The Torrances’ television: company and images of violence

Television appears as a source of stories and a domestic activity. What Danny says he knows and what Wendy watches with him help distinguish these uses from the boy’s supernatural visions.

What Danny says he learned before arriving

During the drive to the Overlook, the family’s conversation turns to the Donner Party and cannibalism. Danny says he knows about it from television. The reference does not prove that the boy understands every aspect of what he mentions, but it changes the exchange between the adults. Protecting him by avoiding a subject becomes less straightforward when he himself says he has already received information another way.

Jack uses that response to shut down or sidestep Wendy’s reluctance. Television then functions as an indirect domestic authority: it makes it possible to claim that something is already part of the child’s knowledge. The set is not in the car, and we do not see the programme being referred to. What the scene presents is a conversation about its effect, not visual evidence of what was broadcast or how Danny interpreted it when he watched it.

The difference between knowing a word and assimilating an experience leaves room for unease. Danny can name an extreme behaviour with the matter-of-factness of someone recalling information. The adults, by contrast, implicitly debate what can be said in front of him. The scene does not require us to conclude that all television is harmful. It makes visible a disagreement about childhood and about who controls the stories that enter the family conversation.

The context of the journey matters because this information appears before the winter isolation. Images received outside the hotel accompany Danny as the family moves from one place to another. Not everything the boy knows comes from the Overlook or from his ability to perceive things. The Torrances’ conversation in the car lets us observe this mixture of a story being told, media recollection and tension between those responding to the questions.

Watching a film in an overly large space

The US cut includes Wendy and Danny in front of a television in one of the hotel’s rooms. The film identifiable on the screen is Summer of ’42, directed by Robert Mulligan and released in 1971; this identification is noted in a study published by Senses of Cinema in 2020. The detail lets us name the excerpt without turning it into a plot connection between the two works of fiction. The Torrances are watching a work that exists in their world, not proof that they share its story.

The screen occupies a small part of a spacious room. Wendy and Danny focus their attention on that point, temporarily turning a public area into a place to relax. The scale of the lounge remains all around them, even though their activity is as ordinary as watching a film at home. The contrast between the size of the building and the modest scale of the family’s occupation creates a kind of loneliness different from that of an empty corridor.

The scene also shows a way of being together that does not require constant conversation. Television lets them sit together, focused on something outside their immediate relationship. When Danny asks to go and get a toy, the exchange takes place within this shared activity. Wendy’s response also takes account of Jack, who is resting in another area. In this way, a leisure activity reveals how permissions and silences are distributed within the family’s temporary home.

There is no need to reconstruct the entire plot of the film on television to analyse this use. The choice of excerpt may invite comparisons, but its domestic function is apparent before any are made. The set provides company and a shared focus. The article about the hotel turned into a home places this scene alongside the kitchen, the apartment and the large rooms the family uses in different ways.

Received images, visions and the limits of interpretation

Television establishes a relatively recognisable viewing situation: there is a screen, content being broadcast and people watching it. Danny’s visions are not always arranged in this way. They can interrupt an activity or appear without another character having the same access to them. Equating the two phenomena would erase a narrative distinction: receiving a story from a device is one thing; experiencing images whose source the film leaves open is another.

The distinction does not rule out comparing them. In both cases, Danny encounters information that may exceed what the adults think he knows. But the story distributes the possibility of verifying it differently. Wendy can watch the same screen as her son; she cannot enter all his perceptions in the same way. Danny’s relationship with the shining preserves that inequality of knowledge without reducing it to a variation on watching television.

It is also worth distinguishing an observation from a hypothesis about the set. The fact that a copy does not let us follow a cable to a power point does not prove that the device is supernatural. The framing may exclude connections, conceal them or simply not make them relevant information. Technical documentation would be needed to assert a filming method. The absence of a visible detail is not enough to turn a domestic activity into an all-encompassing explanation of the hotel.

Television also introduces a time that is separate from the Torrances’. The programme or film continues with its own succession of voices while the family is held in the wait for winter. This contrast can make the company feel impersonal: there is conversation in the room, but not necessarily anyone responding to those listening. The screen fills an interval without resolving the communication difficulties between the building’s inhabitants.

The reference in the car and the scene in the lounge therefore allow us to examine two specific functions. In one, television appears as the stated source of knowledge; in the other, it structures a shared activity. Neither requires us to diagnose the child or look for a code in every broadcast image. Paying attention to who watches, who speaks and who leaves offers a more verifiable reading of television’s presence in the Torrances’ lives.

References: Stanley Kubrick, The Shining (1980). Scenes exclusive to the US cut are identified in the text. Geoffrey Cocks, Senses of Cinema, “Cinema and Me: Family and History Through Film References in Kubrick’s The Shining”, 2020; The Shining, US cut.

View all articles in The Shining (1980): film guide