls aspects of production and an intended director may disagree over characters, the text and authority. That general possibility does not prove what was said in each discussion about One-Eyed Jacks. It helps distinguish a documented professional disagreement from an invented psychological explanation.

The finished shots are not evidence of what Kubrick would have done

Brando’s film can be analysed through its landscapes, its length and the relationships between its characters, but those qualities should not be attributed to Kubrick on the basis of resemblance. A wide shot or a prolonged wait is not an exclusive signature. To establish a specific contribution from the earlier development, one would need to connect an identifiable instruction with the decision made on screen, while still distinguishing the idea from its execution.

Nor can an alternative version be reconstructed simply by removing from the film whatever seems most characteristic of Brando. Directing affects performance, staging and the selection of material throughout the process. A film shot by Kubrick would not necessarily have been the same set of images with different editing. That hypothesis goes beyond what the surviving sources can demonstrate.

The case differs from Burning Secret, where Kubrick’s project produced writing but no feature film made under that production. One-Eyed Jacks has a subsequent film connected to its development, with established responsibilities. The comparison helps explain why not all titles associated with the director should be grouped together in an undifferentiated list of lost films.

It also differs from Lunatic at Large, whose original state is associated with a treatment. In one case, a collaboration was interrupted but went on to a shoot under another director; in the other, the material did not reach the same point during Kubrick’s time. The historical category should follow the evidence for each project, not the expectations its title may create.

Kubrick’s verifiable contribution to One-Eyed Jacks belongs to months of development and discussion before his departure. Brando subsequently took on the directing, as confirmed by the credits and the film. Keeping both statements allows the earlier work to be recognised without claiming the finished film, and preserves the different accounts of the disagreement without turning them into a single anecdote more certain than the sources allow.

References: Stanley Kubrick, interview by Joseph Gelmis (1969), published in The Film Director as Superstar (1970). American Film Institute, One-Eyed Jacks (1961) entry, production chronology based on 1958 press reports. The Criterion Collection, One-Eyed Jacks credits: directed by Marlon Brando; screenplay by Guy Trosper and Calder Willingham.

View all articles in Other Scripts and Projects by Stanley Kubrick