The Shining’s second unit: aerial landscapes and interiors

The landscapes in The Shining and the interior sequences did not come from a single team working in one place. The credits and participants’ accounts make it possible to distinguish responsibilities without attributing every shot on the basis of a general credit.

What the film’s credits tell us

The credits list MacGillivray Freeman Films for helicopter cinematography and second-unit work. Douglas Milsome is credited for second-unit cinematography and for focus and lighting on the first unit. John Alcott is listed as director of photography. These titles identify different roles; none makes it possible to automatically assign every shot to the people responsible.

A second unit is not necessarily a team dedicated to images that play a secondary role in the story. It can capture material that occupies a very prominent place in the finished film. In The Shining, the landscape introduces the world in which the family will be isolated. Its narrative weight depends on its selection and editing, not on whether it was shot by the unit working with the principal actors indoors.

An individual account adds a level of detail that a collective credit cannot provide. In 2012, Jeff Blyth told Take One that he operated an aerial rig with two Arriflex cameras and a video reference. He placed this work in Glacier National Park, Montana, and described the footage being sent to England without being developed. His account helps identify a specific contribution within the credited company.

The distinction also guards against over-attribution. One person describing particular flights does not prove that they shot every aerial view used. Blyth specifically noted that a shot of the arrival at the hotel did not belong to his unit. The scope of a statement can be as informative as its content: it documents a contribution without turning it into sole authorship of a sequence assembled from different materials.

Instructions, locations and decisions about the footage

Blyth recalled that the initial brief focused on the Volkswagen’s first journey to the hotel. Another British unit was preparing footage of the family’s journey and backgrounds for scenes inside the car. He also explained that the finished edit changed the planned allocation of some images. A shot’s role in the film does not necessarily match exactly the purpose for which it was filmed.

In his interview for the Diving Pioneers and Innovators series, Greg MacGillivray recalls conversations with Kubrick and reviewing the footage sent to London. He also says the director was interested in the relationship between the progression of the aerial shots and other movements in the film. This is a recollection of collaboration, not proof that Kubrick was physically present during those flights.

The two accounts describe different working positions. Blyth explains his operation and the contact he personally had; MacGillivray recalls his communication with the director. Their statements should not be merged into an imagined group conversation. Nor should a general instruction be turned into literal remote control of every frame. The distance between teams makes it necessary to distinguish the project’s direction, work on location and later selection.

The production geography does not match the geography of the story, either. The story places the Overlook in Colorado; the work Blyth describes includes Montana and mentions another unit’s activity at Timberline Lodge, Oregon. The interiors were built for filming in England. Bringing this material together creates a continuous cinematic place, but does not make the real locations a physically connected route.

How the units come together in the finished image

The relationship between exterior and interior requires compatibility, even when the methods differ. A building’s apparent size, the direction of movement and the light can help make a cut seem to lead to the same place. This follows from the editing and shared visual decisions. There is no need to assume that every crew member knew in advance where all the shots would ultimately appear.

Backgrounds intended for scenes inside the car illustrate another type of material. They are not the same as filming the actors speaking or getting an aerial shot of the vehicle. Each task provides different information that can later be combined. production organisation includes these contributions without reducing them to the romantic image of a director personally carrying out every camera operation.

It is also worth distinguishing the challenges of an exterior unit from those of working among walls. lenses and enclosed sets shape the crew’s movement differently from a landscape shot. An effective solution in one of these contexts does not automatically explain the other. The continuity the viewer perceives is the result of bringing them together, not proof that their methods were identical.

The opening of The Shining examines the threat these images create alongside the music. Here, the question is who produced the material and what allows us to say so. The credits establish general responsibilities; the accounts define specific work; the film lets us observe the result. To examine a possible discontinuity in the Overlook, we would still need to compare identified images: knowing how the units were allocated does not in itself prove that an error exists or that every difference is intentional.

References: Stanley Kubrick, The Shining / El resplandor (1980). The Criterion Collection, The Shining, production credits. Gavin Midgley, ‘Interview with Jeff Blyth’, Take One, 10 December 2012. Interview with Greg MacGillivray, Diving Pioneers and Innovators, International Training / TDI-SDI.

View all articles in The Shining (1980): film guide