Stephen King’s disagreement with the film centres on how it transforms the family and the emotional experience of the story. His statements are an assessment by the author whose work was adapted, not a neutral description of how all audiences should view it.
An objection to Jack’s trajectory
In the 2014 interview Andy Greene conducted with him for Rolling Stone, Stephen King again explained his disagreement with Kubrick’s The Shining. One of his objections concerns Jack’s journey: he believes the novel lets us get to know a man who tries to do the right thing before deteriorating, while the film conveys a threat that is already present from the outset. This statement describes King’s reading and the kind of transformation he feels is missing.
The difference can be considered by comparing the techniques of both works without automatically adopting his assessment. The novel gives extended access to the character’s memories, frustrations and efforts. The film has to distribute that information across performances, conversations and selected scenes. Jack Nicholson can convey a noticeable unease before Jack commits the more overt violence. Whether that effect is a loss or an expressive choice depends on the criteria used to compare the adaptation.
King’s objection, then, is not simply about counting how many episodes from the book have disappeared. It concerns the experience of accompanying a downfall. For the deterioration to be tragic in the way the novel proposes, readers need to recognise earlier possibilities that gradually close off. A film that makes viewers suspicious of the character sooner creates a different expectation: the audience may await the manifestation of a threat it has already sensed in his earliest interactions.
The theme of alcohol and Jack’s responsibility helps clarify part of that difference. Each medium gives the character’s history and inner struggle a different degree of attention. However, the comparison does not require us to diagnose the character or decide that a more expansive portrayal is always better. The question is what information underpins each emotional connection with him, and when readers or viewers receive it.
Wendy and the debate about vulnerability
King also questions Wendy’s portrayal in that interview. His criticism is aimed at a character he sees as reduced too heavily to reaction and fear, compared with the woman he had written. That assessment has been repeated in some very harsh terms. There is no need to repeat put-downs as if they were facts about Shelley Duvall or her acting ability in order to examine it. The character, the performance and the novelist’s opinion are different things.
The film offers elements that make it possible to discuss the scope of that reading. Wendy prepares food, cares for Danny, manages resources and makes decisions when their living situation becomes dangerous. Those actions do not eliminate her fear or put her in a position of control. They do, however, make it impossible to describe her solely through an isolated vocal reaction. Wendy Torrance’s trajectory reveals a combination of vulnerability and agency that a provocative catchphrase can oversimplify.
The disagreement can be put more precisely: what relationship does the film establish between fear, dependence and the ability to act? One viewer may feel that the portrayal of suffering limits the character; another may focus on how she persists and responds from a deeply unequal position. Neither reading should automatically be attributed to everyone who has read the novel or seen the film.
It is also important to distinguish fidelity from ethical assessment. Pointing out that Wendy differs from her counterpart in the book is a textual comparison. Arguing that the change is impoverishing or misogynistic adds a judgement that must be supported by reference to scenes and relationships. King is particularly well placed to comment on his own literary creation, but that does not make every aesthetic disagreement a verifiable fact of the same kind as a credit or a release date.
Fire, ice and two experiences of closure
In 2014, King summed up another difference by contrasting a work he considers emotionally warm with one he sees as cold, linking this to their fire and ice endings. The metaphor expresses an assessment. The physical elements of each work’s ending can be compared, but emotional temperature is not an objectively measurable property. It describes how the author relates to the adaptation.
The changed ending affects more than the setting of a death. The novel and the film distribute destruction, survival and the hotel’s persistence differently. These choices shape the sense of closure. One resolution may concentrate the conflict in a more conclusive physical event; another may allow a final image to reopen questions about belonging and time. The article on the novel’s adaptation compares these techniques without requiring either work to be treated as the standard for the other.
King’s objections are not the whole story of the film’s reception in 1980, nor do they represent a collective opinion that remained uniform afterwards. In his review at the time of release, preserved by Sight and Sound, Richard Combs was interested in aspects of exaggerated performance and spatial organisation that can be assessed from a different perspective. The disagreement shows that the same choice can be judged by different criteria: psychological development, how well the horror works, performance or the relationship with the literary source.
It is worth keeping the date of the statements in mind. The 2014 interview documents what King argued at the time; without checking, it should not be turned into a record of everything he said before or after. Nor does it justify inventing a reconciliation or a broader personal animosity than his comments about the work support. The history of critical reception of The Shining calls for dated texts and identifiable arguments, not a dispute reduced to two camps.
Read with that precision, King’s criticisms help us recognise what he considers his own narrative project and which changes he finds unacceptable. Viewers may agree with him, dispute his views or prefer the film for different reasons. What is best avoided is replacing analysis with either the novelist’s authority or the director’s reputation. The scenes allow us to test the claims without turning a difference of opinion into a verdict that everyone must accept.
References: Stanley Kubrick, The Shining (1980). Scenes exclusive to the US cut are identified in the text. Stephen King, The Shining, 1977; Stanley Kubrick, The Shining, 1980. Andy Greene, ‘Stephen King: The Rolling Stone Interview’, 2014. Richard Combs, review of The Shining at the time of its release, republished by Sight and Sound/BFI in 2017.
